

Foreign Doctor Medical Negligence in Turkey 2026: Criminal Liability, Malpractice Investigations, Articles 85 and 89, Professional Liability Board Permission, Patient Death, Imprisonment and Defense Rights
Can a foreign doctor face criminal prosecution for medical negligence in Turkey? Learn about negligent homicide, negligent injury, medical malpractice investigations, the Professional Liability Board, expert reports, informed consent, criminal penalties, professional licensing, work permits, and immigration consequences under Turkish law in 2026.
Foreign doctors practicing medicine in Turkey may face serious criminal allegations when patients experience injury, permanent disability, complications, or death following medical treatment. These allegations may arise in public hospitals, private healthcare institutions, university hospitals, specialist clinics, and other legally authorized medical facilities.
A foreign surgeon may be accused of causing a patient’s death following an operation. A foreign anesthesiologist may face allegations concerning complications during anesthesia. A foreign emergency physician may be investigated after a delayed diagnosis allegedly contributes to serious injury. Another foreign doctor may be accused of prescribing inappropriate medication or failing to monitor a patient’s deteriorating condition.
These circumstances raise an important legal question: When can a foreign doctor be held criminally responsible for medical negligence in Turkey, and what must prosecutors prove?
Turkish criminal law distinguishes between an unfortunate medical outcome, an accepted complication, professional negligence, and conduct that satisfies the elements of a criminal offense.
A patient experiencing complications after treatment does not automatically establish medical malpractice. Similarly, a patient’s death following surgery does not automatically mean that the treating physician committed negligent homicide.
The prosecution must examine whether the doctor breached an applicable professional duty of care, whether the alleged conduct was negligent, and whether the breach legally caused the patient’s injury or death.
Articles 85 and 89 of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 are particularly important. Article 85 regulates causing death through negligence, while Article 89 concerns causing bodily injury through negligence.
Article 22 establishes the general framework for negligence, including conscious negligence.
Foreign doctors may also benefit from special procedural safeguards concerning investigation permission under Additional Article 18 of Law No. 3359 on Fundamental Healthcare Services.
Foreign nationality does not automatically increase criminal liability or remove the procedural protections available to healthcare professionals under Turkish law.
However, foreign doctors may face additional consequences involving professional authorization, employment contracts, work permits, residence status, and possible immigration proceedings.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that medical negligence allegations require careful examination of patient records, clinical standards, expert reports, causation, investigation permission, and the precise statutory offense.
Yes. Foreign doctors may face criminal liability where the statutory elements of a criminal offense are established.
For example, a foreign surgeon may be accused of negligently causing a patient’s death during medical treatment.
The prosecutor must determine whether the doctor breached an applicable professional duty and whether that breach caused the death.
However, an adverse medical outcome does not automatically establish criminal negligence.
The authorities must distinguish medically recognized complications from preventable harm caused by a breach of professional standards.
The prosecution must prove the relevant criminal elements according to the applicable legal standard.
Medical negligence generally concerns a failure to exercise the care and attention required by applicable professional standards.
For example, a doctor may fail to recognize a serious medical condition despite clinical findings requiring further investigation.
However, criminal liability depends on more than identifying an error in retrospect.
The prosecution must establish the applicable standard of care, the alleged breach, the required mental element, and a legally sufficient causal connection to the harmful outcome.
Medical practice involves uncertainty, and an unsuccessful treatment does not necessarily establish negligence.
The assessment should consider the circumstances and medical knowledge reasonably available at the relevant time.
Medical malpractice involves conduct that breaches applicable professional standards and may give rise to legal responsibility.
A medical complication is an adverse event that may occur despite appropriate treatment and reasonable professional care.
For example, a patient may develop a recognized postoperative complication even though the surgeon followed accepted medical standards.
The complication alone does not automatically establish criminal liability.
However, a doctor’s failure to identify or appropriately respond to a developing complication may raise separate questions concerning negligence.
The distinction requires careful examination of medical records and expert evidence.
The principal provisions concerning negligent medical harm are Articles 22, 85, and 89 of the Turkish Penal Code.
Article 22 regulates negligence and conscious negligence.
Article 85 concerns causing death through negligence.
Article 89 concerns causing bodily injury through negligence.
Depending on the alleged conduct, other provisions may become relevant, including offenses involving intentional acts, unlawful medical activities, or falsification of records.
However, the prosecutor must identify the precise offense rather than treating every medical complaint as negligent homicide or negligent injury.
Yes. Article 85 applies where a person’s death is legally attributable to negligent conduct.
For example, a foreign anesthesiologist may be accused of failing to respond appropriately to a critical complication during surgery.
The prosecution must establish the applicable duty of care, negligent breach, and causal relationship between the conduct and death.
However, the fact that a patient died during or after medical treatment does not automatically establish negligent homicide.
Medical expert evidence may be necessary to determine whether the doctor’s conduct departed from accepted professional standards.
Article 85(1) provides imprisonment of two to six years for causing the death of another person through negligence.
Where the negligent conduct causes multiple deaths or causes death together with injuries to other persons, Article 85(2) provides imprisonment of two to fifteen years.
For example, a medical negligence allegation involving one patient’s death may require examination under Article 85(1).
However, the statutory penalty applies only where the prosecution establishes the offense.
The actual sentence depends on the facts, degree of negligence, and applicable sentencing provisions.
A patient’s death does not automatically result in imprisonment of the treating doctor.
Yes. Article 89 concerns bodily injury caused through negligence.
For example, a foreign physician may be accused of causing a patient’s permanent nerve injury through an avoidable medical error.
The prosecutor must establish the alleged breach of professional care and the legally relevant causal connection to the injury.
The applicable penalty depends on the statutory form of injury and any aggravating consequences.
A recognized complication that occurred despite appropriate medical care should not automatically be treated as negligent injury.
Following amendments effective in December 2025, the basic form of negligent injury under Article 89(1) carries imprisonment of four months to two years or a judicial fine.
The punishment may increase where the injury causes consequences specified in Article 89, such as certain permanent impairments or other serious harm.
For example, a patient may suffer a lasting impairment allegedly caused by negligent treatment.
The court must determine the correct statutory classification and whether the criminal elements are established.
The applicable penalty should be assessed under the law governing the date of the offense and relevant rules concerning more favorable criminal legislation.
Article 22 distinguishes ordinary negligence from conscious negligence.
Conscious negligence may arise where a person foresees a harmful consequence but proceeds on the assumption that it will not occur.
For example, a doctor may recognize a serious and avoidable risk associated with a medical procedure but disregard an essential precaution.
However, the existence of a known medical risk does not automatically establish conscious negligence.
Medical procedures often involve recognized risks that remain acceptable when appropriate safeguards are followed.
The prosecution must establish the specific mental elements required by Article 22.
Where conscious negligence is established, the punishment is increased by one-third to one-half.
Potentially. A diagnostic error may raise criminal liability where it constitutes a negligent breach of professional care and causes legally relevant harm.
For example, a foreign emergency physician may fail to investigate symptoms that reasonably required urgent testing.
However, a later diagnosis differing from the initial assessment does not automatically prove negligence.
The prosecutor must consider the symptoms, available diagnostic methods, urgency, medical resources, and clinical standards applicable at the time.
The relevant question is whether the doctor acted below the required standard of care, not whether the diagnosis was ultimately correct.
Yes, potentially.
For example, a foreign physician may be accused of failing to recognize a serious infection until the patient’s condition deteriorates.
The prosecution must establish whether the delay resulted from a negligent breach of the applicable professional duty.
It must also determine whether the delay caused or materially contributed to the legally relevant injury or death.
A delay alone does not automatically establish criminal responsibility.
Expert evidence may be essential to distinguish an unavoidable diagnostic difficulty from negligent conduct.
Yes, where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
For example, a foreign surgeon may be accused of performing an operation contrary to accepted surgical standards.
The authorities may examine operative reports, anesthesia records, monitoring data, postoperative care, and expert findings.
However, surgery carries inherent risks, and a patient’s death does not automatically establish malpractice.
The prosecution must prove the alleged negligent conduct and causal connection.
A criminal investigation should not substitute an unfavorable outcome for evidence of professional fault.
Potentially. Anesthesiologists have professional responsibilities concerning preoperative assessment, medication administration, monitoring, and appropriate responses to complications.
For example, a foreign anesthesiologist may be accused of failing to recognize a critical change in a patient’s condition.
The prosecutor must examine the applicable clinical standards and available medical evidence.
However, an anesthesia complication does not automatically establish negligence.
The defendant’s conduct must be assessed in light of the actual circumstances.
Potentially. A medication error may lead to criminal liability where the statutory elements of negligent injury or negligent homicide are established.
For example, a foreign physician may prescribe a medication despite a documented contraindication.
The prosecutor may examine whether the prescription breached applicable medical standards and caused harm.
However, a patient experiencing an adverse drug reaction does not automatically establish malpractice.
The distinction between an unforeseeable reaction and a preventable prescribing error may require expert analysis.
Yes, potentially.
For example, a doctor may be accused of failing to arrange appropriate monitoring after a high-risk procedure.
The prosecutor must determine whether monitoring was required under the applicable medical standards.
The authorities must also examine whether the alleged omission caused the patient’s injury or death.
However, responsibility for monitoring may be shared among healthcare professionals.
The individual duties of the doctor, nurses, and other personnel must be assessed separately.
Yes, where the evidence supports allegations against more than one healthcare professional.
For example, a patient may receive treatment from an emergency physician, surgeon, anesthesiologist, and intensive care specialist.
The prosecutor may examine whether each professional breached a relevant duty of care.
However, criminal responsibility is personal under Article 20 of the Turkish Penal Code.
Participation in the patient’s treatment does not automatically establish that every doctor committed an offense.
The prosecution must determine individual conduct, negligence, and causation.
Not automatically.
For example, a nurse may administer medication incorrectly despite receiving an appropriate prescription.
The prosecutor must examine the responsibilities of the nurse, treating doctor, and supervising personnel.
A doctor may have relevant supervisory duties in certain circumstances, but professional status alone does not establish criminal responsibility for another person’s mistake.
The prosecution must identify the doctor’s own alleged negligent conduct.
The allocation of duties and the actual clinical circumstances are important.
Not automatically. Informed consent is an important part of lawful medical practice, but it does not authorize negligent treatment.
For example, a patient may consent to surgery after being informed of recognized complications.
If a complication occurs despite appropriate care, criminal negligence may not be established.
However, if the doctor breaches accepted professional standards, the patient’s consent does not automatically eliminate responsibility.
The prosecution must distinguish consent to a recognized medical risk from consent to conduct that falls below the required standard of care.
Potentially. Medical treatment without legally valid consent may raise separate legal questions.
For example, a foreign doctor may perform a non-emergency procedure without obtaining the patient’s required consent.
The authorities may examine the circumstances, medical necessity, applicable consent rules, and the nature of the intervention.
However, lack of consent does not automatically establish negligent homicide or negligent injury.
Different criminal provisions may become relevant depending on the facts.
The legal assessment must distinguish consent violations from negligent treatment and intentional unlawful conduct.
For qualifying medical acts, yes. Additional Article 18 of Law No. 3359 establishes a special investigation-permission procedure.
It covers doctors, dentists, and other healthcare professionals working in specified public and private healthcare institutions for medical acts involving examination, diagnosis, and treatment.
The Professional Liability Board within the Ministry of Health is responsible for granting investigation permission under this framework.
However, personnel subject to the separate procedure under Article 53 of the Higher Education Law are excluded from this particular mechanism.
The rule concerns the nature of the medical activity and institutional position, not simply the doctor’s nationality.
The Ministry of Health reaffirmed the significance of this permission requirement in a public announcement dated July 17, 2026. hhgmizlemedb.saglik.gov.tr+1
The Professional Liability Board is established within the Turkish Ministry of Health.
Its responsibilities include deciding whether investigation permission should be granted for qualifying allegations concerning medical examination, diagnosis, and treatment.
For example, a foreign surgeon working in a private hospital may become the subject of a malpractice complaint.
Where Additional Article 18 applies, the competent authorities must follow the statutory permission procedure.
The Board’s decision concerns permission to investigate; it is not a criminal conviction or a final determination of malpractice.
The prosecutor and criminal court retain their respective responsibilities once the applicable procedural requirements are satisfied.
Yes. Additional Article 18 expressly includes healthcare professionals working in private healthcare institutions within its scope, subject to the statutory conditions.
For example, a foreign doctor employed by a private hospital may be accused of negligent treatment.
Where the allegation concerns medical examination, diagnosis, or treatment within the provision, the special permission procedure may apply.
However, the procedure does not automatically cover every alleged offense committed by a doctor.
Conduct unrelated to the covered medical activities may require a different legal assessment.
The Ministry of Health’s 2026 announcement expressly confirms that both public and private healthcare professionals are covered by the relevant permission mechanism. hhgmizlemedb.saglik.gov.tr
Not always. Additional Article 18 excludes healthcare professionals subject to the investigation procedure under Article 53 of the Higher Education Law No. 2547.
For example, a doctor working at a state university hospital may fall within a different statutory investigation framework.
A doctor working at a private hospital or foundation university institution may be subject to Additional Article 18 where its requirements are satisfied.
The correct procedure depends on the doctor’s legal employment status and the relevant institution.
The prosecution must identify the applicable authorization mechanism before proceeding.
Where Additional Article 18 applies, the required investigation permission is a procedural prerequisite.
For example, a malpractice complaint may concern a foreign doctor employed at a private hospital.
The authorities must determine whether the allegation falls within the special permission framework.
If the required permission has not been obtained, ordinary criminal investigative steps cannot simply proceed as though the requirement did not exist.
However, the precise procedural consequences depend on the stage and nature of the proceedings.
The Ministry of Health’s July 2026 guidance emphasizes that the authorization requirement must be respected before the covered criminal investigation proceeds. hhgmizlemedb.saglik.gov.tr
Yes. Additional Article 18 provides for objections against decisions of the Professional Liability Board before the Ankara Regional Administrative Court.
For example, a foreign doctor may wish to challenge a decision granting permission to investigate.
Conversely, a complainant may challenge a refusal of permission where legally entitled.
The applicable objection period and procedural requirements must be examined promptly under the relevant legislation.
An objection should address the legal and factual basis of the permission decision.
The Board’s decision is distinct from the eventual determination of criminal guilt.
The prosecution must establish the statutory elements of the alleged offense.
For negligent injury or negligent homicide, this generally requires examination of the applicable duty of care, breach, causation, and the legally relevant mental element.
For example, a foreign doctor may be accused of failing to respond to a patient’s deteriorating condition.
The prosecutor must determine whether the doctor had the relevant duty, whether the conduct breached accepted standards, and whether the breach caused the injury or death.
The prosecution must also consider evidence supporting the doctor’s defense.
A medical complication alone does not satisfy every element of criminal negligence.
Causation is a central issue.
For example, a patient may die following treatment for a serious pre-existing illness.
The prosecutor must determine whether the alleged negligent act or omission legally caused the death.
It is insufficient merely to establish that the doctor treated the patient before the adverse outcome.
Medical expert reports may examine whether appropriate treatment would have prevented the harm or materially altered the relevant outcome.
However, causation must ultimately be assessed according to the applicable criminal-law standards.
Yes. Medical malpractice cases frequently require specialist expert evidence.
For example, the prosecutor may request an assessment concerning whether the treatment complied with accepted medical standards.
The report may address clinical decisions, patient monitoring, causation, and the significance of complications.
However, an expert report does not automatically determine criminal guilt.
The court must evaluate the report alongside other evidence.
The defense may challenge incomplete, contradictory, or inadequately reasoned findings.
Yes. The Forensic Medicine Institute may provide expert assessments in appropriate criminal proceedings.
For example, a foreign surgeon may be investigated following a patient’s death.
The competent authority may request an expert opinion concerning the alleged medical error and causation.
However, the defense may examine whether the relevant medical specialty and complete patient records were considered.
A report should not be treated as conclusive merely because it was prepared by an official institution.
The court must assess its reasoning and consistency with the evidence.
Potentially. A foreign doctor may obtain or submit an expert opinion through legally available procedures.
For example, the defense may dispute a report concluding that a particular surgical decision was negligent.
A specialist opinion may address accepted clinical standards and alternative explanations.
However, a privately obtained opinion does not automatically override an official expert report.
The court must evaluate the competing evidence.
Where necessary, further expert examination may be requested.
Yes. Medical records may be important to determining what occurred during treatment.
For example, missing monitoring records may make it difficult to establish the patient’s condition at a critical time.
The prosecutor may examine whether the absence reflects incomplete documentation, technical problems, or intentional alteration.
However, missing records do not automatically establish negligent homicide or injury.
The prosecution must determine the significance of the missing information.
Where intentional falsification is alleged, separate criminal-law questions may arise.
Yes, potentially. Deliberately falsifying or altering medical records may raise criminal liability under provisions concerning documents and other relevant offenses.
For example, a doctor may be accused of changing clinical notes after a patient’s death.
The prosecution must determine whether the alleged alteration occurred and which statutory provision applies.
However, a late correction or properly documented amendment is not automatically criminal falsification.
The context, authenticity, and intent must be examined.
Foreign doctors should preserve medical records and comply with lawful documentation procedures.
Potentially, where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
However, a malpractice complaint does not automatically justify arrest or detention.
The applicable investigation-permission framework must also be considered where required.
For example, a foreign doctor may be accused of negligent homicide following a patient’s death.
The competent authorities must comply with the relevant criminal procedure rules.
Foreign nationality alone does not justify deprivation of liberty.
Pretrial detention is governed by Article 100 of the Turkish Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271.
The competent judge must examine the applicable suspicion threshold, detention grounds, necessity, and proportionality.
For example, a foreign doctor may be investigated for a serious alleged medical offense.
However, detention is not automatic merely because the allegation concerns a patient’s death.
The procedural authorization requirements applicable to the investigation must also be respected.
The doctor may challenge a detention decision through the relevant legal procedure.
Yes. A prohibition on leaving Turkey may be imposed as a judicial control measure under Article 109 of the Turkish Criminal Procedure Code where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
For example, a foreign surgeon may remain under investigation while continuing employment.
The competent judicial authority may consider whether a travel restriction is legally justified.
However, a travel ban is not automatic.
The doctor may request review or removal of the measure.
Before traveling abroad, the individual should verify whether any restriction exists.
Article 147 of the Turkish Criminal Procedure Code establishes important safeguards concerning suspect questioning.
These include the right to be informed of the accusation, the right to legal assistance, and the right not to answer questions concerning the alleged offense.
For example, a foreign physician may be questioned about treatment decisions made during an emergency.
The doctor may request defense counsel before providing a detailed statement.
The authorities must comply with applicable procedural requirements.
The doctor should not sign a statement that cannot be understood or verified.
Yes. Article 202 of the Turkish Criminal Procedure Code provides interpretation safeguards for suspects and defendants who cannot adequately communicate in Turkish.
For example, a foreign physician may understand medical terminology in English but have difficulty understanding Turkish criminal procedure terminology.
Accurate interpretation may be essential to explaining the treatment decisions.
The doctor should verify that the recorded statement accurately reflects the answers given.
Where an error occurs, correction should be requested.
Language difficulties should not prevent the effective exercise of defense rights.
Yes. Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations provides important rights concerning consular communication following arrest or detention.
For example, a foreign doctor taken into custody may request that the relevant consular post be informed.
However, consular assistance does not replace Turkish criminal defense representation.
An embassy or consulate generally cannot direct the prosecutor or court to terminate proceedings.
A Turkish criminal lawyer may assist with the defense while consular personnel provide available support.
Potentially. Professional authorization and criminal liability involve separate legal frameworks.
For example, a foreign doctor may face a criminal investigation while holding authorization to practice medicine in Turkey.
The competent professional and administrative authorities may examine whether the circumstances justify a licensing or professional measure.
However, a criminal complaint does not automatically establish that the doctor must lose professional authorization.
Any adverse administrative decision must comply with the applicable statutory requirements.
The doctor may have legal remedies.
Potentially. Work permits are governed by Law No. 6735 on International Workforce and relevant healthcare professional authorization rules.
For example, a foreign doctor may be dismissed from a private hospital following a malpractice allegation.
Termination of employment may affect an employer-specific work permit.
However, the existence of a criminal investigation does not automatically cancel every work authorization.
The doctor should examine the employment relationship, professional authorization, and immigration status separately.
Potentially. An employer may investigate alleged professional misconduct or performance failures.
For example, a private hospital may suspend a foreign surgeon while examining a serious patient complaint.
However, the employer must comply with applicable employment-law requirements.
A criminal allegation does not automatically establish just cause for dismissal.
The doctor may challenge an unlawful termination and seek available employment remedies.
The criminal investigation and employment dispute must be assessed separately.
Yes. Medical malpractice allegations may create civil or administrative compensation claims in addition to criminal proceedings.
For example, a patient may seek compensation for injury allegedly caused by negligent treatment.
The legal route depends on whether the treatment occurred in a public or private healthcare institution and the circumstances of the claim.
However, compensation liability and criminal liability are not identical.
Different legal standards and procedural requirements may apply.
A doctor may face civil proceedings even where criminal liability has not been established.
Potentially. Medical professional liability insurance may cover qualifying compensation claims under the applicable policy and legal framework.
For example, a foreign physician may be insured against certain medical malpractice liabilities.
However, insurance coverage depends on the policy, statutory requirements, exclusions, and nature of the claim.
Insurance does not automatically eliminate criminal responsibility.
The doctor should examine whether the insurer must be notified and whether legal defense costs are covered.
The criminal and insurance consequences should be assessed separately.
Potentially. A criminal conviction may create immigration-law concerns under Law No. 6458 on Foreigners and International Protection.
For example, a foreign doctor may be convicted of negligent homicide following a medical malpractice case.
However, deportation is not an automatic consequence of every conviction.
The competent immigration authority must determine whether the applicable statutory grounds exist.
The criminal judgment and any immigration measure involve separate legal requirements.
An adverse administrative decision may be subject to judicial review.
Potentially. Residence permits are governed by Law No. 6458.
For example, a foreign doctor may remain under criminal investigation while holding a valid residence or work authorization.
The existence of a malpractice allegation does not automatically establish that the residence permit must be canceled.
However, immigration authorities may examine independently relevant statutory grounds.
The doctor may have legal remedies against an adverse administrative decision.
Professional, employment, and immigration issues should be assessed separately.
Potentially. An entry ban may be imposed where the applicable immigration-law requirements are satisfied.
For example, a foreign physician may leave Turkey following the conclusion of criminal proceedings.
The existence of a medical negligence investigation or conviction does not automatically establish that an entry ban has been imposed.
However, separate administrative decisions may affect future travel.
The doctor should verify whether any restriction exists and examine its legal basis.
An entry ban is legally distinct from a criminal conviction.
Yes. Article 53 of Law No. 6458 provides for judicial review of deportation decisions.
The ordinary period for bringing an action is seven days from notification, subject to the applicable statutory framework.
For example, a foreign doctor may receive a deportation decision following a criminal conviction.
The person should examine the decision immediately because the judicial deadline is short.
The legal effect of an appeal and any applicable exceptions must be assessed.
Criminal defense and immigration litigation may need to proceed simultaneously.
Yes. A court may acquit a defendant where the prosecution fails to establish the charged offense beyond reasonable doubt.
For example, expert evidence may establish that the doctor followed accepted medical standards and that the patient’s injury resulted from an unavoidable complication.
Alternatively, the prosecution may fail to establish a legally sufficient causal connection between the alleged conduct and harm.
However, acquittal is not automatic merely because the doctor denies negligence.
The court must evaluate the complete evidence.
The presumption of innocence remains applicable throughout the proceedings.
Yes. The defense may challenge an expert report that is incomplete, contradictory, or based on inaccurate assumptions.
For example, a report may fail to consider important clinical records or the patient’s pre-existing medical condition.
The defense may request further expert examination or submit a legally relevant specialist opinion.
However, disagreement with an unfavorable report does not automatically establish that the report is invalid.
The court must evaluate the reasoning and supporting evidence.
Expert findings are important, but the ultimate determination of criminal responsibility belongs to the court.
A foreign doctor should promptly identify the precise allegation and obtain qualified legal assistance.
The defense should examine the patient’s medical records, clinical chronology, informed consent documents, relevant guidelines, and available expert evidence.
The doctor should also determine whether the special investigation-permission procedure under Additional Article 18 of Law No. 3359 applies.
Where an investigation permission decision has been issued, the available objection procedure and deadline should be reviewed immediately.
The doctor should preserve records, avoid unauthorized alterations, and comply with applicable patient confidentiality obligations.
Any professional licensing, employment, work permit, residence permit, or immigration consequences should be evaluated separately.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya assists foreign healthcare professionals in examining medical negligence allegations, reviewing investigation-permission requirements, challenging disputed expert findings, and protecting criminal, professional, and immigration-related rights under Turkish law.
1. Can a foreign doctor be criminally prosecuted for medical negligence in Turkey?
Yes. Foreign doctors may face criminal liability where the statutory elements of negligent injury, negligent homicide, or another relevant offense are established.
2. Does a patient’s death automatically establish medical malpractice?
No. The prosecution must establish negligent conduct and a legally sufficient causal connection between the breach and the patient’s death.
3. What is the punishment for negligent homicide under Article 85?
The basic offense carries imprisonment of two to six years. Different penalties apply where the statutory conditions concerning multiple victims are satisfied.
4. Can a foreign doctor be prosecuted for causing injury through negligence?
Yes. Article 89 regulates negligent injury, with penalties depending on the nature and consequences of the harm.
5. Is investigation permission required before prosecuting a foreign doctor?
For qualifying medical examination, diagnosis, and treatment acts, Additional Article 18 of Law No. 3359 establishes a special investigation-permission procedure, subject to statutory exceptions.
6. Does the Professional Liability Board procedure apply to private hospitals?
Yes. The framework includes qualifying healthcare professionals working in private institutions.
7. Can a foreign doctor challenge an investigation permission decision?
Yes. Decisions of the Professional Liability Board may be challenged through the applicable objection procedure before the Ankara Regional Administrative Court.
8. Can a medical complication result in criminal liability?
Not automatically. A recognized complication occurring despite appropriate care is different from harm caused by a negligent breach of professional standards.
9. Can a medical negligence investigation affect a foreign doctor’s work permit?
Potentially. However, a criminal allegation does not automatically cancel professional authorization or a work permit. Separate statutory requirements apply.
10. Can a foreign doctor be acquitted of medical negligence?
Yes. Acquittal is possible where the prosecution fails to establish the charged offense beyond reasonable doubt.
Professional legal assistance is essential to protect your rights and prevent unnecessary legal and financial losses.
By working with a lawyer experienced in Turkish criminal law, medical malpractice investigations, professional liability, expert evidence, and foreign healthcare professional representation, doctors accused of medical negligence can obtain professional legal assistance tailored to their circumstances.
At Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office, we provide professional legal support in medical negligence investigations under Articles 85 and 89 of the Turkish Penal Code, Professional Liability Board procedures under Law No. 3359, investigation permission objections, medical expert report disputes, negligent homicide and injury allegations, criminal trials, professional authorization disputes, work permit issues, and related immigration proceedings.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya assists foreign doctors, surgeons, anesthesiologists, emergency physicians, medical specialists, healthcare professionals, and individuals residing abroad in understanding criminal allegations, examining medical evidence, preparing legally reasoned defenses, challenging disputed judicial and administrative measures, and protecting criminal, professional, and immigration-related rights under Turkish law.
Call Now: 0312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: 0532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Website: www.firatfesihkaya.av.tr
This article is provided for general informational purposes only. To avoid any loss of rights, we recommend consulting your lawyer regarding your specific circumstances.