

Discovered that your apartment in Turkey was sold to multiple buyers? Learn whether double-selling property constitutes criminal fraud, how foreign investors can recover money, challenge title deeds and protect their rights in 2026.
Discovering that the same apartment has been sold or promised to multiple buyers in Turkey can create serious financial and legal problems for foreign property investors. A buyer may pay the full purchase price for an apartment, sign a sales agreement, and receive assurances that the title deed will be transferred, only to discover that the developer or seller has accepted payments from several other purchasers for the same property.
This situation is particularly concerning for foreign investors who purchase apartments remotely, invest in off-plan developments, or rely on real estate agents and construction companies to complete transactions in Turkey.
In some cases, the seller deliberately enters into multiple agreements for the same apartment to collect money from different buyers. In other cases, overlapping sales may result from contractual disputes, administrative errors, unauthorized representation, or financial difficulties affecting a development project.
The legal distinction is important because selling the same apartment to multiple buyers may constitute criminal fraud under Turkish law, but multiple sales agreements do not automatically establish a criminal offense.
Under Articles 157 and 158 of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, deliberate deceptive conduct intended to obtain an unlawful financial benefit may give rise to criminal responsibility. Depending on the circumstances, foreign buyers may also pursue contractual remedies, compensation claims, title deed-related litigation, and protective measures against further property transfers.
The legal outcome frequently depends on whether ownership has already been registered, whether the buyer holds a valid preliminary sale agreement, whether the agreement was annotated in the land registry, and whether the seller intentionally deceived the purchasers.
This 2026 guide explains the criminal consequences of selling the same apartment to multiple buyers in Turkey, the legal rights of foreign investors, and the procedures available to recover money or protect a legitimate claim to the property.
A multiple-buyer property dispute arises when two or more individuals claim rights to the same apartment based on separate transactions or promises made by the seller.
For example, a foreign investor may sign an agreement to purchase Apartment 12 in a residential development and transfer the agreed purchase price. Several months later, the investor may discover that the developer entered into another agreement with a different buyer for the same apartment.
The situation becomes more complicated when the second buyer has already obtained a registered title deed.
Another common scenario involves an off-plan development in which the construction company repeatedly markets and sells the same unit to different investors before the building is completed.
Some developers may issue separate contracts containing identical apartment numbers, block references, floor plans, or property descriptions.
The purchasers may remain unaware of one another until the expected delivery date or title deed transfer.
However, the existence of several contracts does not necessarily mean that several individuals have acquired ownership.
Under Turkish law, ownership of immovable property is generally acquired through registration in the land registry, subject to legally recognized exceptions.
A preliminary agreement, reservation form, or payment receipt does not automatically confer registered ownership.
Consequently, determining the legal position of each buyer requires examination of the land registry, the contracts, the payment records, and the sequence of transactions.
Selling or promising the same apartment to multiple buyers may constitute criminal fraud where the seller deliberately deceives purchasers to obtain money or another unlawful benefit.
Article 157 of the Turkish Penal Code regulates the basic offense of fraud.
The offense requires fraudulent conduct capable of deceiving another person, resulting in harm and an unlawful benefit for the perpetrator or another person.
For example, a developer may knowingly accept the full purchase price from a foreign investor while concealing that the apartment has already been sold and that the developer cannot fulfill the promised transfer.
If the evidence establishes the required elements, criminal liability may arise.
The basic fraud offense under Article 157 carries imprisonment of one to five years and a judicial fine of up to five thousand days.
Nevertheless, a criminal investigation must distinguish deliberate deception from ordinary contractual nonperformance.
A developer may enter into a valid agreement and subsequently become unable to deliver the apartment because of financial difficulties, construction delays, or a genuine contractual dispute.
Such circumstances may establish civil liability without necessarily proving criminal fraud.
The prosecution must examine the seller’s conduct, representations, knowledge, and intent.
Article 158 of the Turkish Penal Code establishes aggravated forms of fraud.
A multiple-sale property scheme may fall within an aggravated category where the relevant statutory requirements are satisfied.
For example, a fraudulent transaction conducted within the commercial activities of a merchant, company manager, or person acting on behalf of a company may require examination under Article 158.
Certain schemes involving information systems, banks, or other specifically regulated circumstances may also fall within aggravated fraud provisions.
However, the mere involvement of a construction company, real estate agency, bank transfer, or online advertisement does not automatically establish aggravated fraud.
The prosecution must determine whether the specific qualifying circumstances exist.
Where several foreign buyers have been deceived through a coordinated scheme, the investigation may also examine whether the conduct involves separate offenses, participation by multiple individuals, or other relevant criminal law provisions.
The number of buyers and the relationship between the transactions may affect the legal analysis, but criminal responsibility must be determined according to the applicable statutory rules.
A foreign investor may discover a multiple-sale dispute when requesting the title deed transfer, inspecting the property, or contacting the developer about delivery.
The seller may repeatedly postpone the transaction, claim that administrative approvals are pending, or provide inconsistent explanations concerning ownership.
In other cases, the investor may discover that another person is occupying the apartment or claiming to have purchased it.
The most reliable starting point is to establish the property’s legal identity and current registration status.
The buyer should examine the relevant land registry information, including the parcel, block, independent unit number, registered owner, and any legally relevant annotations.
Where the apartment is part of an unfinished development, additional examination may be necessary to determine whether condominium easement or condominium ownership has been established and whether the promised independent unit can be legally identified.
The buyer should also compare the contract’s property description with the actual registered property information.
A discrepancy between the advertised apartment and the registered unit may indicate an error, a contractual problem, or possible deception.
The surrounding circumstances determine whether a criminal investigation is justified.
The question of ownership is one of the most important issues in a multiple-buyer property dispute.
Under Article 705 of the Turkish Civil Code, ownership of immovable property is generally acquired through registration, subject to specified exceptions.
Accordingly, the person who has completed a legally valid title deed transfer may occupy a stronger ownership position than a purchaser who merely signed a preliminary agreement.
However, the analysis cannot end with identifying the current registered owner.
The court may need to examine whether the registration was lawful, whether an earlier buyer possessed an enforceable annotated right, and whether the subsequent purchaser acted in good faith.
Article 1023 of the Turkish Civil Code protects qualifying third parties who acquire real rights in good faith by relying on the land registry.
Article 1024 addresses circumstances involving knowledge of an unlawful registration.
Article 1025 provides a framework for correcting unlawful land registry entries.
These provisions may become relevant where the dispute involves fraudulent transfers, simulated transactions, or other defects affecting registration.
A buyer who paid first does not automatically become the legal owner merely because the payment occurred before another purchaser’s transaction.
Likewise, the second buyer does not automatically lose ownership simply because an earlier private sales agreement existed.
The applicable property law rules and the validity of the transactions must be examined.
A foreign buyer may pay the entire purchase price while the seller retains registered ownership.
If the seller subsequently transfers the apartment to another person, the first buyer may face substantial financial loss.
The available remedies depend on the legal nature and formal validity of the agreement.
Article 237 of the Turkish Code of Obligations establishes formal requirements concerning immovable property sales and promises to sell.
A privately signed agreement may not satisfy the mandatory form required for an enforceable real estate sale or preliminary sale agreement.
Nevertheless, the buyer may have repayment or compensation claims depending on the transaction.
Where a legally valid preliminary sale agreement exists, the buyer may be entitled to pursue remedies based on that agreement.
If the seller intentionally concealed an earlier sale or deliberately accepted payment despite knowing that performance was impossible, criminal fraud allegations may also arise.
The buyer should preserve bank transfer records, the agreement, payment receipts, communications, and any representations concerning the promised title deed transfer.
These documents may be essential to establishing both the financial loss and the circumstances of the alleged deception.
A properly executed preliminary real estate sale agreement may provide important contractual protection.
However, notarization alone should not be confused with registration of ownership.
A promise to sell immovable property creates rights subject to the applicable legal requirements, while ownership generally requires the legally effective transfer and registration process.
Article 1009 of the Turkish Civil Code provides for annotation of certain personal rights in the land registry.
Where a valid preliminary sale agreement has been properly annotated, the buyer may have enhanced protection against subsequent acquirers within the applicable legal limits.
The date, validity, scope, and continued effectiveness of the annotation are important.
An annotated right does not automatically guarantee success in every dispute.
The buyer must still establish the relevant legal conditions and pursue the appropriate remedy.
Foreign investors should therefore distinguish between an ordinary reservation document, a privately signed contract, a valid notarized promise to sell, an annotated contractual right, and registered ownership.
Each creates a different legal position.
A foreign investor who suspects deliberate deception may submit a criminal complaint to the competent Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office in Turkey.
The complaint should explain the transaction history and identify the conduct believed to constitute fraud.
Relevant information may include the date of the agreement, the apartment’s description, the purchase price, payment records, promises concerning delivery, and the circumstances in which the buyer discovered another purchaser.
Where possible, the complaint should identify other buyers who may have experienced similar conduct.
The prosecution may investigate whether the seller knowingly entered into conflicting agreements, concealed previous transactions, or obtained payments through false representations.
Banking records, company documents, land registry information, and communications with purchasers may become relevant.
If multiple buyers report similar conduct, their evidence may assist the investigation in determining whether a coordinated fraudulent scheme existed.
However, similar complaints do not automatically establish guilt.
Each allegation must be examined according to the applicable criminal procedure and evidentiary rules.
A foreign buyer may appoint a Turkish lawyer to assist with the criminal complaint and subsequent proceedings.
The strongest evidence often demonstrates that the seller knew the apartment had already been sold or promised to another buyer when accepting further payments.
Important documents may include sales agreements, notarized preliminary contracts, bank transfer receipts, invoices, property advertisements, developer correspondence, and land registry records.
The chronology of the transactions may be particularly important.
For example, a seller who received full payment from one buyer and subsequently advertised the same apartment as available may have made representations requiring criminal investigation.
Communications showing that the seller deliberately concealed an existing agreement may also be relevant.
Where several buyers received identical apartment descriptions, their contracts may provide evidence of overlapping promises.
The prosecution may also examine whether the seller possessed sufficient ownership or contractual rights to perform the promised transactions.
Financial records may reveal whether purchase payments were used for legitimate development activities or diverted elsewhere.
However, the use of funds alone does not conclusively establish criminal intent.
The evidence must be evaluated as a whole.
A foreign investor who loses the opportunity to acquire the promised apartment may have claims for repayment or compensation.
The appropriate legal basis depends on the agreement and the circumstances surrounding the transaction.
Where a valid contract exists, contractual remedies may be available under the Turkish Code of Obligations.
Articles 112 and following regulate important aspects of liability for nonperformance, while other provisions govern remedies arising from contractual default and termination.
Where a transaction lacks the required legal form, restitution under the applicable rules may require examination.
Articles 77 and following regulate unjust enrichment.
Where deliberate unlawful conduct causes financial damage, Article 49 may provide a basis for tort-related compensation.
The buyer may seek recovery of amounts paid and other legally recoverable losses where the requirements are established.
However, the recoverable amount and applicable interest depend on the specific legal basis and facts.
A criminal complaint does not automatically result in repayment.
Civil proceedings and subsequent enforcement measures may be necessary.
A foreign buyer may wish to prevent further transfers while the dispute is unresolved.
Under Article 389 and following provisions of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure, interim injunctions may be available where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
The applicant must demonstrate the legal basis of the claim and the circumstances justifying temporary protection.
Where the dispute concerns a legally enforceable claim to a specific property, the court may examine whether an interim measure affecting the property is appropriate.
However, not every buyer who paid a deposit or signed a private contract is entitled to an injunction restricting the property’s transfer.
The requested protection must correspond to the substantive claim and the applicable procedural requirements.
Where the buyer’s claim is purely monetary, other measures such as precautionary attachment may require consideration.
Article 257 and following provisions of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law regulate precautionary attachment under specified conditions.
Foreign investors should therefore distinguish between protecting a claim to the apartment itself and securing a financial claim against the seller.
A foreign buyer may wish to challenge a title deed registered in another purchaser’s name.
However, a previous agreement or earlier payment does not automatically entitle the first buyer to cancellation of the second buyer’s title deed.
A title deed cancellation and registration lawsuit requires a legally recognized basis.
The court may examine whether the first buyer possesses an enforceable right affecting the subsequent acquisition, whether the registration was unlawful, or whether the transaction involved legally relevant bad faith or simulation.
Where the second buyer acquired ownership through a valid transaction and enjoys applicable legal protection, cancellation may not be available.
The first buyer may instead need to pursue financial remedies against the seller or other legally responsible persons.
Where a properly annotated preliminary sale right exists, the legal position may differ.
The outcome depends on the relevant documentation, registration history, and applicable property law provisions.
Off-plan developments can create particular risks because buyers may pay substantial amounts before construction is completed.
A developer may market apartments using architectural drawings, preliminary unit numbers, and projected completion dates.
Where the same unit is promised to multiple buyers, the legal analysis must examine whether the developer intentionally entered into incompatible obligations.
The fact that construction is incomplete does not automatically establish fraud.
However, deliberate concealment of multiple agreements, fabricated unit allocations, or knowingly false representations may support criminal allegations.
The investigation may examine the developer’s ownership or development rights, project documentation, contractual records, and financial transactions.
Where the project has not yet established individually registered apartment units, the legal description of the promised property may require particular attention.
Foreign investors should also examine whether the development has been mortgaged, transferred, or affected by enforcement proceedings.
These circumstances may complicate both property recovery and financial compensation.
A multiple-sale property scheme may involve developers, company directors, sales representatives, real estate agents, and financial intermediaries.
Criminal responsibility depends on each individual’s conduct and participation.
A company director who knowingly organizes a scheme to collect payments from several buyers for the same apartment may face investigation where the elements of an offense are established.
A real estate agent who deliberately provides false information or conceals material facts as part of fraudulent conduct may also face potential criminal responsibility.
However, a person does not automatically become criminally liable merely because they worked for the developer or participated in an unsuccessful transaction.
The prosecution must establish the relevant conduct and mental elements.
Civil liability may require separate examination under contractual, tort-based, or other applicable legal rules.
Where the seller is a company, the buyer should also investigate the legal identity of the contracting entity and the individuals who actually received the funds.
Foreign buyers who suspect a coordinated property fraud scheme may be concerned that the seller will transfer funds or dispose of assets before compensation can be recovered.
Depending on the circumstances, criminal authorities may consider protective measures under the Criminal Procedure Code.
Article 128 regulates seizure of specified assets, rights, and receivables where the relevant legal conditions are satisfied.
These measures are subject to statutory safeguards and are not automatically available upon filing a complaint.
Separately, a buyer with a qualifying monetary claim may examine the possibility of precautionary attachment under the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law.
The applicant must satisfy the relevant legal requirements, and security may be required.
The distinction between criminal seizure and civil precautionary attachment is important.
Neither procedure guarantees eventual recovery.
The practical prospects of repayment depend on the availability of assets, the enforceability of the claim, and the outcome of the relevant proceedings.
Where multiple buyers allege that the same developer accepted payments for identical apartments, the prosecution may examine the relationship between the complaints.
Investigators may compare the contracts, payment dates, representations, and identities of the individuals involved.
Evidence of a repeated pattern may be relevant to determining whether the seller acted deliberately.
However, each buyer’s legal position may differ.
One buyer may possess a valid notarized preliminary agreement, another may have only a reservation form, and a third may already hold registered ownership.
The financial losses may also vary.
The criminal investigation may address related allegations, but the applicable rules concerning multiple offenses and criminal participation require separate legal assessment.
Civil proceedings may likewise involve different claims and remedies.
Foreign investors should therefore avoid assuming that all buyers have identical legal rights simply because they were affected by the same development.
Foreign investors purchasing real estate for Turkish citizenship may encounter additional complications if the same apartment has been promised to several buyers.
The applicable citizenship requirements depend on the qualifying investment, ownership documentation, valuation rules, and relevant administrative conditions.
A payment made under a private agreement does not automatically establish a qualifying property investment.
Where the investor never acquires the required property right, the investment may fail to satisfy the applicable citizenship criteria.
If the apartment has already been transferred to another buyer, the investor may need to address both the property dispute and the consequences for the citizenship application.
A criminal complaint does not automatically preserve citizenship eligibility.
The legal response should consider the investment structure, transaction history, and administrative status.
Foreign investors residing abroad may generally authorize a Turkish lawyer to conduct appropriate legal proceedings.
The power of attorney must comply with the relevant formal requirements and contain the authority necessary for the intended actions.
Depending on the country and circumstances, the authorization may be executed through a Turkish consulate or another legally recognized procedure.
Translation, apostille certification, or legalization may be required.
A lawyer may assist with obtaining property records, preparing criminal complaints, initiating civil proceedings, and examining available protective measures.
However, certain investigative or judicial procedures may require personal participation.
Foreign investors should preserve original documents and ensure that communications concerning the transaction remain accessible.
As of November 2026, disputes involving the sale of the same apartment to multiple buyers are governed by several interconnected areas of Turkish law.
The Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 regulates fraud, aggravated fraud, document forgery, and other potentially relevant criminal offenses.
The Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271 governs criminal investigations, evidence collection, and applicable protective measures.
The Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 governs ownership, land registry rights, annotations, and correction of unlawful registrations.
The Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 regulates contractual obligations, preliminary sale agreements, nonperformance, restitution, and compensation.
The Turkish Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 governs civil litigation and interim injunctions.
The Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 regulates enforcement and precautionary attachment.
The Land Registry Law No. 2644 and related implementing legislation govern important aspects of real estate transactions and registration procedures.
An important distinction in 2026 remains the difference between a contractual promise to transfer an apartment and legally registered ownership of that apartment.
The enforceability of the buyer’s claim depends on the contract’s formal validity, the registration history, any legally effective annotations, and the circumstances of the subsequent transactions.
No unverified legislative amendment is presented as a confirmed 2026 change. Any amendment relevant to an active case should be checked against its official publication and effective date.
A seller’s failure to deliver an apartment does not automatically establish criminal fraud.
Criminal liability requires proof of the relevant statutory elements, including deceptive conduct and the required intent.
Civil liability may arise from nonperformance, invalid agreements, unjust enrichment, or other legally recognized grounds.
A developer who deliberately sells the same apartment to several purchasers while concealing the conflicting transactions may face criminal allegations.
By contrast, a genuine contractual dispute arising from financial difficulties or later disagreement may primarily require civil remedies.
The distinction affects the appropriate evidence, legal procedures, and potential outcomes.
A criminal conviction does not automatically transfer ownership to the complainant.
Likewise, a successful civil claim for repayment does not necessarily establish criminal guilt.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that foreign investors affected by multiple-sale property disputes should examine the criminal allegations, ownership records, contractual rights, and prospects of financial recovery together.
A coordinated legal assessment can help determine whether the investor should pursue ownership-related remedies, repayment, compensation, criminal proceedings, or a combination of legally available measures.
1. Is it illegal to sell the same apartment to two buyers in Turkey?
Selling or promising the same apartment to multiple buyers may constitute criminal fraud where deliberate deception and the other statutory elements are established. However, overlapping contracts or failure to transfer ownership do not automatically prove a criminal offense. The circumstances must be investigated.
2. Who owns an apartment if two people paid for it in Turkey?
Ownership generally depends on legally effective registration in the land registry, subject to applicable exceptions and protections. The fact that one buyer paid earlier does not automatically establish ownership. Valid preliminary agreements, annotations, and the registration history may affect the legal outcome.
3. Can I recover my money if the developer sold my apartment to someone else?
Potentially. Depending on the agreement and circumstances, the buyer may pursue contractual remedies, restitution, or compensation. Recovery depends on the legal basis of the claim, available evidence, and the defendant’s assets.
4. Can I file a criminal complaint against a developer who sold my apartment twice?
Yes, where the circumstances indicate possible fraud or another criminal offense. The complaint should include contracts, payment records, correspondence, and evidence concerning the conflicting sale. The prosecution determines whether criminal charges are justified.
5. Can I cancel the title deed of the second buyer?
Not automatically. Title deed cancellation requires a legally recognized basis. The court may examine the validity of the transactions, any annotated rights, unlawful registration allegations, and applicable third-party protections.
6. Does a notarized property sale agreement protect me against another buyer?
A valid notarized preliminary sale agreement may create enforceable contractual rights. Annotation in the land registry may provide additional protection under the applicable legal requirements. However, notarization alone does not transfer ownership or guarantee priority in every dispute.
7. Can I stop the seller from transferring the apartment while my case is pending?
An interim injunction may be available where the statutory requirements are satisfied and the requested measure is appropriate to the underlying claim. A buyer with only a monetary claim may need to consider different protective remedies.
8. Can a foreign investor file a property fraud case from abroad?
In many circumstances, a foreign investor may appoint a Turkish lawyer to pursue criminal and civil proceedings. The authorization must satisfy the applicable requirements, and personal participation may still be necessary for certain procedural acts.
9. Can several foreign buyers sue the same developer for selling one apartment multiple times?
Yes, affected buyers may pursue appropriate legal remedies. However, their claims may differ depending on their contracts, payments, ownership status, and evidence. Whether proceedings can be combined depends on the applicable procedural rules.
10. How long does a multiple-sale property fraud case take in Turkey?
There is no universal duration. The timeline depends on the number of parties, complexity of the transactions, evidence, related criminal investigations, civil proceedings, and the workload of the relevant authorities. Urgent protective measures should be considered independently of the expected case duration.
Protecting your investment and legal rights requires timely and specialized legal assistance.
Foreign investors who discover that the same apartment has been sold or promised to several buyers may face substantial financial losses, uncertainty concerning ownership, and complex disputes involving developers, real estate agents, company directors, and other purchasers.
Working with a lawyer experienced in Turkish criminal law, real estate law, and international investment disputes can help protect your rights and identify the appropriate remedies.
Serving clients throughout Turkey and internationally, Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office provides professional legal support in multiple-sale property fraud disputes, criminal fraud investigations, developer-related disputes, title deed litigation, contractual claims, money recovery proceedings, compensation lawsuits, and legally available protective measures.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya assists foreign property buyers, international investors, expatriates, and individuals residing abroad who discover that an apartment purchased or reserved in Turkey has also been sold or promised to another buyer.
Call Now: +90 312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: +90 532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Website: https://www.firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only. To avoid any loss of legal rights, we recommend consulting your lawyer regarding the specific circumstances of your case.