The role of insurance experts and adjusters in Turkey – foreigner’s perspective
Foreigners and force-majeure insurance clauses in Turkish contracts
Ekim 31, 2025
Can foreigners insure property still under construction in Turkey?
Kasım 3, 2025
Introduction: Understanding the Role of Insurance Experts in Turkish Claims
In the Turkish insurance market, experts and adjusters play an essential role in assessing the legitimacy of claims, calculating compensation, and interpreting policy coverage. For foreigners who experience property damage, accidents, or commercial loss in Turkey, the expert’s report often determines whether compensation will be paid or denied.
These professionals are licensed by the Insurance and Private Pension Regulation and Supervision Agency (SEDDK) and are responsible for providing impartial technical evaluations. Yet, from a foreigner’s perspective, the process may appear opaque or biased, especially when the expert is appointed by the insurer rather than a neutral authority.
Insurance experts (known in Turkish as eksperler) must adhere to strict ethical and procedural rules under Law No. 5684 on Insurance and the Turkish Commercial Code (TCC). Nevertheless, misunderstanding their role, or failing to challenge a flawed report, can cause serious financial consequences for a foreign claimant.
1. Legal Status and Function of Insurance Experts in Turkey
Insurance experts are recognized as independent professionals authorized to assess and report on the circumstances of insured events. Their expertise covers various fields, including vehicle damage, fire, engineering, health, maritime, and life insurance.
They collect evidence, evaluate the extent of loss, determine the cause of the damage, and calculate indemnity according to the policy terms.
While experts are expected to remain neutral, insurers often nominate them after a claim is filed. For this reason, foreigners should ensure that their reports are reviewed by a lawyer who can verify whether the expert complied with procedural requirements and fairness principles under Turkish law.
Are insurance experts part of the insurer’s staff?
No, they are licensed independent professionals. However, they are often selected by insurers to evaluate claims.
Can a foreign claimant request an independent expert?
Yes, a foreign policyholder can appoint their own licensed expert to prepare an alternative report for submission during arbitration or litigation.
Are expert reports binding on courts?
Not automatically, but they are influential and frequently determine the outcome of a dispute.
2. Appointment and Certification Process
The process of becoming an insurance expert in Turkey is regulated by the SEDDK. Applicants must have a relevant academic background—such as engineering, finance, or law—and pass a qualification exam. Only those listed in the Official Expertise Registry can act as authorized adjusters.
Foreign experts can participate only if the Ministry of Treasury and Finance grants temporary permission.
When a loss occurs, the insurer typically assigns an expert. However, if the claimant suspects bias or negligence, they can request a second evaluation through the Insurance Arbitration Commission or via the courts.
Who appoints the expert in a standard claim?
Usually the insurance company, unless a counter-expert is engaged by the policyholder.
Can a foreigner object to the appointed expert?
Yes. Written objections can be filed to request a re-evaluation or new appointment.
Are foreign experts allowed to operate in Turkey?
Yes, with special authorization from the Ministry or court appointment.
3. Scope of Expert Duties During the Claim Process
An insurance expert’s primary role is to investigate, analyze, and report. This involves visiting the site of the damage, taking photographs, interviewing witnesses, checking policy conditions, and producing a report detailing the cause, extent, and value of loss.
The insurer relies on this report to decide whether to compensate or reject the claim.
For foreign policyholders, this stage is crucial. Small technical inaccuracies—misinterpreting foreign documents, overlooking currency conversions, or misunderstanding imported goods’ values—can result in significantly reduced compensation. Therefore, foreign clients should ensure full participation during the inspection and keep communication in writing.
How long does an expert evaluation usually take?
Typically 15–30 days after notification of the loss.
Can policyholders attend the inspection?
Yes, and it is advisable to ensure that findings are accurate and complete.
What if the report contains mistakes?
A supplementary report or counter-expertise can be requested immediately.
4. Independence and Ethical Obligations
Turkish law requires experts to act independently. Article 22 of the Insurance Law specifies that experts must not have financial or professional ties that may influence their judgment.
Despite this, some foreign claimants have faced difficulties when experts repeatedly work with the same insurer. Yargıtay, the Turkish Supreme Court, has emphasized in multiple decisions that such patterns can compromise neutrality.
If a foreign claimant believes that the expert is biased, their attorney can challenge the report and demand a court-appointed expert panel for a new assessment.
Can bias invalidate an expert report?
Yes, courts may disregard any report proven to be partial or inconsistent.
Are experts regulated by ethical codes?
Yes. The SEDDK supervises their conduct and can impose disciplinary action.
How can foreigners detect bias?
If the expert avoids communication, excludes key evidence, or consistently supports the insurer’s position, legal challenge is warranted.
5. Insurance Experts in Mediation and Arbitration
Since 2019, mediation has become a mandatory pre-litigation procedure for commercial and insurance disputes in Turkey. During mediation, both sides may present expert reports as evidence to support their positions.
In insurance arbitration, which functions similarly to a specialized court, expert reports are also decisive in resolving claims.
Foreign claimants benefit greatly from providing independent assessments translated into Turkish. Mediators and arbitrators are more likely to reach a balanced settlement when both parties’ reports are presented objectively.
Are expert reports accepted in mediation?
Yes, mediators rely heavily on them when determining settlement values.
Can claimants bring their own experts to arbitration?
Yes, and it strengthens their negotiation position.
Is mediation mandatory for foreigners?
Yes, mediation applies equally to foreign and domestic parties.
6. Judicial Expertise in Insurance Disputes
If mediation or arbitration fails, the case proceeds to court. The court appoints judicial experts (bilirkişi) to assess the technical issues. These experts are independent professionals listed in the National Judicial Expertise Registry.
Unlike insurer-appointed experts, judicial experts operate under court supervision and must provide objective, detailed opinions.
Their reports often carry decisive weight. However, foreign claimants can still contest errors by submitting written objections or requesting a second expert review.
Can parties suggest their own judicial experts?
Yes, but the court has the final authority in appointment.
Are court experts different from insurance experts?
Yes. Court experts are judicially independent and not linked to insurers.
Can expert opinions be appealed?
Yes, objections can be filed, and higher courts may order new evaluations.
7. The Evidentiary Power of Expert Reports
Under Article 282 of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure, expert reports constitute critical evidence in civil trials. Judges often rely on them when assessing technical or financial matters.
However, reports that are inconsistent, lack factual support, or show procedural errors may be disregarded.
Foreign claimants should ensure all evidence — invoices, receipts, photographs, and statements — is translated, notarized, and submitted properly. Missing or unverified documents can weaken even the most legitimate claims.
Are expert reports confidential?
Yes, they are shared only with parties to the dispute.
Can the court reject an expert report?
Yes, if it fails to comply with procedural or ethical standards.
Can remote assessments be used?
Yes, provided they meet SEDDK’s technical verification criteria.
8. Protecting the Interests of Foreign Policyholders
Foreign claimants often face structural disadvantages — language barriers, limited access to experts, or misunderstanding procedural rules.
The best defense is proactive legal representation.
A Turkish lawyer specializing in insurance disputes can monitor expert inspections, prepare formal objections, and demand reassessments when necessary.
Foreigners are also advised to keep a copy of all correspondence, expert reports, and insurer responses. These documents are critical for both arbitration and court appeals.
Can embassies intervene in insurance disputes?
They can guide but not represent individuals legally.
Should foreigners hire their own technical experts?
Yes, especially in complex engineering or property cases.
Are objections valid without a lawyer?
They are accepted but far more effective when filed by legal counsel.
9. Supreme Court (Yargıtay) Precedents on Expertise
The Turkish Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed that expert neutrality is essential for fair adjudication.
In one landmark decision (Yargıtay 17th Civil Chamber, 2021/1821 E., 2022/2478 K.), the Court invalidated a ruling that relied solely on an insurer-appointed expert, ordering a retrial with independent expertise.
These precedents empower both Turkish and foreign claimants to contest biased or incomplete expert reports.
Do Yargıtay rulings protect foreign claimants?
Yes, equality before the law ensures the same protections for all parties.
What if an expert ignores key evidence?
The decision can be overturned on appeal or retried with new experts.
Are Yargıtay decisions binding?
They serve as authoritative guidance for all lower courts.
10. Technological Tools in Insurance Expertise
Modern insurance assessments in Turkey increasingly use digital tools, such as drone imaging, AI-based damage evaluation, and satellite data for agricultural losses.
Foreign investors should ensure their policies specify acceptance of such technologies to avoid disputes about measurement accuracy.
The SEDDK promotes digital reporting to reduce fraud, but foreign clients should verify data confidentiality clauses, especially for industrial or energy-sector projects.
Are digital reports legally valid?
Yes, if approved by certified experts.
Can claimants access the data collected?
Yes, they have a legal right to receive full copies of digital assessments.
Are online valuations accepted in court?
Yes, provided authenticity and traceability are proven.
11. Common Errors in Expert Reports
Frequent issues include incomplete documentation, ignoring policy riders, undervaluing losses, or misinterpreting contract language.
Foreigners are especially vulnerable to translation-related discrepancies. For example, “commercial interruption” may be incorrectly classified as “operational loss,” altering compensation amounts.
Legal review can prevent such costly mistakes by ensuring linguistic precision and consistent valuation methodology.
What happens if errors are found?
A supplementary or revised expert report can be ordered.
Can mistakes be corrected during arbitration?
Yes, by submitting counter-reports or expert testimony.
Are translation errors common?
Yes, especially when English or French terms differ from Turkish legal definitions.
12. Challenging Expert Reports in Turkish Courts
To contest an expert report, the claimant must submit formal objections within a specific timeframe — usually one week after receiving the report.
These objections should highlight contradictions, procedural breaches, or evidence omissions.
If accepted, the court may order a new expert review or convene a panel of experts to resolve discrepancies.
Foreigners should always use an attorney for this process since objections must be written in technical Turkish legal language.
Can a flawed report be excluded from evidence?
Yes, if procedural irregularities are proven.
Do courts allow second opinions?
Yes, courts frequently order them in complex insurance cases.
Are expert challenges expensive?
They involve extra costs but are often reimbursed if successful.
13. Insurance Arbitration Board Practices
The Insurance Arbitration Commission (Sigorta Tahkim Komisyonu) offers an alternative to litigation.
Its decisions are binding and enforceable once finalized.
Expert reports form the cornerstone of arbitration rulings, but the Commission can appoint its own neutral experts for verification.
Foreign claimants often prefer this route because proceedings are faster, less costly, and available in English upon request.
Can foreigners apply for insurance arbitration?
Yes, regardless of residence status.
Are arbitration decisions enforceable abroad?
Yes, under international conventions.
Is legal representation mandatory?
Not required but highly recommended.
14. Practical Advice for Foreigners
- Always review insurance contracts with a bilingual lawyer.
- Attend inspections personally or through a trusted representative.
- Request copies of all expert reports immediately.
- Translate every document before submission.
- File timely objections to protect your rights.
Foreign claimants who combine legal diligence with active communication are far more likely to achieve favorable results in Turkish insurance proceedings.
Should foreigners rely solely on global insurance brokers?
No, local legal review ensures compliance with Turkish regulations.
Can documents be submitted electronically?
Yes, through registered e-mail (KEP) systems.
Are settlements common after counter-expert reports?
Yes, insurers often negotiate once faced with credible counter-evidence.
15. Conclusion: Ensuring Fairness in Turkish Insurance Expertise
Insurance experts and adjusters form the technical backbone of Turkey’s insurance system. For foreign policyholders, their evaluations can determine justice or injustice.
Knowing how they operate, how to challenge bias, and when to involve legal counsel transforms a vulnerable position into a protected one.
The Turkish legal system recognizes the equal rights of foreigners — but success depends on evidence, procedure, and expert oversight.
With proper legal representation and awareness, foreign claimants can navigate the Turkish insurance landscape confidently and effectively.
If you are a foreigner or international investor involved in an insurance claim or dispute in Turkey, expert evaluations are the key to securing fair compensation.
At Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Firm, we provide comprehensive legal representation in insurance litigation, arbitration, and expert report analysis.
Our experience ensures that every technical and procedural aspect of your case is properly managed to achieve the most just outcome.
📞 Contact Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Firm
