

Can a foreign parent company face criminal liability for customs violations committed by its Turkish subsidiary? Learn about smuggling allegations, director liability, corporate instructions, personal criminal responsibility, investigations, and legal remedies under Turkish law.
Multinational corporations, foreign investors, international manufacturers, and global trading groups frequently conduct import and export operations in Turkey through locally incorporated subsidiaries.
These subsidiaries may be responsible for purchasing goods, preparing customs declarations, arranging international transportation, and complying with Turkish customs legislation.
Although the Turkish subsidiary generally possesses separate legal personality, important compliance decisions may be influenced by the foreign parent company.
The parent company may establish group-wide procurement policies, approve intercompany pricing, negotiate supplier contracts, determine customs classification practices, or supervise international logistics operations.
In some cases, Turkish customs authorities or criminal investigators may allege that customs violations committed by the subsidiary were directed, approved, or coordinated by individuals working for the foreign parent company.
Such allegations may create significant legal risks for foreign directors, executives, compliance officers, and employees.
For example, a multinational manufacturing group may operate a Turkish subsidiary importing industrial components from related companies abroad.
The foreign parent company’s procurement department may determine the prices used in intercompany transactions.
Following a customs investigation, authorities may allege that certain payments were deliberately excluded from customs declarations to reduce import duties.
Investigators may examine whether foreign executives instructed the Turkish subsidiary to use the disputed valuation method.
In another situation, a foreign parent company may be accused of directing its Turkish subsidiary to submit incorrect certificates of origin, alter commercial invoices, or misrepresent imported goods.
The subsidiary may argue that it followed instructions received from headquarters.
The foreign parent company may respond that its policies were lawful and that any customs errors resulted from local implementation.
Can a foreign parent company or its executives face criminal liability for customs violations committed by a Turkish subsidiary?
Potentially, but liability is not automatic.
Under Turkish criminal law, criminal responsibility is generally personal. The authorities must establish the relevant statutory elements concerning the individuals allegedly involved.
A foreign parent company’s ownership or control of a Turkish subsidiary does not independently establish criminal responsibility for the subsidiary’s customs violations.
However, foreign executives or employees may face criminal investigation where evidence supports allegations that they intentionally directed, participated in, or assisted conduct constituting a criminal offense.
The foreign parent company may also face separate legal consequences under applicable corporate, customs, or security-measure provisions.
Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607, Customs Law No. 4458, Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271, Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, and applicable international criminal cooperation rules may become relevant.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that multinational groups should distinguish corporate ownership, operational control, individual criminal responsibility, customs debt liability, intentional participation in alleged offenses, and the procedural rights of foreign executives during criminal investigations.
Not automatically.
A Turkish subsidiary generally possesses separate legal personality.
The foreign parent company’s ownership of shares does not independently establish criminal responsibility.
However, the authorities may investigate whether particular individuals working for the parent company participated in the alleged offense.
The applicable statutory elements must be established.
No.
Corporate control may allow a parent company to influence the subsidiary’s commercial decisions.
However, control alone does not prove that a particular individual committed a criminal offense.
The authorities must examine the alleged conduct, evidence, and applicable mental requirements.
Article 20 of Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 establishes the principle of personal criminal responsibility.
It also provides that criminal penalties cannot be imposed on legal entities.
However, statutory security measures concerning legal entities may be available under specified conditions.
This distinction is important in multinational corporate investigations.
Potentially, where a specific statutory basis exists and the relevant requirements are satisfied.
Article 60 of the Turkish Penal Code regulates security measures concerning legal entities.
However, these measures are not automatically available for every customs violation.
The applicable offense and statutory conditions must be examined.
Article 60 addresses specified security measures concerning legal entities.
The provision includes measures relating to certain authorizations and confiscation under statutory conditions.
However, its application depends on the relevant offense and legal requirements.
A parent company should not automatically be treated as subject to every measure merely because it owns the subsidiary.
Potentially.
Foreign directors may be investigated where evidence suggests that they instructed, approved, or participated in conduct constituting an offense.
However, their corporate title alone does not establish criminal responsibility.
The authorities must examine the individual’s actual conduct.
Potentially.
A chief executive officer who personally directs or participates in criminal conduct may face investigation under the applicable provisions.
However, general oversight of the corporate group does not automatically establish criminal liability.
The relevant statutory elements must be proved.
Potentially.
Customs investigations may examine financial instructions, intercompany payments, and valuation practices.
However, responsibility depends on the individual’s actual conduct and the alleged offense.
The existence of a financial management role is not sufficient by itself.
Potentially, where the relevant statutory elements are satisfied.
However, a compliance officer is not automatically criminally responsible merely because a violation occurred.
The authorities must examine whether the person participated in the alleged offense or otherwise incurred responsibility under an applicable provision.
Potentially.
Procurement managers may negotiate prices and supplier arrangements affecting customs declarations.
However, ordinary procurement activity does not automatically constitute criminal conduct.
The investigation must establish the relevant conduct and mental element.
Potentially.
A logistics manager may be involved in shipping instructions, documentation, and customs coordination.
However, criminal responsibility requires more than involvement in routine transportation arrangements.
The statutory elements must be established.
Not automatically.
Share ownership does not independently establish participation in criminal conduct.
However, a shareholder who personally participates in an offense may face investigation.
The relevant evidence must be examined.
Potentially.
Investigators may examine whether individuals at the parent company deliberately instructed the subsidiary to submit false information.
However, the allegation must be supported by evidence.
A disagreement concerning customs valuation or tariff classification does not automatically constitute criminal fraud.
Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607 establishes criminal provisions concerning specified smuggling-related conduct.
Article 3 contains several offenses with different statutory elements.
The application depends on the alleged conduct.
Not every customs declaration error constitutes a smuggling offense.
Potentially, where the conduct satisfies the elements of a relevant criminal offense.
However, an ordinary valuation disagreement does not automatically establish smuggling.
The authorities must distinguish deliberate unlawful conduct from a technical customs dispute.
Potentially.
Customs authorities may examine whether related-party prices comply with applicable valuation rules.
However, related-party transactions are not inherently unlawful.
The existence of a corporate relationship does not automatically invalidate the declared customs value.
Criminal liability requires satisfaction of the relevant offense elements.
Potentially.
Investigators may examine whether foreign executives knowingly directed false declarations concerning transaction values.
However, the relevant evidence must establish the alleged conduct and required mental element.
The company should preserve intercompany pricing records and commercial agreements.
Potentially.
Certain royalty or license payments may be relevant to customs valuation under specified conditions.
Failure to include a legally required amount may create customs exposure.
However, a technical disagreement concerning royalty treatment does not automatically constitute a criminal offense.
Potentially.
Year-end transfer pricing adjustments may raise customs valuation questions.
However, tax transfer pricing and customs valuation are distinct legal frameworks.
The authorities must establish the relevant statutory elements before treating the matter as criminal conduct.
Potentially, where the relevant conduct satisfies a criminal offense.
However, tariff classification disputes frequently involve technical interpretation.
An incorrect classification does not automatically prove criminal intent.
Potentially.
The deliberate use of forged or false origin documents may raise criminal issues.
However, the legal consequences depend on the nature of the document and alleged conduct.
The importer should preserve authentic origin records.
Potentially.
Deliberately falsified commercial invoices may raise issues concerning document forgery, fraud, or smuggling-related offenses.
However, the applicable provisions depend on the facts.
The authorities must establish the relevant statutory elements.
Article 204 regulates forgery of official documents under specified conditions.
The provision may become relevant where an official document has been forged or altered.
However, the legal character of the document must be established.
Article 207 regulates forgery of private documents under specified conditions.
A falsified commercial document may raise issues under this provision where the statutory elements are satisfied.
However, not every inaccurate invoice constitutes private document forgery.
Potentially.
Investigators may examine whether foreign executives knowingly directed the use of forged permits.
However, the relevant conduct and mental element must be established.
The company should preserve authentic permit records.
Potentially.
Article 37 of the Turkish Penal Code regulates perpetration under specified circumstances.
Where multiple individuals jointly commit an offense, the provision may become relevant.
However, the statutory requirements must be established.
Article 37 addresses perpetration of criminal offenses.
The provision may become relevant where individuals jointly carry out conduct constituting an offense.
However, ordinary corporate cooperation does not automatically establish joint perpetration.
Potentially.
Article 38 of the Turkish Penal Code regulates instigation.
The provision may become relevant where an individual intentionally induces another person to commit an offense under the statutory conditions.
However, the relevant evidence must establish the required conduct.
Article 38 regulates instigation of criminal offenses.
The provision may become relevant where a person intentionally causes another to commit an offense.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Article 39 of the Turkish Penal Code regulates aiding the commission of criminal offenses.
The provision may become relevant where a person knowingly assists another in committing an offense.
However, ordinary commercial assistance does not automatically establish criminal participation.
Article 39 regulates aiding criminal offenses.
The provision identifies specified forms of assistance under the applicable conditions.
The authorities must establish the relevant conduct and mental element.
Potentially.
Emails, internal memoranda, meeting records, and electronic messages may be relevant.
However, the evidence must be obtained and evaluated in accordance with applicable procedural rules.
The context and meaning of the communications must be examined.
Potentially.
Investigators may examine whether group policies directed the relevant conduct.
However, the existence of a centralized compliance or procurement policy does not automatically establish criminal wrongdoing.
The policy’s content and implementation must be examined.
Potentially.
An internal audit may contain information relevant to the alleged customs violation.
However, the legal treatment of the report depends on applicable procedural and confidentiality rules.
The company should preserve authentic records and obtain appropriate legal analysis before disclosure.
Employees may state that they followed instructions from headquarters.
However, such statements do not automatically establish criminal responsibility of foreign executives.
The authorities must examine the evidence and statutory elements.
The parent company may argue that local management independently performed the disputed acts.
However, this position must be supported by relevant evidence.
The actual allocation of authority and decision-making should be examined.
The absence of knowledge may be important to offenses requiring intentional conduct.
However, the relevant statutory elements must be examined.
The company should preserve evidence concerning internal responsibilities and communications.
Potentially.
Turkish criminal jurisdiction may apply to specified conduct connected with Turkey.
However, the applicable jurisdictional and procedural requirements must be established.
Physical absence from Turkey does not automatically prevent investigation.
Potentially.
The authorities may examine conduct connected with an alleged offense in Turkey.
However, territorial jurisdiction and applicable criminal law rules must be considered.
The relevant facts must be established.
Article 8 regulates territorial application of Turkish criminal law.
The provision addresses circumstances in which an offense is considered committed in Turkey.
The application depends on the relevant conduct and statutory requirements.
Potentially.
Where the relevant procedural conditions are satisfied, investigators may seek a statement from a foreign director.
However, the procedure depends on the person’s status, location, and applicable criminal cooperation rules.
Potentially, where the applicable procedural and international cooperation framework permits it.
However, the availability of remote or international evidence-gathering procedures depends on the circumstances.
The competent authorities must follow applicable law.
Potentially, where a lawful arrest measure exists and the applicable conditions are satisfied.
However, the existence of a customs investigation does not automatically mean that every foreign executive faces arrest.
The relevant judicial decisions must be examined.
Potentially, where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
However, an international request is not automatic merely because a criminal investigation exists.
The relevant offense, judicial measures, and international cooperation rules must be examined.
Potentially.
International police cooperation may become relevant in certain criminal proceedings.
However, an Interpol notice is not automatically issued for every customs investigation.
The applicable requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Extradition depends on applicable treaties, domestic legislation, and the circumstances of the alleged offense.
However, the existence of an investigation does not automatically establish grounds for extradition.
Potentially, through applicable legal procedures.
However, cross-border evidence requests may involve international cooperation rules.
The company should examine the legal basis and scope of the request.
Potentially.
Searches must comply with applicable criminal procedure requirements.
The relevant judicial or statutory authorization must be examined.
The company should preserve records of the search.
Potentially, where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
The Criminal Procedure Code contains provisions concerning searches and seizures of computer data.
However, the applicable procedural safeguards must be observed.
Article 134 regulates specified searches, copying, and seizure concerning computers, computer programs, and computer records.
The provision contains procedural requirements.
The company should examine whether the relevant measure complied with applicable law.
Potentially, where the applicable procedural requirements are satisfied.
However, the scope and legality of access depend on the relevant authorization and statutory framework.
The company should preserve authentic records.
Potentially.
Electronic messages may be relevant to establishing instructions or communications.
However, the evidence must be lawfully obtained and properly evaluated.
The context and authenticity of the messages may be important.
Potentially, through the relevant procedural mechanisms and persons entitled to raise the objection.
Turkish criminal procedure contains safeguards concerning the legality of evidence.
However, the available remedy depends on the proceedings and procedural standing.
Not automatically.
Customs debt liability is determined under the applicable customs provisions.
The foreign parent company’s ownership of the subsidiary does not independently make it responsible for every customs debt.
However, the authorities may examine whether the parent company separately falls within a statutory liability category.
Article 181 regulates customs debt arising under specified import procedures.
The provision identifies the declarant as a person responsible for customs debt.
In indirect representation, the person on whose behalf the declaration is submitted may also become responsible.
Other persons may incur liability under specified statutory conditions.
Potentially, where an applicable statutory provision establishes responsibility.
However, corporate ownership alone does not automatically create liability for every customs penalty imposed on the subsidiary.
The legal basis must be examined.
Potentially.
Article 242 of Customs Law No. 4458 establishes an administrative objection framework for qualifying customs decisions.
The subsidiary may challenge unlawful assessments.
The relevant deadline must be respected.
Article 242 regulates administrative objections concerning qualifying customs decisions.
For decisions within its scope, the provision generally establishes a fifteen-day objection period from notification.
The subsidiary should identify the relevant decision and competent authority.
Potentially.
Customs duty and related penalty disputes generally fall within tax court jurisdiction.
The court may examine the relevant statutory provisions and evidence.
However, the subsidiary must comply with applicable procedural requirements.
No.
Criminal proceedings and customs collection are distinct.
The subsidiary should determine whether a legally effective suspension applies.
The existence of criminal allegations does not automatically eliminate customs debts.
Potentially.
Where the parent company or relevant individuals breached an applicable legal obligation and caused legally compensable damage, civil liability may require consideration.
However, the relevant statutory requirements must be established.
Potentially.
The relevant intercompany agreements and legal obligations should be examined.
However, the existence of an internal corporate instruction does not automatically establish a compensation claim.
The subsidiary must establish the relevant legal basis and loss.
Potentially.
Where local managers breached applicable duties and caused legally compensable damage, a civil claim may arise.
However, the relevant contractual and statutory requirements must be established.
Potentially.
Turkish Commercial Code provisions concerning directors’ duties and responsibility may become relevant.
However, the application depends on the company type and the individual’s legal role.
A compliance program may help prevent violations and establish clear responsibilities.
However, the existence of a compliance program does not automatically eliminate criminal responsibility for proven conduct.
The company should ensure that policies are implemented effectively.
A multinational customs compliance program may address tariff classification, customs valuation, origin documentation, import permits, internal approvals, and recordkeeping.
It should establish responsibilities between headquarters and local subsidiaries.
The program should also provide procedures for identifying and reporting potential violations.
Potentially.
Where credible allegations arise, an appropriately structured internal investigation may help establish the facts.
However, the investigation should comply with applicable legal requirements.
The company should preserve evidence and avoid interfering with official proceedings.
Potentially, where applicable legislation provides a lawful procedure.
However, the consequences depend on the relevant customs violation and procedural stage.
A voluntary disclosure does not automatically eliminate criminal or administrative liability.
Potentially.
Cooperation may involve providing relevant information through lawful procedures.
However, the company should understand its legal obligations and procedural rights.
The relevant criminal and customs frameworks must be examined.
The parent company should preserve corporate governance documents and relevant intercompany agreements.
The allocation of authority between headquarters and the Turkish subsidiary should be established.
Customs declarations, invoices, origin documents, valuation records, and technical specifications should be retained.
Emails, internal memoranda, meeting minutes, and electronic messages may establish how decisions were made.
The company should preserve relevant compliance policies, training records, and internal audit findings.
Any customs investigation notice, criminal procedural document, seizure decision, or administrative assessment should be obtained.
The group should preserve evidence concerning the identity and role of each individual involved.
A clear chronology should establish when the disputed customs transactions occurred, who provided instructions, when the alleged irregularities were discovered, and what corrective actions followed.
A foreign parent company accused of directing customs violations by its Turkish subsidiary should first identify the precise allegations and relevant statutory provisions.
The group should determine whether the matter concerns an administrative customs dispute, a criminal investigation, or both.
The relevant customs declarations and supporting documents should be obtained.
The company should establish which individuals prepared, approved, or submitted the disputed information.
The allocation of responsibilities between headquarters and the subsidiary should be examined.
Corporate communications and electronic records should be preserved without alteration.
The company should determine whether foreign directors or employees are individually identified in the investigation.
Any criminal procedural measures should be examined under the applicable law.
The subsidiary should separately evaluate whether customs assessments or penalties are legally valid.
Where Customs Law Article 242 applies, the relevant objection deadline should be calculated from legally effective notification.
The parent company should review its customs compliance policies and relevant intercompany arrangements.
Where the facts support corrective action, the company should evaluate lawful remediation measures.
Potential criminal, customs, corporate, and civil liabilities should be assessed separately.
All relevant procedural deadlines should be identified promptly.
1. Can a foreign parent company be criminally responsible for customs violations committed by its Turkish subsidiary?
Not automatically. Turkish criminal responsibility is generally personal, and the relevant statutory elements must be established concerning the individuals involved.
2. Can foreign directors face criminal investigation?
Potentially, where evidence supports their personal participation in an alleged offense.
3. Does owning a Turkish subsidiary automatically create criminal liability?
No. Corporate ownership alone does not establish criminal responsibility.
4. What does Turkish Penal Code Article 20 provide?
Article 20 establishes the principle of personal criminal responsibility and addresses the position of legal entities under criminal law.
5. Can instructions from foreign headquarters be used as evidence?
Potentially. Emails, messages, memoranda, and other records may be relevant if lawfully obtained and properly evaluated.
6. Can a foreign executive be accused of instigating customs smuggling?
Potentially, where the statutory requirements of the relevant offense and instigation provisions are satisfied.
7. Can Turkish authorities investigate conduct directed from abroad?
Potentially, where Turkish criminal jurisdiction and the applicable procedural requirements are established.
8. Can a foreign director be arrested when entering Turkey?
Potentially, where a lawful arrest measure exists and the relevant conditions are satisfied.
9. Can the Turkish subsidiary challenge customs penalties arising from the investigation?
Potentially. Article 242 of Customs Law No. 4458 establishes an objection framework for qualifying customs decisions.
10. What should a foreign parent company do first after being accused of directing customs violations?
Identify the allegations, preserve corporate and customs records, determine the individuals involved, examine criminal procedural risks, and protect customs objection and judicial deadlines.
Foreign parent companies and multinational groups facing allegations concerning customs violations by Turkish subsidiaries may require legal assistance involving Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607, Customs Law No. 4458, Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271, Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, corporate criminal investigations, customs smuggling allegations, director liability, cross-border evidence, international criminal cooperation, customs assessments, and corporate compliance disputes.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya provides legal assistance to foreign parent companies, multinational corporations, international manufacturers, trading groups, foreign directors, executives, and commercial investors facing disputes involving alleged customs fraud, smuggling investigations, corporate instructions, administrative penalties, and criminal liability risks.
At Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office, we assist foreign clients with examining customs and criminal investigation records, evaluating the responsibilities of foreign executives and Turkish subsidiaries, reviewing corporate communications and representation arrangements, protecting procedural rights during investigations, challenging unlawful customs assessments, and assessing appropriate criminal, administrative, and civil remedies.
Phone: 0312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: 0532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr