

What happens when a foreign company sells temporarily imported machinery in Turkey without customs clearance? Learn about customs duties, import VAT, penalties under Article 238, smuggling investigations, buyer liability, equipment seizure, and legal remedies.
Foreign construction companies, international engineering firms, industrial manufacturers, energy investors, and multinational corporations frequently bring machinery and specialized equipment into Turkey under the temporary admission procedure.
This customs procedure allows qualifying foreign-owned goods to enter Turkey for a limited period with total or partial relief from import duties, subject to specific legal conditions.
The equipment may include construction machinery, drilling systems, industrial generators, testing instruments, manufacturing equipment, exhibition machinery, and specialized technical devices.
Temporary admission is particularly useful for foreign companies performing short-term projects, installation services, testing operations, or construction activities.
However, temporarily imported equipment is not automatically authorized for unrestricted sale, transfer, rental, or permanent use in Turkey.
The equipment remains subject to the conditions of the customs procedure until those conditions are lawfully discharged.
Serious customs and criminal consequences may arise when a foreign company sells temporarily imported equipment to a Turkish buyer without first completing the necessary customs formalities.
For example, a foreign engineering company may temporarily import industrial machinery worth €1.5 million for an infrastructure project.
After completing the project, the company may decide that transporting the machinery back to its home country would be expensive.
A Turkish construction company may offer to purchase the equipment.
The foreign company may sign a sales agreement, receive payment, and physically deliver the machinery to the Turkish buyer.
However, the machinery may still be registered under the temporary admission procedure.
No declaration for release for free circulation may have been submitted, and the relevant customs duties and import VAT may remain unpaid.
During a subsequent customs inspection, the authorities may discover that the equipment has been transferred to a different company and is being used at another construction site.
The foreign seller may argue that it was unaware that the sale required customs clearance.
The Turkish buyer may contend that it purchased the machinery in good faith and believed that the seller had completed all customs formalities.
Nevertheless, the transaction may expose the parties to customs debt assessments, administrative penalties, restrictions on the equipment, and potentially criminal investigation.
What are the legal consequences when a foreign company sells temporarily imported equipment in Turkey without customs clearance?
The consequences depend on the original temporary admission authorization, the nature of the sale, whether possession or use was transferred, the applicable customs debt provisions, and whether the conduct satisfies the elements of an administrative violation or criminal offense.
Article 238 of Turkish Customs Law No. 4458 is particularly important because violations of temporary admission conditions may result in substantial administrative penalties.
Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607 may also become relevant where the facts satisfy a specific smuggling offense.
However, an unauthorized sale does not automatically establish criminal guilt.
The foreign seller, Turkish buyer, customs representative, and other participants must be assessed separately.
Turkish Customs Law No. 4458, Customs Regulation, Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607, Value Added Tax Law No. 3065, Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, and Administrative Judicial Procedure Law No. 2577 may become relevant.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that foreign companies should distinguish a private sales agreement, customs authorization to transfer goods, release for free circulation, customs debt, import VAT, administrative penalties, and personal criminal responsibility.
Yes, a sale may be possible where the relevant customs requirements are satisfied.
However, equipment under temporary admission cannot simply be treated as goods already in free circulation.
The seller must determine whether release for free circulation or another legally permitted customs procedure is necessary before completing the transaction.
The applicable authorization conditions must be examined.
An unauthorized sale or transfer may violate the conditions of temporary admission.
The legal consequences depend on the applicable statutory provisions and the nature of the transaction.
Customs duties, administrative penalties, and other measures may become relevant.
Criminal liability requires separate examination of the relevant offense.
Temporary admission permits qualifying goods to enter Turkey for a limited period with total or partial relief from import duties.
The procedure is subject to conditions concerning the identity, use, location, and customs treatment of the goods.
The authorization holder must ensure that the procedure is properly discharged.
Article 128 establishes the legal framework for temporary admission.
Qualifying goods may be admitted with total or partial relief from import duties under specified conditions.
However, the procedure does not automatically authorize unrestricted commercial disposal.
Not automatically.
Ownership of equipment and customs authorization to dispose of it are separate legal matters.
A foreign company may own machinery while remaining subject to restrictions concerning its use, transfer, and customs treatment.
Potentially.
A private agreement may establish contractual obligations between the seller and buyer.
However, signing the agreement does not automatically place the equipment in free circulation.
The parties should ensure that the agreed delivery and transfer arrangements comply with customs legislation.
Not necessarily.
The legal consequences depend on the contractual terms and what the parties actually do.
An agreement for a future sale conditional on lawful customs clearance differs from an unauthorized physical transfer or use.
The relevant facts must be examined.
Yes.
Physical delivery may demonstrate that the equipment was transferred outside the authorized conditions of temporary admission.
The authorities may examine whether the machinery remains under lawful customs supervision.
The buyer’s possession and use may also become relevant.
Not automatically.
The buyer must establish a lawful basis for possessing and using the equipment.
A private sales agreement does not independently authorize use contrary to temporary admission conditions.
The private-law consequences depend on the relevant agreement and applicable property law.
However, customs compliance must be examined separately.
A transaction cannot be assumed lawful merely because the machinery remains at its original location.
Potentially, where the applicable customs framework permits a transfer of the procedure and the required formalities are completed.
However, the buyer does not automatically become the authorization holder merely by purchasing the machinery.
Article 320 regulates transfers of rights and obligations under certain customs procedures.
Its provisions may permit the transfer of goods from one authorization holder to another under specified conditions.
For temporary admission, the receiving person may be required to place the goods under the procedure through an appropriate customs declaration.
However, the requirements must be satisfied before treating the transfer as lawful.
Potentially, where the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied.
However, eligibility for temporary admission may depend on the buyer’s status, intended use, and applicable relief provisions.
A domestic buyer is not automatically entitled to continue the same temporary admission arrangement.
Generally, once the equipment has been lawfully released for free circulation and all applicable restrictions are satisfied, the relevant customs barriers to an ordinary domestic sale may be removed.
However, other product-specific or contractual restrictions may still apply.
Release for free circulation is the customs procedure through which qualifying imported goods obtain the relevant customs status after compliance with applicable requirements.
This may involve payment of customs duties, import VAT, application of trade policy measures, and completion of required formalities.
Potentially.
The parties may arrange lawful customs clearance before physical delivery or another prohibited act occurs.
However, the legal consequences depend on whether a violation has already taken place.
Potentially.
The authorities may permit the equipment to be placed under an appropriate customs procedure after identifying a violation.
However, later clearance does not automatically eliminate customs duties, penalties, or other liabilities already incurred.
Not automatically.
Payment may address an underlying customs debt.
However, administrative penalties may remain applicable where the statutory elements of a violation are established.
The amount depends on the equipment’s tariff classification, customs value, origin, relevant customs debt date, and applicable legislation.
The authorities must identify the legal basis for the assessment.
The company should examine whether the correct duty rates and valuation elements have been applied.
Yes, where the applicable statutory conditions are satisfied.
Import VAT is governed by Value Added Tax Law No. 3065.
The parties should distinguish customs duties from import VAT and other import-related financial obligations.
Potentially.
Depending on the equipment and applicable legislation, other import-related taxes or financial measures may become relevant.
The company should examine the product’s tariff classification and import requirements.
Yes, where applicable.
Release for free circulation may require compliance with relevant trade policy measures.
The fact that equipment previously entered under temporary admission does not automatically exempt it from all requirements applicable to permanent importation.
Potentially.
Certain machinery and equipment may be subject to technical conformity, safety, or other regulatory requirements.
The importer should determine whether the equipment satisfies the applicable rules.
Potentially.
Used machinery may be subject to product-specific import requirements or restrictions.
The company should examine whether permanent importation is legally permitted before agreeing to a sale.
The parties may be unable to complete the proposed domestic sale through ordinary release for free circulation.
Alternative customs treatment may require consideration.
The seller should not assume that payment of customs duties alone resolves every regulatory restriction.
Article 193 addresses the time at which customs debt arises and the elements relevant to its calculation under specified circumstances.
The applicable duty rates and valuation elements depend on the relevant statutory rules.
The authorities must identify the correct customs debt date.
Potentially, depending on the applicable customs debt provision.
The company should examine whether the authorities have applied the correct date and calculation method.
The answer cannot be determined solely from the date of the private sale.
The sale price may be relevant in certain circumstances.
However, customs valuation is governed by specific statutory rules.
The price agreed between the foreign seller and Turkish buyer does not automatically determine the legally applicable customs value.
Potentially.
The authorities may examine whether the declared customs value complies with applicable valuation rules.
However, any adjustment must have a lawful basis.
Yes, where the relevant statutory requirements are satisfied.
Unauthorized sale or transfer may constitute a violation of temporary admission conditions.
The authorities must identify the applicable penalty provision and calculate the amount correctly.
Article 238 regulates penalties for specified violations involving customs procedures, including temporary admission.
For certain violations, the provision establishes penalties calculated by reference to the customs-cleared value of the goods.
However, the article contains different rules and exceptions.
The applicable paragraph must be identified before calculating the penalty.
Potentially.
Article 238(1)(a) provides for a penalty equal to twice the customs-cleared value in specified violations, subject to the statutory exceptions and relevant conditions.
However, that calculation should not automatically be applied to every temporary admission irregularity.
The relevant statutory concept concerns the value calculated under applicable customs legislation.
It is not necessarily identical to the private sales price.
The authorities must apply the legally required calculation method.
Potentially.
Article 241 regulates customs irregularity penalties and includes specified situations concerning temporary admission.
However, its application depends on the nature of the violation.
An unauthorized sale should not automatically be treated as a simple late re-export.
The transaction may still violate temporary admission conditions.
The fact that the original deadline has not expired does not automatically authorize a domestic sale.
The relevant transfer and customs clearance requirements must be examined.
The company may face additional issues concerning failure to discharge the procedure within the authorized period.
However, the authorities must identify the applicable statutory provisions.
The timing of the sale and the expiry of the authorization should be examined separately.
Potentially.
Customs debt and administrative penalties serve different legal functions.
However, each assessment must have a statutory basis.
The company should examine whether the amounts have been correctly calculated.
Potentially.
Interest may arise under the applicable customs debt provisions.
The relevant calculation period and rate must be established.
Potentially.
Temporary admission may involve a guarantee securing customs obligations.
Where the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied, the authorities may pursue that guarantee.
Potentially.
The company may seek release of the guarantee once the customs procedure has been properly discharged and relevant obligations have been resolved.
However, outstanding assessments may affect the outcome.
Potentially, where an applicable statutory basis exists.
The relevant measure may arise under customs enforcement or criminal procedure legislation.
However, unauthorized sale does not automatically justify every form of seizure.
Potentially.
Where the equipment is subject to a lawful customs or criminal measure, the buyer’s possession may be affected.
The buyer’s contractual and property rights must be examined separately.
Potentially, where the statutory requirements for confiscation or another forfeiture measure are satisfied.
However, confiscation is not automatic merely because customs clearance was omitted.
The relevant legal basis and procedural safeguards must be examined.
Potentially.
Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607 may apply where the conduct satisfies a specific statutory offense.
However, not every breach of temporary admission conditions constitutes criminal smuggling.
The authorities must establish the relevant conduct and mental elements.
Article 3 regulates multiple smuggling-related offenses.
Certain provisions concern goods imported under customs procedures involving conditional relief or restrictions.
However, the applicable paragraph and statutory elements must be identified.
A general allegation of unauthorized sale is not a substitute for establishing a specific criminal offense.
Potentially.
The authorities may investigate whether the foreign company acted through individuals who knowingly participated in conduct constituting an offense.
However, criminal responsibility must be assessed individually.
Potentially.
The buyer’s knowledge, conduct, and participation may become relevant.
However, purchasing equipment that was temporarily imported does not automatically establish criminal guilt.
Criminal liability depends on the applicable offense and its statutory elements.
A buyer’s knowledge and intent may be important.
The authorities must evaluate the evidence concerning the buyer’s actual conduct.
The seller may explain its understanding of the transaction.
However, lack of knowledge does not automatically eliminate every administrative or customs consequence.
Criminal responsibility requires a separate assessment of the relevant mental element and statutory requirements.
Potentially, where evidence establishes personal participation in a criminal offense.
However, corporate title alone does not establish criminal responsibility.
Article 20 establishes the principle of personal criminal responsibility.
It also provides that criminal penalties cannot be imposed on legal entities, although statutory security measures may apply under specified conditions.
The foreign company’s administrative or civil obligations must be distinguished from individual criminal liability.
Potentially, where the relevant individuals knowingly participated in conduct satisfying a criminal offense.
However, their position as directors does not automatically establish guilt.
Potentially.
A customs broker may be investigated where evidence supports knowing participation in unlawful conduct.
However, the broker’s statutory and contractual role must be examined.
Potentially.
A logistics provider may face consequences where it participated in an unauthorized transfer or breached an applicable obligation.
However, ordinary transportation services do not automatically establish criminal responsibility.
Potentially.
Where false customs documents, invoices, or other qualifying documents were deliberately created or used, forgery provisions may become relevant.
However, the statutory elements must be established.
Potentially.
False declarations may create separate customs and criminal issues.
The authorities must identify the relevant statutory provisions.
Potentially.
The legal consequences depend on the nature of the document, its use, and the relevant statutory elements.
The company should preserve the original commercial records.
Potentially, where the facts support a specific offense under applicable tax legislation.
However, failure to complete customs clearance does not automatically establish every form of tax crime.
The relevant tax and criminal provisions must be examined.
Potentially.
The buyer’s role and conduct may create customs debt exposure under specified statutory provisions.
However, liability is not established solely because the buyer purchased the equipment.
Potentially.
The authorization holder’s customs obligations do not automatically disappear when a private sale occurs.
The relevant customs procedure must be lawfully discharged.
The parties may allocate certain financial responsibilities between themselves.
However, a private agreement does not automatically transfer statutory customs obligations.
The relevant customs authority must recognize any transfer where required.
Potentially.
The sales agreement may require the seller to deliver equipment lawfully cleared for domestic use.
Where that obligation is breached, contractual remedies may become available.
Potentially.
The buyer may possess remedies where the seller cannot lawfully perform the agreed transaction.
However, the applicable contract and statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
Where the agreement is validly terminated or another restitution basis exists, recovery may be available.
However, the relevant legal requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Where the seller breached an applicable contractual obligation and caused legally compensable loss, a reimbursement claim may arise.
However, the enforceability of the claim depends on the circumstances and applicable law.
Potentially.
The buyer may have contractual or other claims against the seller.
However, the relevant breach, damage, and causal relationship must be established.
Potentially.
The buyer may lose commercial opportunities because the machinery cannot lawfully be used.
However, speculative expectations are not automatically compensable.
Potentially.
Seizure or unavailability of machinery may interrupt production or construction activities.
However, the claimant must establish legally compensable damage.
Article 112 regulates liability arising from non-performance or improper performance of contractual obligations.
The provision may become relevant where the seller breaches an obligation concerning lawful delivery or customs clearance.
The relevant statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Where the broker breached an applicable contractual or professional obligation and caused legally compensable damage, a claim may arise.
However, the seller’s own statutory customs obligations must be examined separately.
Potentially.
The sales agreement may allocate responsibility for customs clearance or other expenses.
However, private contractual allocation does not automatically eliminate statutory liability toward customs authorities.
Potentially, where the relevant contract provides a valid basis for reimbursement.
However, the parties must distinguish legally due customs duties from penalties arising from unlawful conduct.
Potentially.
The parties may seek to regularize the equipment’s customs status through an available procedure.
However, corrective action does not automatically eliminate earlier customs violations or criminal exposure.
Where the machinery is being used contrary to the temporary admission conditions, continued use may create additional risks.
The parties should identify the equipment’s current customs status and obtain appropriate legal guidance before further movement or use.
Potentially.
The relevant customs procedure may permit disclosure or corrective applications.
However, the legal consequences depend on the applicable provisions and timing.
Voluntary disclosure does not automatically guarantee immunity from penalties or prosecution.
Potentially.
However, the seller must establish lawful possession and complete the applicable customs procedure.
The buyer’s contractual rights and any customs restrictions must also be examined.
Potentially, where the relevant customs procedure permits it.
However, the buyer must possess the necessary authority and comply with applicable customs requirements.
Potentially.
The equipment may be released for free circulation where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
However, any earlier violation must be addressed separately.
Potentially.
The seller may dispute whether the customs debt arose under the provision applied and whether the amount was correctly calculated.
The relevant customs records and transaction documents must be examined.
Potentially.
The seller may challenge the legal basis, classification of the violation, and calculation of the penalty.
The relevant statutory requirements must be established.
Article 242 regulates administrative objections concerning qualifying customs decisions.
For decisions within its scope, the provision generally establishes a fifteen-day objection period from notification.
The relevant person must identify the competent authority and comply with the applicable procedure.
Potentially.
Article 244 of Customs Law No. 4458 regulates settlement concerning qualifying customs duties and penalties.
However, settlement is subject to statutory conditions.
The company should examine whether settlement is available and appropriate.
Potentially.
Customs duty and related penalty disputes generally fall within tax court jurisdiction.
The court may examine the statutory basis and evidence supporting the assessment.
Potentially.
Article 27 of Administrative Judicial Procedure Law No. 2577 regulates stays of execution and contains special provisions concerning tax litigation.
The applicable rules depend on the disputed decision.
Potentially.
Where the machinery is seized during criminal proceedings, the applicable Criminal Procedure Code remedies must be examined.
An administrative customs objection does not automatically replace a criminal procedural challenge.
Potentially.
The competent authority may consider return where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
However, the customs status and criminal proceedings must be examined.
Potentially.
Where a valid arbitration agreement exists, the private contractual dispute may fall within its scope.
However, arbitration does not automatically annul customs penalties or criminal measures.
Potentially.
The competent court depends on the nature of the contractual dispute and applicable procedural rules.
The relevant sales agreement and governing law must be examined.
The foreign seller should preserve the original temporary admission authorization, customs declaration, and equipment identification documents.
The purchase agreement, commercial invoice, equipment lease, and project contract should be retained.
The parties should preserve the sales agreement and all correspondence concerning the proposed transfer.
Payment records, bank transfers, delivery notes, and transportation documents may establish when the transaction occurred.
The equipment’s serial numbers, location, condition, and current user should be documented.
Any customs broker instructions, declarations, or applications should be obtained.
The parties should preserve evidence concerning who was responsible for customs clearance under the agreement.
Any customs assessment, penalty decision, guarantee claim, seizure order, or administrative correspondence should be retained.
Financial statements, customer contracts, and records of business interruption may support compensation claims.
A clear chronology should establish when the equipment entered Turkey, when the sale was agreed, when possession changed, and when the customs authorities identified the transaction.
A foreign company discovering that temporarily imported equipment was sold without customs clearance should first identify the original temporary admission authorization.
The company should determine whether the equipment remains in Turkey and who currently possesses it.
The relevant customs procedure and authorization conditions should be examined.
The seller should establish whether a private sales agreement was signed and whether physical delivery occurred.
The equipment’s location, identity, and current use should be documented.
The company should preserve all commercial and customs records.
Any further transfer or use contrary to the applicable customs conditions should be avoided.
The seller and buyer should determine whether lawful release for free circulation or another customs-approved treatment remains available.
Potential customs duties, import VAT, interest, administrative penalties, and guarantee exposure should be assessed separately.
The applicability of Customs Law Article 238 should be examined.
Where the facts suggest a potential offense under Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607, criminal procedural risks should be evaluated.
Any customs assessment or penalty should be reviewed for legal and calculation errors.
Where Customs Law Article 242 applies, the objection deadline should be calculated from legally effective notification.
The parties should examine their contractual rights concerning customs clearance, reimbursement, cancellation, and compensation.
All relevant customs, tax, criminal procedural, contractual, and judicial deadlines should be identified promptly.
1. Can a foreign company sell temporarily imported machinery in Turkey?
Potentially, where the applicable customs requirements are satisfied. A domestic sale generally requires examination of release for free circulation or another legally permitted customs procedure.
2. Is it illegal to sell temporarily imported equipment without customs clearance?
An unauthorized sale or transfer may violate temporary admission conditions and create customs, administrative, or criminal consequences depending on the circumstances.
3. Can customs authorities impose a penalty equal to twice the customs-cleared value?
Potentially. Customs Law Article 238(1)(a) provides such a penalty for specified violations, subject to statutory exceptions and conditions.
4. Does paying customs duties after the sale automatically eliminate the penalty?
No. Payment of duties does not automatically extinguish an administrative violation.
5. Can the Turkish buyer be responsible for customs debt?
Potentially, where an applicable statutory provision establishes responsibility based on the buyer’s role or conduct.
6. Can the unauthorized sale constitute smuggling?
Potentially, where the conduct satisfies a specific offense under Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607. Criminal liability is not automatic.
7. Can customs authorities seize the machinery?
Potentially, where the applicable statutory requirements for detention, seizure, or another measure are satisfied.
8. Can the parties complete customs clearance after discovering the violation?
Potentially. However, subsequent clearance does not automatically eliminate earlier customs duties, penalties, or criminal risks.
9. Can the seller challenge customs penalties?
Potentially. Article 242 of Customs Law No. 4458 generally establishes a fifteen-day objection period for qualifying customs decisions.
10. What should a foreign company do immediately after discovering an unauthorized sale?
Identify the equipment and its customs status, preserve transaction documents, prevent further unauthorized movement, examine lawful customs regularization, assess financial and criminal exposure, and protect applicable deadlines.
Foreign companies facing customs investigations concerning unauthorized sales of temporarily imported equipment may require legal assistance involving Customs Law No. 4458, Customs Regulation, Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607, Value Added Tax Law No. 3065, Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, temporary admission violations, customs debt, Article 238 penalties, equipment seizure, criminal investigations, contractual disputes, and compensation claims.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya provides legal assistance to foreign construction companies, international engineering firms, industrial manufacturers, energy investors, multinational corporations, equipment owners, Turkish commercial buyers, and international trading businesses facing disputes involving temporary admission violations and unauthorized machinery sales.
At Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office, we assist foreign clients with reviewing temporary admission authorizations, examining equipment sales and transfer arrangements, evaluating customs duty and VAT exposure, challenging unlawful customs penalties, assessing potential smuggling allegations, and pursuing appropriate administrative and judicial remedies.
We also assist foreign companies with disputes involving customs brokers, equipment purchasers, machinery leasing arrangements, contract termination, reimbursement obligations, and compensation for commercial losses.
Phone: 0312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: 0532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr