

What happens when imported raw materials are lost, wasted, damaged, or destroyed during manufacturing under Turkey’s inward processing regime? Learn about normal production loss, customs duties, export commitments, force majeure, penalties, guarantees, and legal remedies.
Foreign manufacturers, multinational production companies, international suppliers, and export-oriented industrial businesses frequently import raw materials into Turkey under the inward processing regime.
This customs regime enables qualifying companies to import materials for manufacturing and subsequent export under specified customs conditions.
Depending on the authorization, the imported materials may benefit from suspension of import duties against a guarantee or from a drawback mechanism under which qualifying duties may be repaid following export.
The regime is particularly important for manufacturers operating in the automotive, textile, chemical, food processing, electronics, metalworking, plastics, and industrial machinery sectors.
However, manufacturing processes do not always convert every kilogram or unit of imported raw material into a finished export product.
Some materials may be lost through evaporation, drying, cutting, leakage, chemical reactions, or other ordinary production processes.
Other materials may become defective, contaminated, damaged, or unusable because of technical failures, industrial accidents, fires, or flooding.
In some situations, a manufacturer may discover that substantial quantities of imported materials cannot be accounted for.
These circumstances create different customs consequences.
For example, a foreign-owned manufacturing company may import 500 tons of industrial raw materials under an inward processing certificate.
The company may use the materials to manufacture components intended for export.
During production, 20 tons may be lost through ordinary technical processes, including cutting and evaporation.
A further 30 tons may become unusable because of a malfunction in the production system.
During a customs inspection, the authorities may question whether the total loss is consistent with the authorized production process.
The manufacturer may argue that part of the loss constitutes normal production waste and that the remaining materials were destroyed during an unforeseen technical incident.
Customs authorities may examine whether the claimed quantities are supported by production records, whether the relevant losses were authorized, and whether customs duties or penalties are payable.
In another situation, a company may record imported materials as production waste even though those materials were actually transferred to another manufacturer or sold domestically.
Such conduct may create substantially different legal risks.
Are customs duties and penalties payable when imported raw materials are lost during production under Turkey’s inward processing regime?
Not automatically.
The legal consequences depend on whether the loss constitutes recognized normal production loss, recoverable waste, a secondary processed product, accidental destruction, irretrievable loss, or an unexplained inventory shortage.
The inward processing framework expressly recognizes certain losses arising naturally during manufacturing.
However, the company must establish that the claimed loss corresponds to the authorized processing activity and applicable technical or regulatory requirements.
Where materials are destroyed by force majeure or unforeseeable circumstances, separate customs relief provisions may become relevant.
Where imported materials disappear without adequate explanation, customs authorities may investigate whether the inward processing conditions have been violated.
Turkish Customs Law No. 4458, Inward Processing Regime Decision No. 2005/8391, Inward Processing Regime Communiqué No. 2006/12, Customs Regulation, Value Added Tax Law No. 3065, and Administrative Judicial Procedure Law No. 2577 may apply.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that foreign manufacturers should distinguish normal production loss, recoverable manufacturing scrap, secondary processed products, accidental destruction, unexplained shortages, export commitment discharge, customs debt, and administrative penalties.
The inward processing regime allows qualifying companies to import goods for processing and subsequent export under specified conditions.
The regime may provide relief from import duties, subject to the relevant authorization and discharge requirements.
Manufacturers must maintain records linking imported inputs to authorized processing activities and exported products.
Normal production loss refers to material consumed or lost through the inherent characteristics of an authorized manufacturing process.
Examples may include evaporation, drying, leakage, or other unavoidable physical changes.
The legal treatment depends on the relevant production process and applicable rules.
A manufacturer cannot automatically classify every missing material as normal production loss.
The Inward Processing Regime Communiqué recognizes losses occurring during processing, particularly through drying, evaporation, leakage, or gas escape, together with waste having no economic value.
This definition is important because genuine production loss may be treated differently from recoverable scrap or unexplained shortages.
The company should establish the technical basis for the claimed loss.
Not necessarily.
Different industries have different production characteristics.
Some processes naturally involve substantial material loss, while others may produce little or no unavoidable loss.
The relevant authorization, technical specifications, and production records must be examined.
Potentially.
The authorities may question whether the claimed quantity is consistent with the authorized manufacturing process.
The manufacturer should provide technical evidence supporting the loss.
However, rejection must have an appropriate legal and factual basis.
Normal production loss may involve materials that disappear or become economically worthless through the processing operation.
Manufacturing scrap may remain physically identifiable and possess commercial value.
The distinction can affect customs treatment, inventory accounting, and export commitment discharge.
Potentially.
However, metal offcuts may retain commercial value and qualify as scrap or secondary processed products rather than economically worthless loss.
The company should establish the quantity, condition, and value of the material.
Potentially.
Evaporation may be an inherent characteristic of certain chemical or industrial processes.
The manufacturer should preserve technical production data and material balance calculations.
Potentially.
Drying may reduce the weight of agricultural or food products during processing.
However, the relevant loss must be supported by the applicable production characteristics and records.
Potentially.
The applicable inward processing framework recognizes certain losses through gas escape.
However, the manufacturer must distinguish ordinary process-related loss from avoidable leakage caused by defective equipment or improper handling.
Potentially.
Textile production may generate cutting waste and other residual materials.
However, the customs treatment depends on whether the materials have economic value and how they are classified under the applicable rules.
Potentially.
Plastic production may generate residual materials, defective items, and reusable scrap.
The manufacturer must distinguish unavoidable loss from materials that can be recovered or reused.
Potentially.
Automotive manufacturing may generate metal, plastic, and other production residues.
However, recoverable scrap may require separate accounting and customs treatment.
Potentially.
Electronic production may generate defective components and residual materials.
The relevant customs treatment depends on their condition, value, and applicable rules.
A secondary processed product is a product obtained during processing other than the principal finished product.
Such products may possess economic value.
The company should distinguish secondary products from normal production loss.
Potentially.
However, the relevant customs and tax requirements must be satisfied.
The company should not assume that residual materials produced from imported inputs are automatically in free circulation.
Potentially.
The relevant customs procedure may permit export or re-export of qualifying residual materials.
However, the necessary formalities must be completed.
Potentially.
Where the applicable customs framework permits destruction, the company may seek authorization.
However, disposal must comply with relevant customs and environmental requirements.
Potentially.
The company should establish whether reuse is permitted under the authorization and applicable production accounting rules.
Accurate inventory records are important.
Potentially.
However, transfer of goods or materials subject to inward processing obligations may require authorization or another lawful customs procedure.
A private commercial arrangement does not automatically discharge customs obligations.
The company should establish the cause and extent of destruction.
Customs Law Article 186 and relevant inward processing provisions may become important.
However, the statutory conditions must be satisfied.
Article 186 addresses specified circumstances involving destruction or irretrievable loss of goods.
Where non-compliance with a customs obligation results from qualifying destruction or loss caused by the nature of the goods, unforeseeable circumstances, force majeure, or customs authorization, the provision may prevent an import customs debt from arising.
However, the company must establish the relevant statutory conditions.
Irretrievable loss concerns goods rendered unusable under the relevant customs framework.
The company must establish the actual condition of the materials.
A reduction in market value alone does not automatically establish irretrievable loss.
Potentially.
Where imported materials are destroyed by fire, the relevant statutory provisions concerning destruction or force majeure may apply.
However, the cause of the fire and supporting evidence must be examined.
Potentially.
Extraordinary flooding may cause irretrievable loss of imported materials.
However, the company must establish the relevant legal and factual requirements.
Potentially.
A sudden technical failure may be relevant where the applicable legal criteria are satisfied.
However, ordinary maintenance failures or preventable operational problems may affect the analysis.
Potentially.
The authorities may examine whether the loss resulted from qualifying circumstances or from a failure to comply with customs obligations.
The company’s administrative responsibility must be distinguished from the employee’s individual conduct.
Potentially.
Unauthorized destruction may violate inward processing conditions.
However, the relevant customs debt and penalty provisions must be established.
The company should not assume that it may dispose of materials subject to customs obligations without authorization.
The relevant customs procedure should be examined before destruction.
Potentially.
Article 38 of Inward Processing Regime Communiqué No. 2006/12 contains rules relevant to destruction, abandonment, or return of goods under customs supervision within the applicable authorization period.
Where the statutory conditions are satisfied, the corresponding export commitment may not be required.
However, the relevant procedure and evidence must be established.
Potentially.
Where the applicable inward processing provisions permit replacement imports following qualifying destruction or loss, the company may seek authorization.
However, replacement is not automatic.
Potentially.
The relevant inward processing provisions recognize specified force majeure circumstances.
However, the company must provide the required evidence and satisfy the applicable procedural conditions.
Certain provisions of Communiqué No. 2006/12 require court-based evidence preservation for specified force majeure or extraordinary-event claims.
The company should examine the applicable procedure before relying solely on an internal report.
The competent authority must be notified where required.
Not automatically.
An insurance survey may provide useful technical evidence.
However, where the applicable customs provision requires a particular form of evidence preservation, the company must comply with that requirement.
Potentially.
Customs authorities may inspect remaining raw materials, scrap, or damaged goods under applicable supervision powers.
The manufacturer should preserve the relevant evidence.
Yes, where the applicable statutory framework authorizes examination of relevant records.
Production data may establish the relationship between imported materials, finished products, and claimed losses.
Potentially.
Material balance reports may help establish how much imported material entered production and what quantities became finished products, scrap, or loss.
The company should maintain accurate and consistent records.
Potentially.
Technical expertise may be necessary where the alleged production loss is disputed.
The company should identify qualified experts familiar with the relevant manufacturing process.
Potentially.
An internal report may be insufficient where the authorities require additional evidence.
However, the administration should evaluate relevant supporting documents under the applicable rules.
Potentially.
The company may seek an amendment or challenge an incorrect technical determination through the applicable procedure.
However, the relevant authorization and sector-specific rules must be examined.
Yes.
Different manufacturing processes involve different physical and technical characteristics.
The applicable production loss assessment should reflect the relevant process and authorization.
Potentially.
The inward processing framework includes sector-specific guidance for certain industries.
The manufacturer should identify the rules applicable to its products and production process.
An unexplained shortage may create customs compliance concerns.
The authorities may investigate whether the materials were lost, stolen, sold, transferred, or consumed outside the authorized process.
The company should establish the facts before classifying the shortage.
Potentially.
Where the evidence establishes unauthorized domestic use or disposal, customs debt and penalty provisions may apply.
However, an inventory discrepancy alone does not automatically establish every alleged violation.
Potentially.
The applicable customs debt provisions may become relevant where inward processing obligations are not satisfied.
However, the authorities must identify the statutory basis and relevant quantities.
Potentially.
Where the relevant conditions for customs relief are not satisfied, duties may become payable.
However, the assessment should distinguish legally recognized production loss from materials that remain subject to outstanding obligations.
Potentially.
Import VAT consequences depend on the applicable customs and tax provisions.
The company should examine Value Added Tax Law No. 3065 and the relevant customs treatment.
Potentially.
Depending on the materials and applicable legislation, additional import-related taxes or measures may become relevant.
The authorities must establish the legal basis.
Potentially.
Where duties become collectible because inward processing obligations were not satisfied, applicable interest may arise.
The relevant statutory basis, calculation period, and rate must be established.
Potentially.
Under the conditional suspension system, guarantees secure specified customs obligations.
Where those obligations become enforceable, the authorities may pursue the guarantee.
Potentially.
Where the relevant obligations have been lawfully discharged in part, partial release may be available under applicable rules.
The company must establish the qualifying quantities and supporting evidence.
Potentially.
Where part of the imported materials has been incorporated into lawfully exported products, the relevant discharge rules may permit recognition of that portion.
However, the company must establish the relevant input-output relationship.
Recognized production loss may be accounted for under the applicable inward processing framework.
However, the company must establish that the loss is consistent with the authorized processing activity and applicable technical requirements.
Not automatically.
The authorities may require evidence distinguishing normal loss, scrap, secondary products, and unexplained shortages.
Unsupported classification may create customs risks.
Potentially.
The applicable legislation may permit amendments concerning production quantities, input-output ratios, or other authorization conditions.
However, approval is not automatic.
Potentially.
The inward processing framework provides for extensions under specified circumstances.
However, the company must identify the applicable deadline and statutory conditions.
Potentially.
The manufacturer may dispute the quantities, classification of the loss, customs value, duty rates, or interest calculation.
The relevant production and customs records must be examined.
Potentially.
Failure to comply with inward processing conditions may result in penalties under Customs Law No. 4458.
However, the relevant statutory violation must be established.
Article 238 regulates penalties for specified violations involving customs procedures, including inward processing.
The applicable penalty depends on the relevant paragraph and circumstances.
The provision distinguishes certain cases where goods remain under customs supervision from other violations.
Potentially.
Article 241 regulates customs irregularity penalties.
However, not every production loss or inward processing violation falls within the same penalty category.
The relevant statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
The company may challenge the classification of the violation, the calculation, and the supporting evidence.
The authorities must establish the relevant statutory elements.
Article 242 regulates administrative objections concerning qualifying customs decisions.
For decisions within its scope, the provision generally establishes a fifteen-day objection period from notification.
The company should identify the competent authority and preserve the deadline.
Potentially.
Article 244 regulates settlement concerning qualifying customs duties and penalties.
However, settlement is subject to statutory conditions and procedural requirements.
Potentially.
Customs duty and associated penalty disputes generally fall within tax court jurisdiction.
The court may examine the legality of the assessment and supporting evidence.
Potentially.
Article 27 of Administrative Judicial Procedure Law No. 2577 regulates stays of execution and contains special provisions concerning tax litigation.
The applicable rules depend on the disputed decision.
Potentially.
Where duties were collected contrary to applicable legislation, repayment or remission may be available under specified conditions.
The relevant statutory requirements and deadlines must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Where the facts support suspected smuggling, theft, document forgery, or another offense, criminal proceedings may become relevant.
However, ordinary manufacturing loss does not automatically constitute criminal conduct.
Potentially.
Deliberately falsified records may raise criminal issues where the statutory elements are satisfied.
However, an inaccurate technical calculation does not automatically establish criminal guilt.
Potentially, where evidence establishes their personal participation in a criminal offense.
However, corporate title alone does not establish criminal responsibility.
Potentially.
Where defective equipment caused material loss and the supplier breached an applicable obligation, compensation may become available.
However, the relevant contract, technical evidence, and causal relationship must be examined.
Potentially.
Where negligent maintenance caused legally compensable loss, a contractual or tort claim may arise.
The relevant breach and evidence must be established.
Potentially.
Where a subcontractor caused loss of imported materials through breach of an applicable obligation, compensation may be available.
However, the relevant contractual and statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Property insurance may cover specified physical losses affecting raw materials.
However, coverage depends on the insured risks, exclusions, deductibles, and policy conditions.
Potentially.
Machinery breakdown insurance may cover specified equipment damage.
However, coverage for consequential raw material losses depends on the relevant policy wording.
Potentially.
Where an insured event interrupts production, business interruption coverage may become relevant.
However, the policy conditions must be satisfied.
Not automatically.
Insurance compensation and customs debt are separate legal matters.
The manufacturer must establish the relevant customs treatment independently.
The manufacturer should preserve the inward processing certificate or customs authorization and all amendments.
Import declarations, commercial invoices, packing lists, and transportation documents should be retained.
Production records, material balance reports, stock ledgers, and input-output calculations should establish how imported materials were used.
Technical reports should explain the manufacturing process and expected production loss.
The company should preserve records concerning scrap, secondary processed products, and reusable materials.
Where an accident occurred, official reports, photographs, maintenance records, and engineering assessments may be important.
Any customs inspection report, assessment, penalty notice, or guarantee claim should be obtained.
The manufacturer should preserve evidence concerning customs-supervised destruction or authorized disposal.
Insurance policies, claim notifications, and loss adjuster reports may support the relevant claims.
Customer contracts, replacement purchase invoices, and production interruption records may establish commercial losses.
A clear chronology should identify when the materials were imported, when production occurred, when the loss was discovered, and what corrective action followed.
A foreign manufacturer discovering that imported raw materials have been lost during production should first identify the relevant inward processing authorization.
The company should determine the quantity and identity of the missing materials.
A physical inventory reconciliation should be performed.
The manufacturer should distinguish normal production loss from recoverable scrap, secondary processed products, accidental destruction, and unexplained shortages.
Technical production records should be preserved.
Where an accident or extraordinary event caused the loss, official and independent evidence should be obtained.
The company should determine whether Customs Law Article 186 or the relevant inward processing force majeure provisions apply.
Any required customs notification, evidence preservation, or destruction procedure should be examined.
The company should not sell, transfer, or dispose of residual materials without addressing applicable customs requirements.
The impact on the export commitment should be calculated.
Potential customs duties, import VAT, interest, administrative penalties, and guarantee exposure should be assessed separately.
Any customs assessment should be examined for incorrect treatment of recognized production loss.
Where Customs Law Article 242 applies, the objection deadline should be calculated from legally effective notification.
Potential insurance and contractual compensation claims should be evaluated.
All relevant customs, administrative, contractual, insurance, and judicial deadlines should be identified promptly.
1. Are customs duties payable when imported raw materials are lost during production under the inward processing regime?
Not automatically. The answer depends on whether the loss is recognized as normal production loss, qualifying destruction, or an unexplained shortage.
2. What is normal production loss under the inward processing regime?
It includes specified losses occurring during processing, such as drying, evaporation, leakage, or gas escape, together with economically worthless waste.
3. Can metal scrap or plastic waste be treated as normal production loss?
Potentially, but recoverable materials with economic value may require separate treatment as scrap or secondary processed products.
4. Can customs authorities reject an excessive production loss claim?
Potentially. The company must support the claimed quantity with appropriate technical and production evidence.
5. Can raw materials destroyed by fire or flooding qualify for customs relief?
Potentially. Customs Law Article 186 and the relevant inward processing provisions may apply where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
6. Can the manufacturer obtain replacement imports for destroyed materials?
Potentially, where the applicable inward processing rules permit replacement following qualifying destruction or loss.
7. Can unexplained material shortages create customs debt?
Potentially. The authorities must establish the relevant customs debt provision and supporting facts.
8. Can customs authorities impose penalties under Article 238?
Potentially, where a qualifying inward processing violation is established. The applicable paragraph and statutory conditions must be examined.
9. Can the manufacturer challenge customs duties assessed on production waste?
Potentially. Article 242 of Customs Law No. 4458 establishes an objection framework for qualifying customs decisions.
10. What should a foreign manufacturer do immediately after discovering material loss?
Reconcile inventory, classify the loss, preserve technical evidence, examine customs relief and discharge rules, calculate financial exposure, and protect applicable deadlines.
Foreign manufacturers facing customs disputes concerning imported raw materials lost during production may require legal assistance involving Customs Law No. 4458, Inward Processing Regime Decision No. 2005/8391, Inward Processing Regime Communiqué No. 2006/12, Customs Regulation, Value Added Tax Law No. 3065, normal production loss, manufacturing scrap, secondary processed products, force majeure, customs debt, export commitment discharge, guarantees, and administrative penalties.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya provides legal assistance to foreign manufacturers, multinational production companies, international suppliers, export-oriented businesses, industrial investors, and commercial operators facing disputes involving inward processing authorizations, raw material shortages, production losses, customs assessments, and commercial damages.
At Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office, we assist foreign clients with examining inward processing authorizations, reviewing production loss calculations, evaluating customs-supervised destruction and force majeure claims, reconciling imported inputs and exported products, challenging unlawful customs assessments, and pursuing administrative and judicial remedies.
We also assist foreign companies with disputes involving defective machinery, subcontracted manufacturing, industrial accidents, insurance coverage, customs guarantees, and compensation for material losses.
Phone: 0312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: 0532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr