

Received a shipment from Turkey with missing products or fewer goods than ordered? Learn about CISG short delivery, evidence, carrier liability, refunds, replacement goods, damages, customs records and legal remedies against Turkish suppliers.
A foreign buyer who discovers missing products in a shipment from Turkey may face substantial financial losses, disrupted supply chains, delayed customer deliveries, and serious commercial disputes with Turkish manufacturers, exporters, freight forwarders, and transport companies.
International businesses frequently purchase textiles, machinery, automotive components, furniture, electronics, industrial materials, food products, packaging, and consumer goods from Turkish suppliers.
These transactions commonly involve purchase orders, commercial invoices, packing lists, shipping documents, customs declarations, and international transport arrangements.
The foreign buyer expects the supplier to deliver the agreed quantity of products.
However, disputes may arise when the shipment contains fewer goods than ordered or when particular products are missing entirely.
For example, a foreign wholesaler may order 5,000 garments from a Turkish manufacturer but receive only 4,300 units.
In another case, an international distributor may purchase 200 machinery components, only to discover that several expensive parts are missing from the delivered containers.
More serious situations may involve missing pallets, incomplete cartons, substituted products, discrepancies between packing lists and actual contents, unauthorized removal of goods during transportation, or shipments that were never fully loaded.
The foreign buyer may discover the shortage during customs inspection, warehouse unloading, inventory counting, or subsequent customer deliveries.
The Turkish supplier may claim that the full quantity was dispatched.
The freight forwarder may argue that the shipment was received in sealed containers.
The carrier may deny responsibility, while the buyer may face pressure from customers demanding immediate delivery.
These circumstances raise important legal questions.
Who is responsible when products are missing from a shipment originating in Turkey? Can the buyer demand delivery of the missing goods? Can the buyer recover part of the purchase price? Can the buyer claim compensation for lost profits, replacement purchases, storage expenses, and customer penalties? What evidence is required to establish a shortage? Does the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods apply?
Under Turkish law and applicable international sales rules, a supplier that delivers fewer goods than contractually agreed may be responsible for incomplete performance. However, liability depends on the contract, delivery terms, risk allocation, evidence, and applicable legal framework.
For qualifying international sales, the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) may apply.
Article 30 establishes the seller’s principal delivery obligations.
Article 35 requires goods to conform to the quantity required by the contract.
Article 51 establishes important rules concerning partial delivery and partial nonconformity.
Articles 45–52 regulate buyer remedies.
Articles 74–77 establish important rules concerning damages.
Where Turkish domestic sales law applies, the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 establishes relevant rules concerning contractual performance and liability.
Transport-related shortages may also involve the Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR), maritime carriage rules, air carriage conventions, or other applicable transport legislation.
This guide explains how foreign buyers can investigate missing products, establish responsibility, preserve evidence, recover payments, and pursue legal remedies under the 2026 framework.
A short delivery occurs when the quantity of goods delivered is less than the quantity required under the contract.
For example, a buyer may order 1,000 units but receive only 850.
The shortage may concern individual products, cartons, pallets, or entire containers.
However, the legal consequences depend on the contractual quantity and delivery arrangements.
The buyer must establish what the supplier was required to deliver.
Potentially.
A supplier may breach the agreement where it fails to deliver the agreed quantity.
For example, a purchase order may require 2,000 components.
If the supplier delivers only 1,700 without a valid contractual basis, incomplete performance may arise.
However, the contract may permit partial deliveries or quantity tolerances.
The relevant terms must be examined.
Article 35 requires goods to conform to the quantity, quality, description, and packaging required by the contract.
For example, a supplier may agree to deliver 5,000 products.
Delivery of fewer products may constitute nonconformity.
However, the legal consequences depend on the agreement and applicable CISG provisions.
The buyer must establish the relevant shortage.
Article 30 establishes the seller’s principal obligations.
The seller must deliver the goods, hand over documents relating to them, and transfer property as required by the contract and Convention.
The provision may become relevant where the supplier fails to deliver the complete quantity.
However, the buyer must examine the agreed delivery terms.
The seller’s obligations may differ depending on the contract.
Potentially, where the contract permits it.
For example, the parties may agree on a quantity tolerance or partial delivery schedule.
However, the supplier cannot automatically reduce the agreed quantity without a valid legal basis.
The buyer should examine the purchase order and contractual terms.
The existence of a shortage must be assessed against the agreed quantity.
Potentially.
Some commercial contracts permit limited variations in quantity.
For example, a manufacturing agreement may allow a specified percentage tolerance.
However, the supplier must establish that the tolerance was agreed or otherwise applicable.
The buyer should examine the contract and relevant trade practices.
A general assertion that shortages are normal does not automatically establish a valid defense.
Potentially.
The contract may permit installment deliveries.
For example, the supplier may agree to deliver 10,000 units in several batches.
A partial shipment may not constitute breach if the remaining quantity is not yet due.
The buyer should identify the delivery schedule.
The legal consequences depend on the agreement.
Potentially.
However, the buyer’s rights depend on the contract and applicable law.
For example, the supplier may offer to deliver missing units in a subsequent shipment.
The buyer may accept the proposed cure.
However, delayed delivery may create additional losses.
The relevant statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
The supplier may rely on packing lists, loading photographs, warehouse records, or transport documents.
However, such documents do not automatically establish that every product reached the buyer.
The buyer should compare the supplier’s evidence with unloading records and inventory counts.
The relevant transport arrangements may be important.
Potentially.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and risk allocation.
For example, the supplier may have fulfilled its delivery obligation by handing the goods to the carrier under the applicable terms.
Alternatively, the supplier may remain responsible until delivery at the destination.
The buyer must examine the Incoterms and governing law.
Potentially.
Customs authorities may inspect or detain goods under the applicable legal framework.
However, the supplier must establish the relevant circumstances.
The buyer should obtain customs records where available.
The existence of a customs inspection does not automatically explain every shortage.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that the goods were delivered in full and that the shortage occurred afterward.
The buyer should preserve unloading records, warehouse entry documents, and inventory counts.
The relevant chronology is important.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the evidence.
Yes.
A packing list may contain inaccurate quantities.
For example, the supplier may state that a carton contains 100 units when it contains only 80.
The discrepancy may arise from packing errors or other causes.
However, an inaccurate packing list does not automatically establish intentional misconduct.
The buyer must examine the actual contents and relevant documents.
Potentially.
A commercial invoice may identify quantities that differ from the actual shipment.
However, the invoice alone does not establish what was physically delivered.
The buyer should compare the invoice with packing lists, transport documents, and inventory records.
The relevant contractual quantity must also be established.
Yes.
A supplier or loading contractor may fail to load the complete quantity.
For example, several pallets may remain at the factory.
The buyer should examine loading records and warehouse dispatch documents.
The legal consequences depend on the relevant contractual responsibilities.
Potentially.
Goods may be lost or stolen during international transport.
However, the legal consequences depend on the transport arrangement and applicable law.
For example, the carrier may face liability under the relevant transport convention.
The buyer must establish the circumstances and responsible party.
Potentially.
A shortage may occur while goods are stored before or after transportation.
The legal consequences depend on the warehouse relationship and applicable law.
The buyer should examine warehouse entry and exit records.
The relevant custody period must be established.
Potentially.
Customs authorities may open containers or packages for inspection.
However, the buyer should not automatically attribute shortages to customs procedures.
Official inspection records may be relevant.
The circumstances must be established.
Potentially.
Damaged cartons or broken seals may indicate that goods were lost during handling or transportation.
However, packaging damage does not automatically establish the cause.
The buyer should document the condition of the shipment.
Photographs, videos, and transport records may be important.
Yes.
Inventory counting errors may create apparent shortages.
For example, goods may be packed in unexpected quantities or mixed cartons.
The buyer should conduct a reliable count.
The method and timing of inspection may affect the evidence.
The supplier may challenge an inaccurate inventory report.
Potentially.
Article 46(1) of the CISG permits the buyer to require performance of the seller’s obligations, subject to the relevant conditions.
For example, the buyer may demand delivery of the missing units.
However, the availability of specific performance may be affected by Article 28 and the applicable judicial framework.
The buyer must establish the outstanding delivery obligation.
Potentially.
The appropriate remedy depends on the nature of the shortage and contract.
For example, the buyer may require delivery of the outstanding quantity.
However, replacement and delivery of missing goods are not always legally identical concepts.
The buyer should identify the precise obligation.
The applicable CISG provisions must be examined.
Potentially.
Article 47 of the CISG permits the buyer to fix an additional period of reasonable length for performance.
For example, the buyer may demand delivery of the missing products within a specified period.
However, the legal consequences of noncompliance depend on the applicable statutory framework.
The buyer should preserve evidence of the notice.
Potentially.
Article 49 of the CISG permits avoidance where the seller’s breach is fundamental and the relevant requirements are satisfied.
However, not every shortage automatically constitutes a fundamental breach.
For example, a small shortage may not justify cancellation of the entire contract.
The buyer must examine the seriousness of the nonperformance.
Article 25 defines fundamental breach.
The concept concerns a breach that substantially deprives the other party of what it was entitled to expect under the contract, subject to the foreseeability qualification.
For example, missing essential machinery components may prevent the buyer from using an entire production system.
However, the legal assessment depends on the circumstances.
Potentially.
Article 51 of the CISG establishes important rules concerning partial delivery and partial nonconformity.
For example, a buyer may receive most of the ordered goods but not the remaining quantity.
The buyer may possess remedies concerning the missing portion.
Avoidance of the entire contract may require additional conditions.
Article 51 addresses situations where the seller delivers only part of the goods or where only part conforms to the contract.
The buyer’s remedies may apply to the missing or nonconforming portion.
However, avoidance of the entire contract generally requires a fundamental breach concerning the whole agreement.
The relevant statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
However, the legal consequences depend on the seriousness of the shortage.
For example, missing components may render the delivered goods commercially useless.
Alternatively, the shortage may concern a small number of independent products.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine whether the breach affects the entire contract.
Potentially.
A buyer may retain the delivered products while pursuing remedies concerning the shortage.
However, the applicable law and contract must be examined.
The buyer should document the quantity received.
Acceptance of part of the shipment does not automatically eliminate every claim concerning the missing goods.
Potentially.
Where the supplier fails to deliver part of the agreed quantity, the buyer may possess rights concerning the corresponding payment.
However, the legal basis depends on the contract and governing law.
For example, the buyer may have prepaid for 1,000 units but received only 800.
The buyer may seek appropriate restitution or other relief.
The statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
However, a full refund generally requires a legally sufficient basis affecting the entire contract.
For example, valid avoidance of the entire agreement may create restitution rights.
A minor shortage does not automatically justify repayment of the full price.
The buyer should examine the applicable remedies.
Potentially.
Where the buyer prepaid for goods that were not delivered, restitution or contractual recovery may be available.
However, the relevant legal requirements depend on the governing law.
The buyer should preserve payment records and contractual documents.
The supplier may dispute the outstanding quantity.
Potentially.
The available remedy depends on the governing law and nature of the nonperformance.
For example, the CISG contains specific provisions concerning partial delivery and price reduction.
The buyer should distinguish a claim for repayment of undelivered units from a price reduction for nonconforming goods.
The correct legal classification is important.
Potentially.
The buyer may possess contractual defenses or suspension rights under the applicable framework.
For example, the supplier may demand the full balance despite delivering fewer goods.
However, withholding payment without a legally sufficient basis may create additional liability.
The buyer should examine the relevant obligations.
Potentially.
Set-off may be available under the applicable legal framework.
For example, the buyer may possess a monetary claim concerning the missing quantity.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
The supplier may dispute the claim.
The contract may also contain relevant provisions.
Yes, where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
Article 45 of the CISG establishes important buyer remedies for seller nonperformance.
Articles 74–77 regulate damages.
For example, the buyer may incur replacement purchase costs or customer penalties.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant loss and causal connection.
Article 74 establishes the general damages framework for breach of contract.
Damages may include loss suffered and loss of profit, subject to the foreseeability limitation.
For example, missing products may prevent the buyer from fulfilling customer orders.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant financial loss.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the evidence.
Potentially.
Article 75 of the CISG establishes important rules concerning substitute transactions following valid avoidance.
For example, the buyer may purchase replacement goods from another supplier at a higher price.
However, the statutory conditions must be satisfied.
The replacement purchase should be commercially reasonable.
Potentially.
Article 76 of the CISG establishes important rules concerning damages based on the current price where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
However, the remedy depends on the circumstances.
The buyer must establish the relevant market price.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the evidence.
Potentially.
Article 74 permits recovery of qualifying lost profits.
For example, the buyer may lose a confirmed customer order because part of the shipment is missing.
However, speculative sales expectations do not automatically establish recoverable loss.
The buyer must establish the relevant causal connection and foreseeability.
Potentially.
A foreign buyer may face penalties from downstream customers because of incomplete delivery.
However, recovery from the Turkish supplier depends on the governing law and circumstances.
The buyer must establish the relevant contractual obligations and financial loss.
Not every penalty paid to a third party is automatically recoverable.
Potentially.
The buyer may need to arrange a separate shipment for missing products.
However, reimbursement depends on the applicable legal framework.
The buyer must establish that the expense was reasonable and caused by the breach.
The relevant shipping invoices should be preserved.
Potentially.
Missing products may create customs-related expenses or correction procedures.
However, the allocation of responsibility depends on the contract, Incoterms, and applicable law.
The buyer must establish the relevant loss and causal connection.
Potentially.
A shortage may require additional storage or inventory handling.
However, the buyer must establish that the expenses resulted from the supplier’s breach.
The court must examine the reasonableness of the costs.
The relevant records should be preserved.
Potentially.
The buyer may incur expenses to verify the shipment quantity.
For example, an independent surveyor may inspect containers or pallets.
However, reimbursement depends on the applicable legal framework.
The buyer must establish that the costs were reasonable and causally connected to the breach.
Potentially, but the legal requirements may be difficult to establish.
For example, incomplete deliveries may damage the buyer’s commercial relationships.
However, the claimant must identify legally recoverable damage.
General allegations of reputational harm do not automatically establish compensation.
Yes.
Article 77 of the CISG establishes a duty to take reasonable measures to mitigate loss.
For example, the buyer may need to arrange replacement goods or notify customers promptly.
However, the buyer is not automatically required to accept unreasonable costs or risks.
Failure to mitigate may reduce recoverable damages.
The answer depends on the contract, risk transfer, and applicable transport law.
For example, the seller may have fulfilled its delivery obligation before the loss occurred.
Alternatively, the seller may remain responsible until arrival at the destination.
The carrier may also possess separate liability.
The buyer must examine the relevant legal relationships.
Potentially.
The supplier’s liability depends on the contract and applicable risk allocation.
For example, the supplier may have agreed to deliver goods to the buyer’s warehouse.
The legal consequences may differ from a contract requiring delivery to a carrier at an earlier point.
The relevant Incoterms and CISG provisions must be examined.
Article 67 establishes important rules concerning risk transfer in sales involving carriage of goods.
However, the applicable conditions depend on the contract and circumstances.
For example, risk may pass when goods are handed over to the relevant carrier under the statutory framework.
The parties may also agree on different delivery arrangements.
The buyer must examine the applicable terms.
Article 69 establishes important risk transfer rules for certain situations not governed by Articles 67 or 68.
However, the relevant conditions depend on the delivery arrangement.
The buyer should identify when risk passed.
The existence of a shortage does not automatically establish which party bears the loss.
Incoterms may allocate delivery obligations, costs, and risk of loss.
For example, the contract may use FOB, CIF, FCA, DAP, or another recognized term.
However, Incoterms do not automatically determine every contractual remedy or title issue.
The buyer should examine the agreed term and named place.
The applicable version of Incoterms may also be important.
Potentially.
However, risk transfer does not automatically eliminate liability for the supplier’s own earlier breach.
For example, the supplier may have loaded fewer goods than required before risk passed.
The buyer may still possess contractual claims concerning incomplete delivery.
The relevant facts and applicable law must be examined.
Potentially.
Carrier liability depends on the transport mode and applicable legal framework.
For example, international road carriage may be governed by the CMR Convention.
Maritime and air carriage may involve different rules.
The buyer must establish the relevant transport relationship and loss.
The CMR Convention establishes important rules concerning international carriage of goods by road where the relevant conditions are satisfied.
Article 17 addresses carrier liability for loss or damage occurring between taking over the goods and delivery, subject to the Convention’s defenses.
Article 23 establishes important compensation rules.
Article 30 addresses reservations and related evidentiary matters.
However, the Convention’s application depends on the transport arrangement.
Potentially.
Article 17 establishes carrier liability for total or partial loss under the applicable conditions.
However, the carrier may possess statutory defenses.
The buyer must establish the relevant loss and transport circumstances.
The court must examine the evidence.
Potentially.
Transport conventions may establish liability limits.
For example, the CMR contains compensation limits under specified conditions.
However, exceptions may apply.
The buyer should examine the applicable transport framework.
Carrier liability may differ from the supplier’s contractual liability.
Potentially.
However, the legal basis for each claim may differ.
The supplier may face contractual liability.
The carrier may face transport-related liability.
The buyer must establish the relevant requirements against each party.
The same loss cannot automatically be recovered multiple times.
Potentially.
The freight forwarder’s responsibility depends on its contractual role and applicable law.
For example, the forwarder may act as an agent or assume carrier-like obligations.
The buyer must identify the relevant contract.
A freight forwarder is not automatically responsible for every missing product.
Potentially.
A warehouse operator may be responsible for goods under its custody.
However, liability depends on the storage contract and applicable law.
The buyer must establish when the shortage occurred.
Warehouse records and inventory reports may be important.
Potentially, where the broker breached an applicable legal obligation and caused recoverable damage.
However, a customs broker is not automatically responsible for shortages occurring during manufacturing or transport.
The buyer must identify the broker’s duties and actual conduct.
The relevant customs and contractual framework must be examined.
Potentially.
Cargo insurance may cover specified losses during transportation.
However, coverage depends on the policy terms, exclusions, insured risks, and circumstances.
For example, theft or partial loss may be covered under certain policies.
The buyer should examine the insurance certificate and notification requirements.
Insurance does not automatically eliminate contractual claims against responsible parties.
Potentially.
However, the legal consequences depend on the insurance policy and applicable subrogation rules.
For example, an insurer that pays compensation may acquire rights against responsible parties.
The buyer cannot automatically recover the same loss twice.
The relevant legal relationships must be examined.
Potentially.
A bill of lading may contain important information concerning the goods received for carriage.
However, its evidentiary effect depends on the document and circumstances.
For example, the carrier may record container quantities or apparent condition.
The document does not automatically establish the contents of every sealed carton.
The buyer should examine the relevant terms and notations.
Potentially.
A CMR consignment note may contain information concerning the goods and their apparent condition.
However, the evidentiary effect depends on the circumstances and applicable provisions.
The buyer should compare the note with loading and unloading records.
The document may be important but not necessarily conclusive.
Potentially.
A packing list may identify the expected contents of cartons or pallets.
However, it does not automatically establish what was physically delivered.
The buyer should compare the list with actual inventory counts.
The supplier may dispute the findings.
Potentially.
An invoice may establish the quantity sold or billed.
However, it does not automatically prove the quantity physically delivered.
The buyer should examine the purchase order, packing list, and transport documents.
The relevant contractual quantity must be established.
Potentially.
Container seals may provide evidence concerning access during transportation.
For example, a broken or mismatched seal may raise concerns.
However, an intact seal does not automatically establish that the correct quantity was loaded.
The buyer should examine the loading records and seal documentation.
Potentially.
Photographs may show products being loaded.
However, they may not establish the complete quantity.
The buyer should examine timestamps, product identifiers, and other evidence.
The supplier may rely on photographs, but their evidentiary value depends on the circumstances.
Potentially.
Videos may document the condition and contents of the shipment.
However, authenticity and completeness must be examined.
The buyer should preserve original recordings where possible.
A partial video may not establish the entire unloading process.
Potentially.
Inventory reports may establish the quantity recorded upon receipt.
However, the reliability of the counting process is important.
The supplier may challenge the method or timing.
The buyer should preserve supporting documents.
Yes.
An independent surveyor may inspect the shipment and document discrepancies.
For example, the surveyor may count cartons, pallets, or individual products.
However, the evidentiary value depends on the methodology and circumstances.
The buyer should preserve the survey report and supporting records.
Potentially.
Articles 400–405 of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 establish mechanisms concerning preservation of evidence.
For example, the buyer may seek judicial examination of goods or loading records where there is a legally sufficient risk of evidence loss.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Evidence preservation is not an unrestricted discovery procedure.
Potentially.
Articles 219 and following of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure establish important rules concerning documentary evidence.
A court may order production of relevant documents under the applicable conditions.
For example, loading records may help determine whether the supplier dispatched the complete quantity.
The applicant must identify the documents and legal relevance.
Potentially.
Factory dispatch records may help establish what left the supplier’s premises.
However, the buyer does not automatically possess unrestricted access to the manufacturer’s internal records.
The contract may provide inspection rights.
Judicial document production procedures may also become relevant.
Potentially.
CCTV footage may help establish loading or unloading activities.
However, access is subject to applicable legal and privacy requirements.
The buyer should act promptly because recordings may be retained for limited periods.
Judicial evidence preservation may require consideration.
Yes, potentially.
Emails may establish the quantity ordered and confirmed.
For example, correspondence may identify the number of units required.
The buyer should preserve the complete communication history.
However, authenticity and context must be examined.
Potentially.
Messages may contain discussions concerning missing products or supplier admissions.
However, authenticity and context must be examined.
A screenshot alone may not conclusively establish every relevant fact.
The buyer should preserve communications lawfully.
Potentially.
For example, the supplier may acknowledge that several cartons were not loaded.
Such a statement may provide important evidence.
However, the legal consequences depend on the context and applicable law.
The supplier may dispute the scope of the admission.
The buyer should preserve the complete communication.
The deadline depends on the governing law and contract.
Under the CISG, Articles 38 and 39 establish important inspection and notification rules concerning lack of conformity.
Where the dispute concerns failure to deliver an identifiable part of the goods, the precise application of those provisions and other CISG remedies must be assessed.
The buyer should notify the supplier promptly.
The notice should identify the missing products and quantity.
Article 38 requires the buyer to examine the goods, or cause them to be examined, within as short a period as practicable in the circumstances.
However, the timing depends on the delivery arrangement.
For example, inspection may occur after arrival at the destination under the relevant conditions.
The buyer should not assume that inspection can be delayed indefinitely.
Article 39 establishes notification requirements concerning lack of conformity.
The buyer generally must notify the seller within a reasonable time after discovering the nonconformity or when it ought to have discovered it.
The notice must specify the nature of the problem.
However, the legal analysis may differ where the claim concerns non-delivery rather than nonconformity.
The applicable provisions must be examined.
Potentially.
Failure to comply with applicable notification requirements may affect the buyer’s remedies.
However, the legal consequences depend on the governing law and nature of the claim.
The supplier cannot automatically rely on every notice objection without examining the applicable provisions.
The buyer should preserve evidence concerning discovery and notification.
Potentially.
Article 23 establishes important rules concerning commercial sales between merchants.
For certain commercial sales, the buyer must notify the seller of obvious defects within two days.
Where the defect is not immediately apparent, the buyer must examine or have the goods examined within eight days and notify the seller within that period if a defect is discovered.
However, the precise application depends on the transaction and whether the issue is classified as a defect or incomplete delivery.
The governing law must be identified.
No.
Where the CISG applies, its provisions generally govern relevant international sales issues.
Article 23 of the Turkish Commercial Code does not automatically replace the CISG.
The buyer should examine the contract and applicable law.
Different transport notice requirements may also apply.
Potentially.
Transport conventions may establish specific notice or reservation rules.
For example, Article 30 of the CMR addresses reservations and evidentiary consequences.
However, failure to make a reservation does not automatically produce identical consequences in every case.
The buyer must examine the applicable transport framework.
Not automatically.
A delivery receipt may establish physical receipt of goods.
However, its evidentiary effect depends on the wording and circumstances.
For example, the buyer may sign before discovering missing products inside sealed cartons.
The applicable inspection and notification requirements must be examined.
Not automatically.
Payment may establish that the buyer paid for the goods.
However, payment does not automatically prove that the full quantity was delivered.
The buyer may discover the shortage afterward.
The applicable legal requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
For example, a supplier may allegedly invoice and receive payment for goods it never intended to deliver.
However, ordinary incomplete performance does not automatically constitute fraud.
Articles 157 and 158 of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 establish relevant provisions.
The prosecution must establish the statutory elements.
Potentially.
A supplier may allegedly create false shipping documents.
The legal consequences depend on the nature of the document and conduct.
Articles 204 and 207 of the Turkish Penal Code regulate official and private document forgery.
However, an inaccurate packing list does not automatically establish criminal forgery.
The statutory elements must be examined.
Potentially.
Where goods were unlawfully taken, criminal law provisions concerning theft may become relevant.
However, the existence of missing products does not automatically establish theft.
The relevant conduct and responsible person must be identified.
The buyer should distinguish criminal investigation from commercial recovery claims.
Not automatically.
A criminal complaint concerns suspected criminal conduct.
Recovery of the purchase price may require separate commercial proceedings.
A criminal investigation does not automatically reverse payments.
The buyer should examine the appropriate contractual remedies.
Potentially.
The CISG may apply where the parties have their places of business in different Contracting States and the relevant conditions are satisfied.
It may also apply through applicable private international law rules in specified circumstances.
However, the parties may exclude the CISG under Article 6.
The buyer should examine the contract and governing law.
Yes.
Article 6 permits parties to exclude the CISG or derogate from specified provisions under the Convention’s framework.
However, the exclusion must be established through the contract and applicable interpretation rules.
A general choice of Turkish law does not necessarily exclude the CISG.
No.
The CISG forms part of the applicable legal framework in qualifying international sales.
A contractual choice of Turkish law does not automatically mean that domestic contract law replaces the CISG.
The parties may expressly exclude the Convention.
The relevant contractual wording must be examined.
Yes, where the CISG does not apply or has been validly excluded.
The Turkish Code of Obligations establishes important rules concerning contractual performance, default, and damages.
The Turkish Commercial Code may establish additional requirements for commercial sales between merchants.
However, the applicable framework depends on the transaction.
The buyer should identify the governing law before selecting a remedy.
Article 112 establishes the general framework concerning liability for failure to perform an obligation properly.
The debtor may be liable for resulting damage unless it establishes the relevant absence of fault under the statutory framework.
However, the claimant must establish the obligation, breach, damage, and causal connection.
For example, a supplier may fail to deliver the agreed quantity.
The buyer must establish the resulting legally recoverable loss.
Potentially.
Articles 117–126 of the Turkish Code of Obligations establish important rules concerning default and related remedies.
However, termination rights depend on the contract and circumstances.
For example, a supplier may fail to deliver the remaining products after an additional period.
The buyer must examine the applicable statutory requirements.
Potentially.
The competent court depends on the contract, jurisdiction agreement, and applicable procedural framework.
For example, a foreign buyer may bring a commercial claim before a competent Turkish commercial court where jurisdiction exists.
However, a valid arbitration agreement may require a different procedure.
The buyer should examine the dispute resolution clause.
Potentially.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and applicable jurisdiction rules.
For example, the parties may have agreed on foreign court jurisdiction.
However, the enforceability of the clause must be examined.
The buyer should also consider whether a foreign judgment can be enforced against the supplier’s assets.
Potentially.
Arbitration may be available where the parties have a valid arbitration agreement.
For example, the supply contract may provide for arbitration concerning delivery shortages.
However, the buyer cannot automatically require arbitration without a legally sufficient basis.
The arbitration clause and procedural requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
Turkey is a party to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards.
Foreign arbitral awards may be recognized and enforced under the applicable framework.
However, the statutory requirements and possible refusal grounds must be examined.
The buyer may need to pursue the relevant enforcement procedure.
Potentially.
Law No. 5718 establishes important rules concerning recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
For example, a foreign buyer may obtain a judgment requiring repayment or damages.
The buyer may then seek enforcement against the supplier’s assets in Turkey.
The applicable procedure must be examined.
Potentially.
Precautionary attachment may be available under the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
For example, the buyer may possess a qualifying monetary claim concerning undelivered goods.
However, precautionary attachment is not automatically available in every shipment shortage dispute.
The court must examine the relevant conditions.
Security may also be required.
Potentially.
Articles 389 and following of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure establish important rules concerning interim judicial protection.
For example, the buyer may seek preservation of specified goods or evidence.
However, the court must examine the asserted right, urgency, and proportionality.
The requested measure must address a specific legal risk.
Potentially.
Where the buyer possesses an enforceable monetary claim, Turkish enforcement procedures may be available.
However, the supplier may possess procedural defenses.
The appropriate mechanism depends on the relevant judgment, arbitral award, or other enforceable instrument.
The applicable deadlines and requirements must be examined.
Yes.
A foreign buyer may appoint a Turkish lawyer to assist with commercial litigation and related proceedings.
The applicable authorization and procedural requirements must be satisfied.
Where documents are executed abroad, authentication and translation requirements may arise.
The buyer’s physical absence from Turkey does not automatically prevent legal action.
Relevant evidence may include the supply agreement, purchase order, commercial invoice, packing list, bill of lading, CMR consignment note, container seal records, loading photographs, unloading videos, warehouse inventory reports, customs documents, independent survey reports, bank transfer records, emails, and WhatsApp messages.
The buyer should identify the exact missing products and quantities.
The relevant delivery, inspection, discovery, and notification dates should be documented.
Where transport loss is suspected, evidence concerning custody and risk transfer may be important.
The buyer should also preserve records concerning financial losses.
As of November 2026, several legal frameworks may govern disputes involving missing products in shipments originating from Turkish suppliers.
The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods may apply to qualifying international sales.
Article 6 permits exclusion or modification of the Convention under the applicable conditions.
Article 25 defines fundamental breach.
Article 28 addresses specific performance in judicial proceedings.
Article 30 establishes the seller’s principal delivery obligations.
Article 35 establishes conformity requirements concerning quantity, quality, description, and packaging.
Article 38 establishes inspection obligations.
Article 39 establishes notification requirements concerning lack of conformity.
Articles 45–52 establish important buyer remedies.
Article 46 addresses performance.
Article 47 permits the buyer to fix an additional period for performance.
Article 49 governs avoidance by the buyer.
Article 51 establishes important rules concerning partial delivery and partial nonconformity.
Articles 67–69 establish important risk transfer rules.
Articles 74–77 regulate damages and mitigation.
Articles 81–84 address consequences of avoidance and restitution.
Where Turkish domestic contract law applies, the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 establishes important rules concerning contractual performance and nonperformance.
Article 112 establishes the general framework for liability arising from improper performance.
Articles 117–126 regulate debtor default and related remedies.
The Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 may establish additional obligations concerning commercial sales and merchant conduct.
Article 23 establishes important rules concerning specified commercial sales.
The CMR Convention may govern qualifying international road carriage.
Article 17 addresses carrier liability for loss or damage.
Article 23 establishes important compensation rules.
Article 30 addresses reservations and related evidentiary matters.
Other transport modes may be governed by different conventions and statutory frameworks.
The Turkish Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 establishes important rules concerning documentary evidence, expert examination, interim judicial protection, and evidence preservation.
Articles 219 and following concern documentary evidence.
Articles 389 and following regulate interim injunctions.
Articles 400–405 regulate evidence preservation.
The Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 establishes relevant enforcement and precautionary attachment mechanisms.
Law No. 5718 establishes important rules concerning international jurisdiction, applicable law, and enforcement of foreign judgments.
The Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 may become relevant where the conduct satisfies the elements of fraud, theft, forgery, or another recognized offense.
The central legal distinction is whether the Turkish supplier failed to dispatch the agreed quantity or whether the goods were lost after the relevant contractual risk passed.
A supplier may remain responsible for incomplete delivery.
However, transport-related shortages may involve separate carrier, warehouse, or insurance liability.
The foreign buyer should identify the relevant legal basis for each claim.
A foreign buyer who discovers missing products in a shipment from Turkey should first identify the governing law and contractual delivery terms.
The buyer should determine whether the CISG applies or whether the parties validly excluded it.
The next question is whether the supplier delivered the agreed quantity.
The buyer should compare the purchase order, invoice, packing list, and actual inventory count.
The shortage should be documented immediately.
Photographs, videos, warehouse reports, and independent surveys may be important.
The buyer should identify whether the shortage occurred before dispatch, during transportation, or after delivery.
The applicable Incoterms and risk transfer rules must be examined.
Where the supplier failed to deliver the complete quantity, Articles 30, 35, 46, and 51 of the CISG may become relevant.
Where the goods were lost during transportation, the applicable carrier liability framework may require consideration.
The buyer should notify the supplier and relevant transport parties promptly.
The notice should identify the missing products and quantity.
Where the buyer seeks delivery of the outstanding goods, a formal demand may be appropriate.
Where the breach is fundamental, contract avoidance or other remedies may require consideration.
The buyer should calculate any financial losses, including replacement purchases, additional shipping costs, customer penalties, and lost profits.
Where the supplier or carrier refuses to cooperate, the buyer should examine the dispute resolution clause and applicable transport jurisdiction rules.
Commercial litigation, arbitration, precautionary attachment, or enforcement proceedings may be available.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that shipment shortage disputes require careful distinction between incomplete supplier performance, transport loss, risk transfer, evidence preservation, damages, and cross-border enforcement.
A shipment shortage may affect several legal interests simultaneously.
The contractual issue concerns whether the supplier delivered the agreed quantity.
The transport issue concerns whether goods were lost during carriage.
The risk issue concerns when responsibility for accidental loss passed between the parties.
The evidence issue concerns packing lists, transport documents, container seals, and inventory records.
The commercial issue concerns delivery of missing products, refunds, and replacement purchases.
The financial issue concerns damages, lost profits, and additional expenses.
The insurance issue concerns possible cargo coverage and subrogation.
The procedural issue concerns notification deadlines, evidence preservation, and litigation.
The international issue concerns governing law, jurisdiction, arbitration, and enforcement.
These matters have different legal requirements.
A foreign buyer cannot automatically hold the Turkish supplier responsible for every shortage discovered after delivery.
However, a supplier cannot automatically avoid liability merely by asserting that the complete quantity was shipped.
A coordinated legal assessment may therefore be necessary to establish responsibility and protect the buyer’s commercial interests.
1. Can a foreign buyer claim compensation for missing products in a shipment from Turkey?
Yes, where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied. The buyer must establish the shortage, responsible party, and recoverable loss.
2. Can the buyer demand delivery of missing goods?
Potentially. Article 46 of the CISG may provide a performance remedy where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
3. Can the buyer recover payment for undelivered products?
Potentially. The available remedy depends on the contract, governing law, and circumstances.
4. Can the buyer cancel the entire contract because some products are missing?
Potentially. Article 51 of the CISG establishes important rules concerning partial delivery, while avoidance of the entire contract generally requires additional conditions.
5. Can the Turkish supplier blame the transport company?
Potentially. However, responsibility depends on the contract, risk transfer, and applicable transport law.
6. Can the carrier be liable for missing goods?
Potentially. The CMR Convention or another applicable transport framework may establish carrier liability.
7. What evidence is important in a shipment shortage dispute?
Purchase orders, packing lists, transport documents, container seal records, unloading videos, inventory reports, and independent survey findings may be important.
8. Can the buyer recover lost profits?
Potentially. Article 74 of the CISG permits recovery of qualifying lost profits, subject to the statutory requirements.
9. Can a foreign buyer sue the Turkish supplier in Turkey?
Potentially. The competent forum depends on the contract, jurisdiction rules, and any valid arbitration agreement.
10. Can a foreign buyer pursue the dispute without traveling to Turkey?
Yes. A foreign buyer may appoint a Turkish lawyer to assist with commercial proceedings, subject to applicable authorization and procedural requirements.
Protecting international supply contracts, commercial investments and buyer rights requires timely and specialized legal assistance.
Foreign companies that discover missing products in shipments from Turkish suppliers may face serious risks involving incomplete deliveries, disputed packing lists, transport losses, customs discrepancies, customer complaints, replacement purchases, and substantial financial losses.
Working with a lawyer experienced in Turkish commercial law, international sales contracts, the CISG, transport liability, cargo insurance disputes, arbitration, and foreign buyer protection can help clarify the applicable legal framework and identify appropriate remedies.
Serving clients throughout Turkey and internationally, Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office provides professional legal support in shipment shortage disputes, incomplete delivery claims, international supply contract enforcement, advance payment recovery, carrier liability litigation, cargo insurance claims, evidence preservation, precautionary attachment, arbitration, and enforcement proceedings against Turkish suppliers.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya assists foreign buyers, international distributors, importers, manufacturers, wholesalers, retailers, and overseas businesses facing missing products or contractual nonperformance involving shipments from Turkey.
Call Now: +90 312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: +90 532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Website: https://www.firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only. To avoid any loss of legal rights, we recommend consulting your lawyer regarding the specific circumstances of your case.