

What can foreign investors do when assets included in a Turkish company acquisition belong to third parties? Learn about ownership disputes, seller warranties, asset recovery, purchase price adjustments, indemnification, fraud, and legal remedies under Turkish law.
Foreign investors acquiring Turkish companies frequently evaluate the target company’s commercial value based on its financial statements, physical assets, production facilities, machinery, vehicles, inventory, intellectual property, and real estate holdings. These assets may represent a substantial portion of the agreed acquisition price and influence the buyer’s decision to complete the transaction.
A serious legal dispute may arise when a foreign investor discovers after closing that certain assets represented as belonging to the acquired Turkish company are actually owned by third parties.
For example, a foreign investor may purchase a Turkish manufacturing company for EUR 12 million based on financial statements identifying production machinery, warehouse equipment, vehicles, and industrial assets as company property. After completing the acquisition, the buyer discovers that several high-value machines belong to a leasing company, some warehouse equipment is owned by suppliers, and certain vehicles were never legally registered in the target company’s name.
In another situation, the seller may have included real estate owned by a shareholder, intellectual property registered in the name of a founder, or inventory held under consignment arrangements in the target company’s reported assets.
The financial consequences can be substantial.
The acquired company may lose access to essential machinery, face demands for the return of equipment, incur unexpected lease payments, or discover that assets included in the purchase price cannot legally be sold, pledged, transferred, or used without third-party consent.
The foreign buyer may also face operational disruption, customer contract breaches, financing difficulties, and a significant reduction in the actual value of the acquired business.
These circumstances raise important legal questions.
Can the foreign buyer sue the Turkish seller for including third-party property in the acquisition valuation? Can the buyer recover part of the purchase price? What happens if the true owner demands the return of machinery or equipment? Can the buyer claim fraudulent misrepresentation? Does the seller remain liable if the buyer conducted due diligence before closing?
The answers depend on the acquisition structure, the legal ownership of the disputed assets, the share purchase or asset purchase agreement, the seller’s representations and warranties, and the information disclosed before closing.
The central legal distinction is that a company’s possession or use of an asset does not necessarily mean that the company owns it.
Turkish law distinguishes ownership, possession, contractual usage rights, security interests, leasing arrangements, and other legal relationships affecting assets.
Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, and other applicable legislation may determine the parties’ rights.
This article examines the legal risks of third-party owned assets in Turkish company acquisitions and the remedies potentially available to foreign investors who discover ownership problems after closing.
Asset ownership directly affects the financial value, operational capacity, and legal security of an acquired business.
A manufacturing company may depend on machinery and production equipment to fulfill customer orders. A logistics company may rely on vehicles and warehouses. A technology business may depend on software, patents, and other intellectual property.
If these assets belong to third parties, the company may have fewer enforceable rights than the buyer expected.
For example, a machine recorded as a company asset may actually be leased under a financing arrangement. The company may have a right to use the equipment but no ownership right to sell it.
Similarly, a factory building used by the company may belong to a shareholder personally rather than to the company.
The buyer must therefore distinguish the economic usefulness of an asset from the legal rights the target company holds over it.
Third-party ownership means that an asset represented as belonging to the target company is legally owned by another person or entity.
The third party may be a supplier, leasing company, shareholder, director, affiliate, customer, employee, or unrelated business.
The target company may possess or use the asset under a valid agreement, or it may lack a sufficient legal basis for continued possession.
The legal consequences depend on the nature of the asset and the underlying relationship.
An asset subject to a valid lease is not legally equivalent to an asset held without the owner’s consent.
The buyer should identify the true owner and the precise rights available to the acquired company.
Potentially, yes.
A foreign buyer may have a contractual claim where the seller inaccurately represented that the target company owned specified assets.
Share purchase agreements frequently contain warranties concerning asset ownership, title, encumbrances, financial statements, and the sufficiency of assets required for business operations.
If those warranties were inaccurate, the buyer may seek contractual remedies.
Where the seller intentionally concealed third-party ownership and thereby induced the acquisition, fraudulent deception may also require consideration.
However, the existence of third-party property does not automatically establish seller liability.
The buyer must identify the relevant obligation, breach, and legally recoverable loss.
A share purchase generally transfers ownership of shares rather than direct ownership of the company’s individual assets.
The target company remains the legal owner of assets that belonged to it before the acquisition.
If an asset was owned by a third party before closing, the acquisition of the company’s shares does not automatically transfer that asset into the company’s ownership.
This distinction is fundamental.
A foreign investor may acquire 100% of the shares in a Turkish company without acquiring personal ownership of the company’s machinery, buildings, vehicles, or intellectual property.
Those assets remain legally separate from the shareholder’s property.
The buyer must therefore examine both the shares being purchased and the assets owned or used by the target company.
In a share purchase, the buyer acquires shares in the target company.
The company generally continues to own its existing assets and remain responsible for its obligations.
In an asset purchase, the buyer seeks to acquire specified assets directly.
The transfer of each asset may require compliance with particular legal formalities.
For example, transferring real estate generally requires appropriate land registry procedures.
Registered intellectual property may involve separate assignment and registration requirements.
The legal remedies for missing ownership may therefore differ depending on whether the transaction was structured as a share purchase or an asset purchase.
A seller may describe assets used by the target company, including leased or third-party property, provided the transaction documents accurately identify the relevant legal rights.
However, representing third-party property as company-owned may create liability where the representation is inaccurate and legally actionable.
The buyer should distinguish an honest disclosure of leased equipment from a misleading statement that the company owns the equipment free of third-party rights.
The acquisition agreement and disclosure schedules are central to this analysis.
Leased machinery is a common source of acquisition disputes.
A company may operate machinery under an ordinary lease or financial leasing agreement.
The equipment may appear in financial statements under accounting rules that recognize a right-of-use asset or other relevant accounting treatment.
However, accounting recognition does not necessarily mean that the company legally owns the machinery.
The buyer should examine the lease agreement, ownership documentation, payment obligations, and termination provisions.
If the seller represented leased machinery as legally owned, the buyer may investigate a warranty breach.
Not automatically.
A financial leasing arrangement may allow the company to use equipment while legal ownership remains with the lessor.
The agreement may contain an option or mechanism for eventual ownership transfer.
The buyer should review the contractual terms and applicable legislation, including Financial Leasing, Factoring, Financing and Savings Financing Companies Law No. 6361 where relevant.
The company should not be treated as the legal owner merely because it makes lease payments or records the equipment in its financial statements.
The buyer should determine whether the lease remains valid and whether the acquired company has complied with its obligations.
The leasing company may have contractual or statutory rights if the relevant conditions for termination or repossession are satisfied.
The buyer should also examine whether the acquisition triggered a change-of-control clause.
If the seller concealed material lease obligations or incorrectly represented ownership, the buyer may have contractual remedies against the seller.
However, a claim against the seller does not automatically defeat the leasing company’s rights.
Suppliers sometimes provide machinery, molds, tools, containers, or production equipment for use in manufacturing or distribution arrangements.
The target company may have possession and usage rights without ownership.
The buyer should examine the supply agreement and any provisions concerning return, maintenance, insurance, or termination.
If the seller included supplier-owned machinery in the acquisition valuation as company property, the buyer may investigate an inaccurate asset ownership warranty.
The financial consequences depend on whether the company can continue using the equipment and whether replacement is necessary.
Manufacturing companies may hold equipment supplied by customers for production of specific goods.
Examples include molds, dies, specialized tools, and testing devices.
These assets may be physically located at the target company’s factory while remaining legally owned by the customer.
The buyer should review customer agreements and equipment ownership records.
The acquisition valuation should distinguish company-owned equipment from customer-owned assets.
If the seller misrepresented the ownership position, contractual remedies may be available.
Consignment inventory may remain owned by a supplier or another third party until specified contractual conditions are satisfied.
The target company may possess the goods for sale or distribution without owning them.
The buyer should examine consignment agreements, inventory ledgers, supplier confirmations, and accounting records.
Including consignment goods as company-owned inventory may distort the acquisition valuation.
The buyer must determine whether the discrepancy breached the applicable financial statement or asset ownership warranties.
A retention-of-title arrangement may affect ownership of goods supplied to the target company.
Under Turkish law, the effectiveness of retention-of-title arrangements is subject to specific legal requirements.
Turkish Civil Code Article 764 is relevant to certain retention-of-title arrangements involving movable property.
The buyer should examine the supply contract and any required registration or formalities.
A contractual statement reserving ownership does not automatically establish an enforceable right in every circumstance.
The legal status must be assessed under the applicable rules.
The buyer should investigate whether the accounting treatment was incorrect under the applicable financial reporting framework.
The presence of goods in a warehouse does not necessarily justify recording them as owned inventory.
The buyer should compare physical inventory counts, purchase invoices, consignment agreements, and supplier ownership records.
If the financial statements materially overstated company-owned assets, the buyer may have a warranty claim.
The amount of recoverable loss depends on the transaction documents and applicable law.
This can create substantial acquisition risk.
A Turkish company may operate from a building owned personally by its founder or another shareholder.
The company may have a lease or informal usage arrangement.
If the buyer believed the property belonged to the target company, the acquisition valuation may have been based on inaccurate assumptions.
The buyer should examine the land registry records and the company’s legal right to occupy the property.
A share purchase does not automatically transfer personally owned real estate into the company.
Not merely because the property was included in the seller’s financial presentation.
Ownership of real estate in Turkey is generally determined through the applicable property law and land registry framework.
Turkish Civil Code Article 705 addresses acquisition of immovable property ownership, subject to statutory exceptions.
The buyer should determine whether the property was legally registered in the target company’s name.
If the property belongs to another person, the buyer may have a contractual claim against the seller but does not automatically acquire ownership of the property.
The buyer should examine whether the promise was legally enforceable and whether the required formalities were satisfied.
Transactions involving real estate are subject to specific form and registration requirements.
An ordinary commercial promise does not automatically transfer ownership.
The buyer may need to pursue performance or other contractual remedies where legally available.
The correct approach depends on the nature of the agreement and the legal status of the property.
The buyer should investigate whether the target company has a valid lease or other enforceable usage right.
A factory may be owned by another company within the seller’s corporate group.
Following the acquisition, the affiliate may demand rent, terminate the arrangement where legally permitted, or refuse continued access.
The buyer should examine related-party agreements and any post-closing transitional arrangements.
If the seller represented the factory as company-owned, the buyer may investigate a warranty or misrepresentation claim.
The absence of a written lease does not necessarily mean that no enforceable lease relationship exists.
Turkish law recognizes contractual arrangements subject to applicable requirements, and the legal consequences depend on the circumstances.
However, an undocumented arrangement may create evidentiary uncertainty and operational risk.
The buyer should investigate the history of occupation, rent payments, communications, and the owner’s position.
The seller’s warranties concerning lawful occupation and asset sufficiency may be relevant.
The buyer should determine whether termination is legally effective.
The owner may rely on contractual termination rights or other applicable legal provisions.
The target company may have defenses or rights to continued use.
The buyer should separately examine whether the seller breached an acquisition warranty concerning asset ownership or continuing usage rights.
A dispute with the owner and a claim against the seller may require different legal proceedings.
Vehicle ownership should be verified through the relevant registration and transaction records.
A company may use vehicles under leasing, rental, or financing arrangements.
The buyer should determine whether the target company owns the vehicles or merely possesses contractual usage rights.
If the seller represented third-party vehicles as company assets, the buyer may investigate a contractual claim.
The financial impact may include replacement costs, rental expenses, and operational disruption.
Intellectual property ownership may be separate from company ownership.
A founder may personally own a trademark, patent, software rights, or other intellectual property used by the target company.
A share acquisition does not automatically transfer those personally owned rights.
The buyer should examine registry records, assignments, licenses, and development agreements.
If the seller represented that the company owned the rights, the buyer may have contractual remedies.
The buyer should examine the relevant trademark records maintained by the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office.
The registered owner may be a founder, affiliate, distributor, or unrelated third party.
The company may have a valid license or other legal basis for using the mark.
However, the buyer should determine whether the usage rights are sufficient for the intended business operations.
If the seller falsely represented ownership, a warranty claim may arise.
The buyer should examine the software development agreements and the applicable copyright framework.
Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846 governs qualifying software and copyright-related economic rights.
Payment for software development does not automatically establish that the company owns every relevant economic right.
The buyer should verify whether the target company possesses enforceable rights to reproduce, modify, distribute, license, and commercially exploit the software.
A missing assignment or license may significantly affect the acquisition value.
The buyer should determine whether the target company has a valid patent license.
The license may contain territorial restrictions, royalty obligations, termination rights, or change-of-control provisions.
The buyer should examine whether the company can continue using the technology after closing.
If the seller represented that the company owned the patent, the buyer may investigate a contractual breach.
Yes.
The loss of essential machinery, production equipment, software, or premises may disrupt operations.
The company may be unable to fulfill customer orders or maintain production schedules.
The buyer should assess whether the company has alternative assets or legally enforceable usage rights.
The operational consequences may be relevant to the valuation and damages analysis.
However, the buyer must establish the legal basis for recovering losses from the seller.
Potentially.
If the acquisition price was calculated on the assumption that the target company owned assets that actually belonged to third parties, the buyer may argue that the business was overvalued.
The buyer should examine the valuation methodology and the financial significance of the disputed assets.
A valuation expert may assess the difference between the represented and actual economic position.
The recoverable amount depends on the agreement and applicable law.
Potentially.
The buyer may seek compensation through contractual indemnification, damages, or an applicable purchase price adjustment mechanism.
However, the buyer does not automatically receive a refund equal to the recorded value of every third-party asset.
The calculation must consider the company’s actual usage rights, liabilities, replacement costs, and the effect on acquisition value.
The buyer should avoid double recovery.
A net asset value acquisition may be particularly sensitive to ownership discrepancies.
If the seller included assets that did not belong to the target company, the reported net asset value may have been overstated.
The buyer should examine the agreed valuation rules and the closing balance sheet.
The agreement may provide a mechanism for correcting asset values.
The buyer should comply with any objection deadlines and expert determination procedures.
Third-party ownership may affect EBITDA-based valuations differently.
For example, the company may have been using leased machinery without properly recognizing the associated expenses.
The buyer should determine whether the financial statements and earnings calculations accurately reflected the contractual arrangements.
The effect on valuation may involve operating costs, lease liabilities, or future replacement expenses.
A financial expert may be necessary to assess the impact.
Yes, where the relevant contractual requirements are satisfied.
Share purchase agreements commonly contain warranties stating that the target company owns specified assets or possesses valid rights to use them.
The buyer should identify the precise representation and determine whether it was inaccurate.
The agreement may contain disclosure exceptions, materiality thresholds, knowledge qualifications, and liability limitations.
The buyer must comply with applicable claim-notification procedures.
The buyer should examine the scope of the warranty.
A warranty concerning freedom from encumbrances may address pledges, liens, security interests, or other restrictions.
However, ownership by a third party is not necessarily identical to an encumbrance over company-owned property.
The buyer should determine whether the agreement separately warrants legal ownership, possession, and freedom from security interests.
The precise wording may determine the claim.
The seller may argue that the buyer accepted the relevant risk.
The buyer should examine what was disclosed and how the acquisition agreement treats disclosed matters.
A valid disclosure may qualify particular warranties.
However, the effect depends on the contractual language and the buyer’s actual knowledge.
The buyer should preserve the data room index, disclosure schedules, and correspondence.
Concealment of ownership records may be relevant to allegations of intentional deception.
The buyer should investigate whether the seller possessed documents showing that the assets belonged to third parties.
Evidence may include leasing agreements, supplier contracts, registration records, and internal correspondence.
The buyer must establish the relevant legal requirements for a fraud or misrepresentation claim.
The absence of disclosure alone does not automatically prove fraudulent intent.
Potentially.
Turkish Code of Obligations Article 36 addresses fraudulent deception affecting contractual consent.
If the seller knowingly represented third-party property as company-owned and that deception influenced the buyer’s decision to acquire the business, the buyer may consider remedies under this provision.
The buyer must establish the relevant statutory elements.
Article 39 establishes an important one-year period for the relevant declaration after discovery of deception.
The buyer should obtain legal advice promptly.
Potentially, where a valid contractual or statutory ground exists.
The discovery of third-party owned assets does not automatically invalidate a completed share purchase.
The buyer must establish a recognized basis for avoiding or terminating the agreement.
Unwinding a completed acquisition may involve complex restitution and corporate law issues.
The buyer should consider whether monetary compensation or a negotiated asset transfer is more appropriate.
Yes, where a valid legal basis for compensation exists.
The buyer may wish to retain the target company while seeking compensation for inaccurate asset ownership representations.
This may be commercially appropriate where the company continues operating and retains valuable assets or customer relationships.
The buyer must establish the applicable contractual or statutory claim and recoverable loss.
Yes, where the acquisition agreement contains an applicable indemnification provision.
The indemnity may cover losses arising from title defects, third-party claims, or inaccurate asset ownership warranties.
The buyer should examine the definition of covered losses, claim deadlines, financial caps, and procedural requirements.
Specific indemnities may apply to identified assets.
A specific title indemnity may require the seller to compensate the buyer if the target company lacks ownership of designated assets.
The buyer should examine the trigger conditions and available remedies.
The indemnity may address replacement costs, third-party claims, or other defined losses.
The buyer must comply with the contractual procedure.
Potentially.
An escrow arrangement may secure qualifying indemnification claims.
The buyer should examine the escrow agreement, notification deadlines, and release conditions.
A disputed ownership claim does not automatically entitle the buyer to retain all escrow funds.
The contractual requirements must be satisfied.
Possibly, where the agreement or applicable law permits withholding or setoff.
The buyer should examine the provisions governing deferred consideration and indemnification.
Turkish Code of Obligations Articles 139 and following may be relevant where Turkish law applies.
Unilateral nonpayment without a valid basis may expose the buyer to a counterclaim.
The buyer should determine whether the seller has the legal authority to transfer the assets.
A seller cannot automatically transfer property owned by an unrelated third party.
The agreement may require the seller to procure ownership or obtain consent.
The enforceability of such an obligation depends on the contractual wording and applicable law.
If the seller fails to perform, contractual remedies may be available.
The buyer should examine whether the owner is bound by any enforceable obligation.
A third party is not automatically required to transfer property merely because the seller promised to procure the transfer.
The buyer may have a claim against the seller if the seller breached an enforceable procurement obligation.
The buyer should also consider whether continued use can be secured through a license or lease.
Potentially.
A direct purchase may provide a practical solution where the asset is essential to the company’s operations.
The buyer should verify ownership and negotiate appropriate transfer terms.
However, acquiring the asset separately may create additional costs.
The buyer may consider whether those costs are recoverable from the seller under an applicable legal claim.
The buyer should determine whether the owner has an enforceable right to immediate possession.
The company may have contractual defenses or rights to continued use.
The buyer should avoid assuming that every ownership claim requires immediate surrender.
The legal position depends on the asset and the underlying agreement.
Urgent legal advice may be necessary where the asset is essential to business operations.
Potentially.
An owner may pursue remedies available under Turkish property law or the relevant contractual relationship.
Turkish Civil Code Article 683 recognizes important rights of ownership, including claims concerning unlawful possession or interference, subject to applicable requirements.
The target company may have defenses based on leases, licenses, or other legal rights.
The buyer should assess the owner’s claim separately from any contractual claim against the seller.
The buyer cannot automatically sue the true owner merely because the seller misrepresented ownership.
A claim against the third party requires an independent legal basis.
The acquired company may have contractual rights against the owner or other relevant parties.
The buyer should distinguish the seller’s misrepresentation from the third party’s lawful ownership rights.
Potentially.
If the loss of third-party assets causes production interruptions, delayed deliveries, or other operational problems, the buyer may seek compensation where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
The buyer must establish causation and recoverable loss.
The claim should distinguish losses suffered by the acquired company from losses suffered directly by the purchasing shareholder.
Potentially.
The buyer may need to purchase or lease replacement machinery to maintain operations.
The recoverability of those costs depends on the contractual or statutory basis of the claim.
The buyer should document the necessity and reasonableness of the replacement expenses.
The calculation should also consider the value of any continuing usage rights.
Potentially.
The loss of essential assets may prevent the company from fulfilling customer contracts or generating expected revenue.
The buyer must establish the applicable legal basis, causation, and recoverable loss.
Projected profits must be supported by reliable evidence.
The buyer should avoid treating gross revenue as equivalent to net profit.
The target company may remain responsible for its contractual obligations to customers.
The buyer should examine whether the loss of equipment or premises caused the breach.
The company may face contractual penalties, damages claims, or other consequences.
The buyer may separately investigate whether the seller is responsible under the acquisition agreement.
The legal positions of the customer, target company, buyer, and seller must be distinguished.
The buyer should assess whether the asset can be replaced, leased, licensed, or otherwise obtained.
The absence of an essential asset may materially affect the acquisition’s commercial value.
The buyer should also examine whether the seller warranted that the company possessed all assets necessary to operate its business.
A breach of an asset sufficiency warranty may provide a contractual basis for a claim.
Yes, where the agreement contains such a warranty and the relevant requirements are satisfied.
An asset sufficiency warranty may state that the target company owns or possesses valid rights to use all assets necessary for its business.
The buyer should determine whether the missing ownership or usage rights make that statement inaccurate.
The claim may be available even where the asset was not expressly listed as company-owned, depending on the wording.
The legal and financial consequences may be less severe.
For example, a company may operate successfully using leased equipment under a long-term agreement.
The buyer should determine whether the usage rights are secure, transferable where necessary, and sufficient for continued operations.
Third-party ownership does not automatically make the acquisition defective.
The central issue is whether the seller accurately represented the company’s rights and obligations.
A lease may contain provisions triggered by changes in the target company’s ownership.
The buyer should examine whether the acquisition requires notice or consent.
If the clause permits termination under specified conditions, the buyer may face operational risk.
The seller may have warranted that the acquisition would not trigger termination of material contracts.
If that warranty was inaccurate, contractual remedies may be available.
Undisclosed lease obligations may affect the target company’s financial position.
The buyer should examine the lease agreements, payment schedules, and applicable accounting treatment.
The acquisition agreement may contain warranties concerning indebtedness, financial statements, and material contracts.
If the liabilities were inaccurately represented, the buyer may have a contractual claim.
A company may legally own an asset while a creditor holds a security interest over it.
This differs from third-party ownership.
The buyer should examine the relevant registers, financing agreements, and security documentation.
The acquisition agreement may contain warranties concerning freedom from encumbrances.
If undisclosed security rights exist, the buyer may investigate a separate contractual claim.
The buyer should determine whether the assets were legally transferred before closing.
If the seller included previously sold assets in the target company’s financial statements, the reported asset position may have been inaccurate.
The buyer should examine invoices, delivery records, ownership documentation, and accounting entries.
The legal consequences depend on the transaction documents and evidence.
Related-party ownership is common in corporate groups.
A target company may use machinery, property, intellectual property, or vehicles owned by an affiliate.
The buyer should examine intercompany agreements and the legal basis for continued use.
The seller may need to procure assignments or transitional arrangements.
A share purchase does not automatically transfer assets owned by another group company.
The buyer should determine whether the transfers were permitted under the acquisition agreement.
Pre-closing covenants may restrict extraordinary asset disposals.
If the seller removed assets that were expected to remain with the target company, the buyer may investigate a contractual breach.
The buyer should preserve the relevant transfer documents and financial records.
Undisclosed related-party arrangements may affect asset ownership, liabilities, and financial valuation.
The buyer should examine whether the acquisition agreement contains related-party transaction warranties.
The seller’s failure to disclose material arrangements may support a contractual claim.
The buyer should distinguish lawful related-party transactions from actionable misrepresentation or misconduct.
Selling shareholders may be liable under obligations they accepted in the acquisition agreement.
The buyer should identify the warranty-giving parties and the allocation of liability.
Where multiple sellers participated, the agreement may establish different liability rules.
Share ownership alone does not automatically create personal liability for every company asset problem.
Potentially, where an independent legal basis exists.
Turkish Commercial Code Article 369 addresses directors’ duties of care and loyalty, while Article 553 concerns liability for certain breaches.
However, directors are not automatically personally liable to the buyer merely because assets were incorrectly recorded.
The proper claimant, relevant duty, breach, damage, and causation must be established.
Forgery allegations require careful investigation.
The buyer should preserve original documents and obtain appropriate forensic examination.
Turkish Penal Code provisions concerning document forgery may be relevant depending on the nature of the documents and the alleged conduct.
A disputed ownership record does not automatically establish criminal forgery.
The statutory elements must be satisfied.
Potentially, where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
Turkish Penal Code Articles 157 and 158 address fraud and aggravated fraud.
A knowingly deceptive scheme involving fictitious or third-party assets may warrant criminal law analysis.
However, an inaccurate asset valuation or contractual warranty breach does not automatically constitute criminal fraud.
A criminal complaint does not replace civil recovery proceedings.
Not automatically.
The seller may argue that the buyer should have discovered the ownership problems during due diligence.
However, the legal effect depends on the acquisition agreement and the information actually disclosed.
An express warranty may allocate particular risks to the seller.
Intentional concealment may raise separate legal issues.
The buyer should examine disclosure schedules, data room materials, and contractual knowledge provisions.
The seller may argue that the buyer knew or should have known about the relevant ownership position.
The buyer should examine whether the documents clearly identified the true owner.
The legal effect depends on the agreement and applicable law.
A document’s presence in a data room does not necessarily resolve every disclosure or warranty dispute.
False answers to specific ownership questions may provide important evidence.
For example, the buyer may have asked whether all machinery listed in the fixed asset register belonged to the company.
If the seller knowingly answered affirmatively despite possessing leasing agreements showing third-party ownership, the response may support a contractual or deception claim.
The buyer should preserve the due diligence questionnaire and all responses.
Important evidence may include the share purchase agreement, disclosure schedules, asset registers, financial statements, ownership certificates, land registry records, vehicle records, leasing agreements, supplier contracts, and intellectual property registrations.
The buyer should also preserve due diligence reports, data room documents, correspondence, and third-party ownership claims.
A detailed chronology should identify when the assets were acquired, who owned them, what the seller represented, and when the buyer discovered the problem.
Evidence should be collected lawfully and preserved in a manner that supports authenticity.
Potentially.
Turkish Civil Procedure Code Articles 219 and following regulate documentary production under specified conditions.
Article 222 concerns the evidentiary significance of commercial books.
The buyer may seek relevant records where the procedural requirements are satisfied.
However, Turkish civil litigation does not provide unlimited discovery.
Requests should identify the documents and their relevance.
Yes, where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
Turkish Civil Procedure Code Articles 400–405 regulate evidence preservation.
This may be relevant where disputed machinery, inventory, documents, or electronic records risk becoming unavailable.
The buyer should consider whether urgent measures are necessary.
Potentially.
Turkish Civil Procedure Code Articles 389 and following govern interim injunctions.
The buyer must establish the applicable requirements and identify the right requiring protection.
An injunction may be relevant where a disputed asset is at risk of disposal or removal.
However, the buyer cannot automatically obtain an injunction against a lawful owner merely because the seller misrepresented ownership.
Precautionary attachment may be available for qualifying monetary claims under Articles 257 and following of Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004.
The statutory conditions must be satisfied.
The court may require security.
A disputed ownership warranty claim does not automatically justify attachment.
The buyer should investigate the seller’s assets and the jurisdictions in which enforcement may be necessary.
A transfer abroad is not automatically unlawful.
However, cross-border enforcement planning may become important.
The buyer should examine whether the seller has assets in Turkey or elsewhere.
Potentially.
The competent forum depends on the acquisition agreement, the parties, and the nature of the claim.
Certain disputes may fall within the jurisdiction of Turkish commercial courts.
However, an arbitration clause or valid jurisdiction agreement may require a different forum.
The buyer should distinguish contractual claims against the seller from ownership disputes involving third parties.
Turkish Commercial Code Article 5/A establishes mandatory mediation for certain commercial monetary lawsuits within its statutory scope.
Whether mediation is required depends on the nature of the claim and applicable procedural rules.
The buyer should not assume that every acquisition dispute is subject to the same requirement.
An arbitration clause may require separate analysis.
A valid arbitration clause may require contractual disputes to be resolved through arbitration.
The buyer should examine whether the clause covers ownership warranties, indemnification, and damages.
However, disputes concerning third-party ownership may involve persons who are not parties to the arbitration agreement.
The buyer should distinguish contractual compensation claims from proceedings directly affecting third-party property rights.
Potentially.
The New York Convention and applicable Turkish legislation may provide a framework for recognition and enforcement of qualifying foreign arbitral awards.
The buyer must satisfy the relevant requirements.
Obtaining an award does not automatically guarantee collection.
Foreign judgments may be recognized or enforced under the applicable provisions of International Private and Procedural Law No. 5718.
The buyer should examine the statutory requirements and potential refusal grounds.
A judgment concerning contractual compensation may raise different issues from a decision directly affecting property rights in Turkey.
The governing law clause may determine the substantive law applicable to contractual claims.
However, ownership and transfer of certain assets located in Turkey may be governed by separate legal rules.
The buyer should distinguish the law governing the acquisition agreement from the law governing property rights.
International Private and Procedural Law No. 5718 may be relevant to the conflict-of-laws analysis.
The relevant deadlines depend on the legal basis.
The acquisition agreement may contain warranty survival periods and claim-notification requirements.
Turkish Code of Obligations Article 146 establishes a general ten-year limitation period for certain claims where no special period applies.
Different periods may govern other claims.
Article 39 is important for rights arising from fraudulent deception.
The buyer should obtain a claim-specific limitation analysis promptly.
Share purchase agreements frequently contain caps on warranty liability.
The buyer should examine whether the cap applies to asset ownership claims.
The agreement may contain exceptions for specific indemnities or intentional misconduct.
Turkish Code of Obligations Article 115 restricts advance exclusions of liability for intentional wrongdoing and gross negligence.
The enforceability of a particular limitation depends on the governing law and agreement.
A de minimis threshold may exclude individual claims below a specified amount.
A basket may require aggregate qualifying losses to exceed a specified threshold.
The buyer should determine whether related asset ownership claims can be aggregated.
The contractual wording is important.
Potentially, where the agreement or applicable procedural rules provide a basis.
The buyer should document legal expenses, ownership investigations, asset valuations, and other professional costs.
Not every expense is automatically recoverable.
The legal basis and reasonableness of the claimed amounts must be assessed.
Yes.
A settlement may involve compensation, asset transfers, replacement equipment, leases, licenses, or adjustments to deferred consideration.
The buyer should first establish the true ownership position and the financial consequences.
Any transfer or licensing arrangement must comply with applicable legal formalities.
Settlement terms should address third-party rights and future cooperation.
The buyer should examine post-closing assistance obligations.
The agreement may require the seller to provide ownership documents, procure assignments, or resolve specified third-party claims.
If the seller breaches an enforceable obligation, contractual remedies may be available.
The buyer should preserve correspondence and comply with applicable notice requirements.
In many circumstances, a foreign investor may appoint authorized legal counsel to manage the dispute.
A power of attorney may be required.
Authentication, translation, and procedural requirements depend on the circumstances.
Personal attendance may still be necessary for particular proceedings.
Disputes involving third-party owned assets may engage Turkish property law, contract law, company law, civil procedure, and cross-border enforcement rules.
Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 governs important aspects of ownership, possession, and property rights.
Article 683 addresses the rights of ownership and certain remedies available to owners.
Article 705 is relevant to acquisition of immovable property ownership, subject to statutory exceptions.
Article 764 concerns certain retention-of-title arrangements involving movable property.
Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 governs contractual liability, damages, fraudulent deception, and other relevant obligations.
Article 112 may be relevant to liability for breach of contractual obligations.
Articles 36 and 39 may apply where the seller intentionally concealed material ownership information.
Article 115 restricts advance exclusions of liability for intentional wrongdoing and gross negligence.
Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 governs important corporate and commercial matters, including directors’ duties and commercial disputes.
Articles 369 and 553 may be relevant to certain director liability claims.
Financial leasing arrangements may involve Law No. 6361 and the applicable contractual framework.
Intellectual property ownership may involve Industrial Property Code No. 6769 and Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846.
Turkish Civil Procedure Code No. 6100 governs documentary evidence, evidence preservation, and interim injunctions.
Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 may become relevant where the buyer seeks precautionary attachment or enforcement.
International Private and Procedural Law No. 5718 may govern questions involving foreign elements, applicable law, jurisdiction, and enforcement of foreign judgments.
The precise legal framework depends on the type of asset, the transaction structure, and the governing contractual provisions.
A strong case begins with identifying the disputed assets.
The buyer should determine whether the problem concerns machinery, inventory, vehicles, real estate, intellectual property, or other property.
The next issue is legal ownership.
The buyer should examine registration records, contracts, invoices, leasing arrangements, and other documents establishing title or usage rights.
The buyer should then identify the seller’s representations and warranties.
The acquisition agreement may contain specific title warranties, asset sufficiency provisions, financial statement warranties, or indemnities.
The financial analysis should establish how the ownership discrepancy affected the acquisition value and the target company’s operations.
Where intentional concealment is alleged, the buyer should investigate the seller’s knowledge and the information provided during due diligence.
Finally, the buyer should assess claim-notification requirements, limitation periods, dispute resolution provisions, and enforcement risks.
The objective is to connect the ownership problem to a specific legal obligation and a demonstrable remedy.
Third-party ownership disputes cannot be resolved solely by examining the company’s fixed asset register.
An asset may appear in accounting records because the company possesses a contractual right to use it.
A machine may be leased, a warehouse may be rented, and a trademark may be licensed.
These arrangements can be commercially legitimate and valuable.
The central issue is whether the seller accurately represented the target company’s legal rights and financial obligations.
The acquisition valuation must also reflect the distinction between ownership and usage.
A company with secure long-term access to essential equipment may retain substantial value even without owning the equipment.
Conversely, a business that depends on assets subject to immediate third-party recovery may face significant operational risk.
A comprehensive legal strategy therefore requires coordinated ownership verification, contractual analysis, financial valuation, and enforcement planning.
1. Can a foreign investor sue a Turkish seller for including third-party assets in a company acquisition?
Yes, where the seller breached an enforceable contractual obligation or another applicable legal duty. The buyer must establish the relevant facts and legal requirements.
2. Does buying a Turkish company’s shares transfer ownership of assets belonging to third parties?
No. A share acquisition does not automatically transfer property owned by shareholders, affiliates, suppliers, or other third parties.
3. What if machinery included in the acquisition belongs to a leasing company?
The buyer should examine the lease agreement, ownership records, and seller warranties. A valid lease may provide usage rights even though the company does not own the equipment.
4. Can the buyer recover part of the purchase price?
Potentially, where an applicable contractual or statutory claim establishes a recoverable loss caused by inaccurate asset ownership information.
5. Can the true owner demand the return of the asset?
Potentially, subject to the owner’s legal rights and any enforceable lease, license, or other arrangement allowing the company to retain possession.
6. Can the buyer claim fraud against the seller?
Possibly, where the evidence establishes intentional deception and the applicable legal requirements. An ownership discrepancy alone does not automatically prove fraud.
7. Can the buyer cancel the acquisition?
Potentially, where a valid contractual or statutory ground exists. Third-party ownership does not automatically invalidate a completed acquisition.
8. Can the buyer claim compensation for production losses?
Potentially, where the applicable legal basis, causation, and recoverable loss are established.
9. Can the buyer obtain an injunction or freeze the seller’s assets?
Interim injunctions or precautionary attachment may be available where the relevant statutory requirements are satisfied.
10. What should a foreign investor do after discovering third-party owned assets?
The investor should verify legal ownership, preserve acquisition documents, review seller warranties, assess operational risks, and obtain legal advice promptly to protect available remedies.
Discovering that valuable assets included in a Turkish company acquisition belong to third parties can expose foreign investors to substantial financial losses, operational disruption, and complex legal disputes.
These cases frequently involve inaccurate asset ownership representations, undisclosed leasing arrangements, related-party property, inventory discrepancies, intellectual property ownership problems, and breaches of share purchase agreements.
Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office provides legal assistance to foreign investors and international companies involved in Turkish mergers and acquisitions, shareholder disputes, asset ownership conflicts, commercial litigation, and post-closing contractual claims.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya assists clients with reviewing acquisition agreements, investigating asset ownership, assessing seller warranties and indemnification provisions, preparing compensation claims, and evaluating litigation, arbitration, and enforcement options under Turkish law.
Foreign investors who discover third-party ownership problems after acquiring a Turkish company should seek legal advice promptly to preserve evidence, protect business operations, and assess their contractual rights.
Call Now: +90 312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: +90 532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Website: https://www.firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only. To avoid any loss of legal rights, we recommend consulting your lawyer regarding the specific circumstances of your case.