

What can foreign exporters do when Turkish customs seizes goods and prevents delivery under an international sales contract? Learn about CISG remedies, Incoterms, force majeure, customs seizure appeals, buyer claims, contract termination, and compensation in Turkey.
Foreign exporters, international manufacturers, overseas suppliers, and trading companies may face serious legal and financial difficulties when Turkish customs authorities seize commercial goods before delivery to the buyer.
An international sales contract may require the exporter to deliver machinery, raw materials, electronics, industrial equipment, agricultural products, or other commercial goods to a Turkish buyer within a specified period.
The foreign exporter may manufacture the goods, arrange transportation, prepare shipping documents, and dispatch the shipment in accordance with the contract.
However, when the goods arrive at a Turkish port, airport, customs warehouse, or border crossing, customs authorities may prevent their release because of suspected documentation irregularities, customs valuation disputes, origin verification, import restrictions, or alleged smuggling.
The exporter may consequently become unable to complete delivery.
For example, a foreign manufacturer may agree to supply industrial machinery to a Turkish company for €600,000, with delivery required by a contractual deadline.
The machinery may arrive in Turkey on time, but customs authorities may seize it because the importer allegedly submitted incorrect customs declarations.
The Turkish buyer may then demand compensation for delayed delivery, refuse further payment, or threaten to terminate the contract.
The foreign exporter may argue that it fulfilled its shipping obligations and that the customs seizure resulted from circumstances outside its control.
In another situation, the exporter may retain ownership of the goods under a retention of title clause while the Turkish buyer is responsible for customs clearance.
The buyer’s failure to obtain the necessary import permits may prevent delivery, creating a dispute over which party bears the financial consequences.
What legal remedies are available to foreign exporters when Turkish customs seizure prevents delivery under an international sales contract?
The answer depends on the sales agreement, applicable governing law, delivery terms, allocation of customs responsibilities, cause of the seizure, and whether the exporter has fulfilled its contractual obligations.
The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG), Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Customs Law No. 4458, Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607, Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271, and applicable private international law rules may become relevant.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that foreign exporters should distinguish customs seizure from contractual nonperformance, identify which party was responsible for customs clearance, determine when delivery and risk legally transferred, and evaluate whether the seizure creates grounds for exemption, damages, termination, or recovery of the goods.
Yes.
Customs seizure may prevent goods from reaching the buyer or being released into free circulation.
The exporter may be unable to complete delivery despite having dispatched the shipment.
However, the legal consequences depend on the contractual delivery obligations.
A shipment held by customs does not automatically establish that the exporter breached the contract.
The relevant delivery terms and governing law must be examined.
No.
The exporter’s liability depends on whether it failed to perform an obligation for which it was legally responsible.
For example, the exporter may have agreed to deliver goods to a named destination in Turkey.
Alternatively, the exporter may have fulfilled its delivery obligation by handing the goods to the first carrier under the agreed contractual terms.
The customs seizure may occur before or after the relevant delivery obligation has been completed.
The contract and applicable law determine the consequences.
The applicable law depends on the contractual arrangements and relevant conflict-of-laws rules.
The CISG may apply to qualifying international sales contracts.
Where the CISG does not apply or does not govern a particular issue, the relevant domestic law must be identified.
Article 24 of International Private and Procedural Law No. 5718 contains important rules concerning contractual obligations.
The parties’ governing-law agreement may also be relevant.
Potentially.
Turkey is a contracting state to the CISG.
The Convention may apply to qualifying international sales contracts where the parties have their places of business in different contracting states.
It may also apply in certain circumstances through applicable private international law rules.
However, the Convention contains exclusions and the parties may exclude its application under Article 6.
The exporter should determine whether the contract falls within the CISG.
Article 30 establishes the seller’s principal obligations to deliver the goods, hand over documents, and transfer property as required by the contract and Convention.
However, the CISG does not itself govern the proprietary effect of the contract on ownership of the goods.
The exporter should determine which delivery and documentary obligations apply.
A customs seizure may affect performance, but the legal consequences depend on the relevant contractual requirements.
Article 31 addresses the seller’s delivery obligations where the seller is not bound to deliver the goods at another particular place.
In certain carriage contracts, delivery may be completed by handing the goods over to the first carrier for transmission to the buyer.
However, the contract may establish different delivery obligations.
The exporter should determine whether delivery was legally completed before customs seizure occurred.
Potentially.
Where the contract requires delivery by handing the goods to a carrier, the seller may complete its delivery obligation before the goods arrive in Turkey.
However, this depends on the agreed terms and applicable law.
The exporter should preserve transportation documents establishing when and where the goods were handed over.
The customs seizure should be assessed in relation to the contractual delivery point.
Incoterms may allocate important responsibilities concerning delivery, transportation, risk, and customs formalities.
For example, different delivery terms allocate export and import clearance obligations differently.
However, Incoterms apply as incorporated into the parties’ contract.
They do not automatically determine every legal consequence of customs seizure.
The exporter should identify the agreed Incoterm and applicable version.
Under FOB terms, the seller generally delivers the goods on board the vessel at the named port of shipment.
The buyer ordinarily assumes specified transportation and import responsibilities after the relevant delivery point.
However, the exact obligations depend on the agreed Incoterms version and contract.
A subsequent customs seizure in Turkey may not automatically establish a failure by the exporter to deliver.
The exporter should examine the contract and shipping records.
Under CIF terms, the seller generally arranges carriage and insurance to the named destination port while risk transfers at the relevant shipment point under the applicable Incoterms rules.
The seller must also provide the required documents.
However, the buyer may remain responsible for import clearance.
The exporter should determine whether the documentary and delivery obligations were fulfilled before customs seizure.
Under DAP terms, the seller generally bears responsibility for delivering the goods to the named destination, ready for unloading.
The buyer ordinarily handles import clearance.
However, the contract may contain additional obligations.
A customs seizure may prevent the seller from completing delivery at the agreed destination.
The legal consequences depend on the cause of the seizure and allocation of responsibilities.
Under DDP terms, the seller generally undertakes extensive obligations concerning delivery and import clearance.
However, the seller’s ability to perform import formalities may depend on local legal requirements.
A foreign exporter should determine whether it can lawfully act in the required customs capacity.
Where the seller assumed responsibility for import clearance, customs seizure may create significant contractual exposure.
However, liability still depends on the relevant facts and applicable law.
Not automatically.
Risk transfer depends on the sales contract and applicable law.
Under the CISG, Articles 66–70 contain important rules concerning the passing of risk.
The relevant delivery terms may also determine when risk transfers.
However, risk of loss and responsibility for customs clearance are distinct matters.
The exporter should examine both issues.
Article 67 regulates the passing of risk in qualifying contracts involving carriage of goods.
Where the statutory conditions are satisfied, risk may pass when the goods are handed over to the relevant carrier.
However, the goods must be clearly identified to the contract.
The parties may also agree to different arrangements.
The exporter should determine whether risk passed before the customs seizure.
Article 69 addresses passing of risk in circumstances not governed by Articles 67 and 68.
The relevant conditions depend on the contractual delivery arrangements and the buyer’s conduct.
The exporter should determine whether the buyer was required to take over the goods and whether the applicable conditions were satisfied.
The customs seizure may complicate the analysis.
No.
Risk transfer does not automatically eliminate the seller’s remaining contractual obligations.
For example, the exporter may still be responsible for providing required documents or complying with contractual specifications.
The seller may also remain liable for certain breaches existing before risk passed.
The exporter should distinguish risk allocation from performance obligations.
Potentially.
The legal effect depends on the contract and applicable law.
A force majeure clause may address governmental restrictions, import prohibitions, or other events preventing performance.
However, the clause must be interpreted according to its wording.
The exporter should determine whether the customs seizure falls within the contractual definition and whether notice requirements apply.
Article 79 establishes a framework for exemption from liability for damages where failure to perform is due to an impediment beyond a party’s control and the other statutory conditions are satisfied.
The party seeking exemption must establish the relevant requirements.
A customs seizure does not automatically qualify as an exempting impediment.
The cause of the seizure, foreseeability, avoidability, and available alternatives may be important.
Potentially.
The exporter may argue that customs seizure prevented performance because of circumstances beyond its control.
However, the exporter must establish that the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied.
For example, a seizure caused by the exporter’s own false documents may not support the same position as an unforeseeable government restriction unrelated to the seller’s conduct.
The exporter should preserve evidence concerning the cause of seizure.
No.
Article 79 concerns exemption from damages under specified conditions.
It does not automatically eliminate every contractual remedy or terminate the agreement.
Other CISG provisions may remain relevant.
The exporter should distinguish exemption from damages from avoidance of the contract.
The contract may impose specific notification obligations.
Where CISG Article 79 applies, paragraph 4 contains a notification requirement concerning the impediment and its effect on performance.
Failure to provide the required notice may create liability for damage resulting from nonreceipt of the notice.
The exporter should communicate promptly and preserve evidence of notification.
Potentially.
Under the CISG, Articles 45 and 74 may become relevant where the seller breaches contractual obligations.
However, the buyer must establish the applicable requirements.
The exporter may possess defenses or grounds for exemption depending on the circumstances.
The cause of the customs seizure and allocation of responsibilities are important.
Article 74 regulates damages for breach of contract.
Damages generally correspond to the loss, including loss of profit, suffered as a consequence of the breach, subject to the Convention’s foreseeability rule.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant loss and causal relationship.
The exporter should examine whether the claimed damages resulted from its breach or from another party’s conduct.
Potentially.
A Turkish buyer may claim that customs seizure prevented production or resale.
However, the buyer must establish a legally relevant breach, loss, and causal relationship.
The applicable foreseeability and mitigation rules may also matter.
The exporter should examine the buyer’s evidence and contractual responsibilities.
Potentially.
The exporter may dispute whether the claimed losses were actually caused by its conduct.
The buyer’s financial records, customer contracts, and production evidence may be relevant.
The exporter may also examine whether the buyer took reasonable steps to reduce the loss.
The applicable legal framework determines the assessment.
Article 77 requires a party relying on breach to take reasonable measures to mitigate the resulting loss.
Where the injured party fails to take reasonable measures, the party in breach may request a reduction in damages corresponding to the avoidable loss.
This provision may become relevant where a buyer allows storage or demurrage expenses to increase unnecessarily.
However, the appropriate mitigation measures depend on the circumstances.
Potentially.
Under the CISG, avoidance of the contract is subject to specified requirements.
Article 49 addresses the buyer’s right to declare the contract avoided in qualifying circumstances.
A customs seizure does not automatically establish a fundamental breach.
The relevant contractual obligations and consequences of nonperformance must be examined.
Article 25 defines a fundamental breach.
A breach is fundamental where it results in detriment substantially depriving the other party of what it is entitled to expect under the contract, subject to the Convention’s foreseeability qualification.
This standard may become relevant where customs seizure prevents delivery of commercially essential goods.
However, the existence of a fundamental breach depends on the facts.
Potentially.
Article 49 permits avoidance in specified circumstances, including where the seller’s failure constitutes a fundamental breach.
The provision also addresses certain failures to deliver within an additional period.
However, the buyer must satisfy the applicable requirements.
The exporter should examine whether it actually breached the contract and whether the buyer validly declared avoidance.
Potentially.
The buyer may have contractual obligations concerning import permits, customs declarations, or payment of import duties.
Where the buyer fails to perform, the seller may possess remedies under the contract and applicable law.
Under the CISG, Articles 61 and 64 may become relevant.
However, the exporter must establish the applicable conditions.
Article 60 regulates the buyer’s obligation to take delivery.
The obligation includes performing acts reasonably expected of the buyer to enable the seller to make delivery and taking over the goods.
Depending on the contract, import clearance responsibilities may be relevant to the buyer’s performance obligations.
The exporter should determine whether the buyer failed to take required steps.
Potentially.
Where the buyer breaches contractual obligations, the seller may possess remedies under the CISG or applicable domestic law.
The exporter must establish the relevant breach and compensable damage.
For example, the buyer’s failure to obtain required import permits may cause storage expenses or delivery delays.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and circumstances.
Potentially.
Customs seizure may result in warehouse charges, container demurrage, terminal expenses, and additional transportation costs.
The exporter should determine which party was responsible for the relevant customs formalities.
The applicable sales contract and delivery terms may allocate these expenses.
Where another party breached its obligations, the exporter may have a contractual claim.
However, costs incurred during lawful customs procedures are not automatically recoverable from Turkish authorities.
Potentially.
The exporter’s right to payment depends on the contract, delivery obligations, and applicable law.
Where the seller has fulfilled the relevant obligations, the buyer may remain required to pay.
However, the buyer may possess remedies if the seller failed to perform.
The exporter should examine the payment terms and whether payment was conditional on customs clearance or delivery.
The exporter should identify the contractual payment obligation.
The buyer may argue that the goods were never delivered.
The exporter may argue that delivery was completed under the agreed terms.
The relevant shipping documents, Incoterms, and governing law should be examined.
Where payment remains due, the exporter may pursue the applicable contractual remedies.
Potentially.
A sales contract may provide that ownership remains with the seller until payment.
However, the legal effectiveness of the arrangement depends on the applicable property law and formal requirements.
Where Turkish property law governs, Article 764 of the Turkish Civil Code may become relevant.
The exporter should establish whether it remains the lawful owner.
Potentially.
The exporter may retain ownership under a legally effective contractual or property arrangement.
However, ownership and customs procedural rights are separate matters.
The exporter should establish its property interest and determine whether it has standing to request release.
The relevant customs and criminal restrictions must also be examined.
Potentially.
The buyer may have submitted inaccurate import declarations or failed to obtain required permits.
The authorities may investigate the resulting customs irregularity.
However, the exporter’s lack of involvement may be relevant to criminal responsibility and property rights.
The exporter should preserve authentic commercial documents.
The exporter should identify which party appointed the customs broker.
The broker may have submitted incorrect information concerning value, origin, or classification.
The legal consequences depend on the relevant customs obligations and contractual arrangements.
The exporter should establish whether it supplied accurate documents.
A separate claim against the broker may arise where the applicable requirements are satisfied.
Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607 establishes criminal provisions concerning specified customs-related offenses.
Goods suspected of being connected with an offense may become subject to criminal seizure.
However, the measure must comply with the applicable statutory framework.
The exporter should determine whether the goods are held under a criminal seizure order or an administrative customs restriction.
Article 127 of Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271 regulates criminal seizure decisions and procedures.
The provision establishes safeguards concerning the authority to order seizure and judicial approval in specified circumstances.
The exporter should determine whether the relevant requirements were followed.
The seizure record and judicial documents should be obtained where legally accessible.
Potentially.
A foreign exporter whose legally protected ownership rights are affected may have remedies under the Criminal Procedure Code.
The exporter should establish its property interest and identify the competent judicial authority.
The appropriate application depends on the stage of the investigation and legal basis for seizure.
Article 131 regulates the return of seized property.
Where the goods are no longer necessary for evidentiary purposes and are not subject to confiscation, return may be appropriate under the statutory conditions.
The exporter may request return where it possesses a legally protected interest.
However, the competent authority must assess the application.
Potentially.
A criminal investigation may continue even where physical retention of particular goods is no longer necessary.
The exporter may request return under the applicable procedure.
However, release is not automatic where another lawful restriction remains.
The exporter should establish why continued seizure is unnecessary.
The answer depends on the applicable confiscation provisions.
Article 54 of the Turkish Penal Code contains rules concerning confiscation of property connected with criminal offenses.
The provision also contains protections concerning good-faith third-party ownership.
However, special legislation and the nature of the goods may affect the analysis.
The exporter should establish its ownership and relevant good faith.
Potentially.
Article 242 of Customs Law No. 4458 establishes an objection framework for qualifying customs decisions.
The provision generally provides a fifteen-day objection period from notification for decisions within its scope.
However, the exporter must establish the relevant procedural standing.
Criminal seizure is governed by separate procedures.
Potentially.
Article 27 of Administrative Judicial Procedure Law No. 2577 regulates stays of execution concerning qualifying administrative acts.
The statutory requirements generally involve clear unlawfulness and a risk of irreparable or difficult-to-repair damage.
However, an administrative stay of execution is not automatically the appropriate remedy for criminal seizure.
Potentially.
Where the applicable customs procedure permits re-exportation, the exporter may seek return of the goods abroad.
However, re-exportation may be restricted where the goods remain subject to criminal seizure or another lawful measure.
The exporter should determine which authority controls release.
Perishable goods may deteriorate during prolonged customs detention.
The exporter should document the goods’ condition and storage requirements.
Where legally available, urgent release or protective measures may require consideration.
The parties should preserve evidence of deterioration and financial losses.
Potentially.
Article 125 of the Turkish Constitution establishes the principle of administrative liability for damage arising from administrative acts and actions, subject to the applicable legal framework.
However, compensation requires an appropriate legal basis, damage, and causal relationship.
The exporter must also establish its standing and comply with procedural requirements.
Potentially.
Articles 141 and following of the Criminal Procedure Code regulate compensation concerning specified unlawful criminal procedure measures.
However, the statutory requirements and procedural deadlines must be satisfied.
The exporter should determine whether the seizure falls within those provisions.
Potentially.
The carrier may be responsible where it breached an applicable transportation obligation.
For example, the carrier may have submitted inaccurate documents or failed to follow agreed instructions.
However, liability depends on the transportation contract and applicable law.
International conventions may also become relevant.
Potentially.
A freight forwarder may be responsible where its breach causes legally recognized damage.
The exporter should examine the forwarding agreement and relevant correspondence.
The forwarder’s role should be distinguished from that of the carrier and customs broker.
Potentially, depending on the insurance policy.
Cargo insurance may cover specified physical risks during transportation.
However, standard policies may exclude or restrict losses arising from customs detention, confiscation, or governmental action.
The exporter should examine the policy’s territorial scope, exclusions, and claims requirements.
Insurance coverage should not be assumed merely because the goods were insured during transportation.
The dispute should be assessed under the sales contract and applicable law.
The parties should identify the delivery point, risk transfer, customs responsibilities, and cause of seizure.
The CISG may provide relevant rules concerning performance, breach, damages, and exemption.
However, the legal outcome depends on the specific contractual arrangement.
Potentially.
The sales contract may contain an arbitration clause.
The validity and scope of the arbitration agreement must be examined.
The parties may also have agreed to a particular arbitral institution or seat.
However, contractual arbitration between buyer and seller does not automatically provide jurisdiction over Turkish customs authorities.
The customs restriction and commercial dispute may require separate proceedings.
Potentially.
The competent court depends on the contract, applicable jurisdiction rules, and any valid arbitration agreement.
The exporter should determine whether Turkish courts have jurisdiction.
The governing law and forum must be examined separately.
Potentially.
Law No. 5718 contains provisions concerning recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments and arbitral awards.
The New York Convention may also apply to qualifying foreign arbitral awards.
However, enforcement is subject to applicable legal requirements.
A judgment or arbitral award against the buyer does not automatically eliminate a separate customs seizure.
Foreign exporters should preserve the international sales contract, purchase order, commercial invoice, packing list, bill of lading, CMR consignment note, customs declaration, and transportation documents.
The agreed Incoterms and payment terms should be clearly documented.
The exporter should preserve correspondence concerning customs clearance responsibilities and notification of the seizure.
Where a force majeure or CISG Article 79 defense may be relevant, evidence concerning the cause and duration of the impediment should be retained.
Storage invoices, demurrage statements, financial records, and customer communications may also be important.
A clear chronology should establish when the goods were manufactured, shipped, handed over to the carrier, detained by customs, and scheduled for delivery.
Foreign exporters whose goods are seized by Turkish customs should first determine whether they have already fulfilled their contractual delivery obligations.
The sales contract, governing law, and agreed Incoterms should be examined.
The exporter should identify which party was responsible for import clearance and whether the seizure resulted from a breach of that responsibility.
The relevant customs declaration, detention record, seizure document, or administrative decision should be obtained where legally accessible.
The exporter should notify the buyer promptly and preserve evidence of the communication.
Where CISG Article 79 may apply, the statutory requirements concerning exemption and notification should be assessed.
The exporter should determine whether it retains ownership of the goods and whether a release or re-export application is available.
Where criminal seizure has occurred, the relevant procedures under the Criminal Procedure Code should be considered.
Where an administrative customs decision exists, the applicable objection or judicial procedure should be examined.
The exporter should also evaluate potential claims against the buyer, carrier, freight forwarder, customs broker, or insurer.
Any financial losses should be documented, and applicable procedural deadlines should be calculated promptly.
1. Can Turkish customs seizure prevent delivery under an international sales contract?
Yes. Customs seizure may prevent goods from reaching the buyer or being released into free circulation.
2. Is the foreign exporter automatically liable for delayed delivery?
No. Liability depends on the contract, delivery obligations, governing law, and cause of the seizure.
3. Does the CISG apply to sales contracts involving Turkish buyers?
Potentially. The CISG applies to qualifying international sales contracts under its relevant provisions.
4. Can customs seizure qualify as force majeure?
Potentially. The effect depends on the contract and applicable law, including CISG Article 79 where relevant.
5. Can the buyer terminate the contract because customs seized the goods?
Potentially, where the applicable legal requirements for avoidance or termination are satisfied.
6. Can the exporter claim payment even though the goods remain detained?
Potentially. The answer depends on the payment terms and whether the exporter fulfilled its contractual obligations.
7. Can the exporter recover goods under a retention of title clause?
Potentially, where the arrangement is legally effective and the exporter retains ownership.
8. Can foreign exporters challenge customs seizure in Turkey?
Potentially. The appropriate remedy depends on whether the measure is administrative detention or criminal seizure.
9. Can exporters recover compensation for unlawful customs seizure?
Potentially, where an applicable legal basis, compensable damage, and causal relationship are established.
10. What should a foreign exporter do first when customs seizure prevents delivery?
Review the sales contract and Incoterms, identify the legal basis for seizure, establish delivery and risk allocation, notify the buyer, and determine the appropriate customs and contractual remedies.
Foreign exporters facing customs seizure that prevents delivery under international sales contracts may require legal assistance involving the CISG, Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Customs Law No. 4458, Anti-Smuggling Law No. 5607, Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271, Incoterms, force majeure, contractual nonperformance, international arbitration, customs objections, release of goods, and compensation claims.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya provides legal assistance to foreign exporters, international manufacturers, overseas suppliers, trading companies, and commercial investors facing disputes involving customs seizure, delayed delivery, international sales contracts, buyer claims, contractual termination, and unpaid commercial receivables.
At Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office, we assist foreign clients with reviewing international sales contracts, examining customs and criminal investigation records, determining delivery and risk allocation, challenging unlawful customs restrictions, requesting release or re-export of goods, pursuing contractual claims, and evaluating compensation remedies arising from customs-related delivery failures.
Phone: 0312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: 0532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr