

Can a foreign buyer claim indemnity when a seller conceals historical customs penalties during a Turkish company acquisition? Learn about seller liability, share purchase agreement warranties, fraudulent concealment, escrow, damages, and legal remedies.
Foreign investors, multinational corporations, private equity funds, and international trading groups frequently acquire Turkish companies to expand manufacturing operations, establish distribution networks, or enter new commercial markets.
However, acquiring an established Turkish import company may involve substantial historical customs risks.
The target company may have imported goods for many years before the acquisition. These transactions may involve customs valuation, tariff classification, preferential origin, anti-dumping duties, import permits, and technical conformity requirements.
Customs authorities may have previously imposed administrative penalties or initiated proceedings concerning alleged irregularities.
Where the seller fails to disclose these matters, the foreign buyer may complete the acquisition without understanding the target company’s actual financial exposure.
For example, a foreign manufacturing group may acquire all shares of a Turkish import company for €6 million.
The share purchase agreement may contain warranties stating that the target company has complied with applicable customs legislation and that no material customs penalties remain outstanding.
After closing, the buyer may discover that customs authorities had imposed several administrative penalties before the acquisition.
The seller may have known about the penalties but failed to include them in the disclosure schedules.
The target company may subsequently receive payment orders or face enforcement proceedings concerning the outstanding amounts.
The buyer may argue that the concealed liabilities reduced the value of the acquired company and that the seller should compensate it.
In another situation, the seller may have paid certain penalties before closing but concealed the underlying customs violations.
Those violations may later lead to additional assessments concerning other import declarations.
Can a foreign buyer claim indemnity when the seller conceals historical customs penalties during a Turkish company acquisition?
Potentially, yes.
However, the available remedies depend on the share purchase agreement, the scope of the seller’s warranties, any specific indemnity provisions, the nature of the concealed liabilities, and the applicable governing law.
The buyer may possess contractual claims for breach of warranty, indemnification, damages, or other remedies.
Where the seller deliberately concealed material information, fraudulent misrepresentation may also require consideration.
However, the buyer must distinguish contractual recovery against the seller from the target company’s statutory customs obligations.
Turkish Customs Law No. 4458, Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Law No. 6183 on the Procedure for Collection of Public Receivables, and applicable procedural legislation may become relevant.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that foreign buyers should examine the seller’s knowledge, the contractual disclosure obligations, the legal status of historical customs penalties, the indemnity wording, applicable claim deadlines, and the financial impact of the concealed liabilities.
Historical customs penalties may create substantial financial exposure.
A target company may have received penalties concerning incorrect customs declarations, undervaluation, origin documentation, or other alleged violations.
Some penalties may remain unpaid.
Others may be under administrative objection or judicial review.
The buyer should determine whether the liabilities were disclosed and reflected in the purchase price.
No.
In a share acquisition, the target company generally continues to exist as the same legal entity.
Its historical customs obligations ordinarily remain with the company.
The change in shareholders does not automatically eliminate outstanding penalties.
However, the legality and enforceability of each penalty may still be challenged.
Not automatically.
The buyer acquires shares rather than automatically becoming the original customs debtor.
However, the economic burden of the target company’s liabilities may affect the value of the acquired shares.
Specific statutory rules may create additional exposure for certain shareholders or legal representatives.
The company’s legal form must be examined.
Potentially.
Where a legally enforceable penalty remains outstanding, customs authorities may pursue collection through the applicable framework.
However, the administration must comply with statutory requirements.
The target company may challenge unlawful assessments or collection measures.
Potentially.
The seller’s liability depends on the applicable contractual and statutory framework.
The share purchase agreement may contain warranties concerning compliance, investigations, penalties, and undisclosed liabilities.
Where the seller breaches an applicable obligation, contractual remedies may become available.
The buyer must establish the relevant breach and loss.
A customs indemnity is a contractual mechanism allocating responsibility for defined customs liabilities.
For example, the seller may agree to compensate the buyer for customs duties and penalties arising from pre-closing imports.
However, the scope depends on the agreement.
The buyer should identify which liabilities are covered and whether any exclusions apply.
Potentially.
The buyer must establish that the penalties fall within the contractual indemnity.
The agreement may cover penalties assessed before closing, penalties arising from pre-closing conduct, or both.
The wording is important.
Potentially.
A customs indemnity may cover liabilities arising from pre-closing transactions even where the assessment is issued after closing.
However, the relevant contractual conditions must be satisfied.
The buyer should examine the defined period and claim procedures.
The absence of a specific indemnity does not automatically eliminate every possible claim.
General warranties, contractual obligations, or statutory remedies may become relevant.
However, the buyer must establish the applicable legal basis.
Potentially.
The seller may have warranted that the target company complied with customs legislation or had no undisclosed penalties.
Where the warranty was inaccurate, a contractual claim may arise.
The buyer should identify the exact warranty and relevant breach.
An express warranty may provide an important contractual basis for recovery.
The buyer should establish that the penalty existed within the relevant contractual period.
The seller may argue that the matter was disclosed or excluded.
The agreement and disclosure schedules must be examined.
The buyer should determine whether the warranty covers administrative penalties as well as customs duties.
The terms may have different legal meanings.
A warranty concerning payment of duties does not necessarily cover every regulatory investigation or penalty.
The contractual wording must be examined.
A general compliance warranty may be relevant.
However, the scope depends on the agreement.
The buyer should determine whether the warranty covers historical declarations, administrative penalties, and regulatory investigations.
The buyer should compare the disclosure schedules with the actual customs records.
The seller may argue that the disclosed information was sufficient.
However, the buyer may contend that the undisclosed penalties constituted separate material liabilities.
The contractual disclosure standard must be examined.
The legal consequences depend on the disclosure wording and the relevant contractual requirements.
Disclosure of an investigation does not necessarily establish disclosure of every subsequent assessment.
The buyer should examine what information was available to the seller before closing.
Potentially.
The agreement may provide that disclosed matters qualify the warranties.
However, the scope depends on the contractual wording.
The buyer should determine whether general disclosure was sufficient or whether specific disclosure was required.
Deliberate concealment may raise additional legal issues.
The buyer may consider whether the conduct constitutes fraudulent misrepresentation.
However, the statutory requirements must be established.
Evidence of the seller’s knowledge and communications may be important.
Article 36 of Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 regulates fraud affecting contractual consent.
Where a party is induced to enter into a contract through fraudulent conduct, the legal consequences may include avoidance under the applicable conditions.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant statutory elements.
Potentially.
The availability of rescission or avoidance depends on the applicable contractual and statutory framework.
However, unwinding a completed acquisition may involve significant corporate and commercial consequences.
The buyer should evaluate the remedy carefully.
Potentially.
The buyer may pursue damages where the applicable contractual or statutory requirements are satisfied.
The appropriate remedy depends on the agreement and circumstances.
The buyer should establish the relevant breach and legally compensable loss.
Article 112 regulates liability arising from non-performance or improper performance of contractual obligations.
Where the seller breaches a contractual warranty or other obligation, compensation may become available.
The buyer must establish the relevant obligation, breach, damage, and causal relationship.
Article 49 regulates liability arising from unlawful acts under specified conditions.
Where the seller’s conduct constitutes an unlawful act causing damage, tort liability may become relevant.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
However, the recoverable amount depends on the contractual indemnity or damages framework.
The buyer must establish that the penalties fall within the relevant claim.
The amount assessed by customs authorities is not automatically recoverable from the seller.
Potentially.
The agreement may allocate responsibility for pre-closing customs duties.
However, the buyer should determine whether the relevant duties were legally payable and whether the contractual conditions are satisfied.
Potentially.
The applicable indemnity may cover specified interest-related amounts and collection costs.
However, the scope depends on the agreement and governing law.
The buyer should preserve payment and enforcement records.
Potentially.
The buyer may incur legal, accounting, or technical expenses responding to the customs dispute.
However, recoverability depends on the applicable contractual and legal framework.
The company should preserve invoices and evidence of the expenses.
Potentially.
The agreement may contain price adjustment provisions.
Other statutory remedies may also require consideration.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant legal basis.
Potentially.
Concealed customs penalties may affect the target company’s financial position.
The buyer may argue that the purchase price was based on inaccurate information.
However, the relevant valuation impact must be established.
Financial and expert evidence may be necessary.
Potentially.
However, speculative expectations are not automatically compensable.
The buyer should preserve reliable evidence of the alleged loss.
The contractual framework and applicable damages rules must be examined.
Potentially.
Customs enforcement may affect import operations, financing, or commercial relationships.
However, the buyer must establish legally compensable damage and causal relationship.
The agreement may also contain relevant limitations.
A liability cap limits the seller’s contractual exposure under specified conditions.
The buyer should determine whether customs claims fall within the general cap or a separate limit.
The relevant contractual wording must be examined.
Potentially.
The parties may negotiate a separate liability regime for customs claims.
However, the applicable contractual and statutory requirements must be considered.
A basket establishes a threshold for specified contractual claims.
The buyer should determine whether customs claims are subject to the basket.
Multiple historical penalties may need to be aggregated under the agreement.
A de minimis threshold excludes claims below a specified amount.
The buyer should examine whether individual penalties are measured separately or collectively.
The contractual wording may affect recovery.
A survival period determines how long specified contractual claims remain enforceable under the agreement.
The buyer should compare the period with the potential timing of customs assessments.
However, contractual survival periods and statutory limitation periods are distinct.
Potentially.
Turkish law contains restrictions concerning certain exclusions or limitations of liability.
Deliberate misconduct may affect the enforceability of contractual protections.
However, the relevant statutory provisions and circumstances must be examined.
Article 115 regulates agreements excluding or limiting liability under specified circumstances.
The provision contains restrictions concerning certain advance exclusions of liability.
The buyer should examine whether the relevant contractual limitation is enforceable.
Potentially.
Where the acquisition agreement includes an escrow arrangement, the buyer should examine the release conditions.
The customs claim may fall within the escrow provisions.
However, the buyer must comply with contractual notice and claim procedures.
Potentially.
The agreement may contain provisions permitting withholding or set-off under specified circumstances.
However, the buyer should not assume that every hidden customs penalty automatically permits suspension of payment.
The contractual and statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
Set-off may be available where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
The buyer should examine the nature and maturity of the respective claims.
The share purchase agreement may contain relevant provisions.
The buyer should preserve the indemnity notice and relevant correspondence.
The agreement’s dispute resolution provisions should be examined.
The buyer may need to pursue litigation or arbitration.
The applicable deadlines and procedural requirements must be respected.
Potentially.
A foreign investor may pursue contractual or statutory claims where Turkish courts possess jurisdiction.
The competent court depends on the nature of the dispute and applicable procedural rules.
The share purchase agreement should be examined for jurisdiction provisions.
Potentially.
Where a valid arbitration agreement exists, the dispute may fall within its scope.
The buyer should examine the arbitration clause and governing law.
The target company’s customs dispute remains separate from the private acquisition claim.
Potentially.
The target company may challenge an unlawful customs penalty through the applicable administrative procedure.
Article 242 of Customs Law No. 4458 establishes an objection framework for qualifying customs decisions.
The relevant deadline must be respected.
The buyer’s contractual claim against the seller is separate from the target company’s customs dispute.
Article 242 regulates administrative objections concerning qualifying customs decisions.
For decisions within its scope, the provision generally establishes a fifteen-day objection period from notification.
The target company should identify the relevant decision and competent authority.
Potentially.
Customs duty and related penalty disputes generally fall within tax court jurisdiction.
The court may examine the relevant statutory provisions and evidence.
However, the target company must comply with applicable procedural requirements.
Potentially.
Article 27 of Administrative Judicial Procedure Law No. 2577 regulates stays of execution and contains special provisions concerning tax litigation.
The applicable rules depend on the disputed decision.
The target company should determine whether a statutory suspension applies or a separate stay request is necessary.
A payment order is a separate public receivables collection measure.
Law No. 6183 regulates the relevant procedure.
The target company should distinguish the original customs penalty from the subsequent payment order.
Different legal remedies and deadlines may apply.
Potentially.
Article 58 of Law No. 6183 regulates challenges to payment orders.
The provision establishes specific grounds and a fifteen-day period for filing the relevant challenge.
However, payment-order litigation has a narrower scope than a general challenge to the underlying customs assessment.
Yes.
A post-closing review may help identify additional historical customs risks.
The buyer may examine import declarations, tariff classifications, valuation records, origin documents, and correspondence with customs authorities.
However, access to records and cooperation obligations may depend on the acquisition agreement and applicable law.
The buyer should examine the seller’s contractual cooperation and document delivery obligations.
The target company may also possess its own records.
Where the seller breaches an applicable obligation, legal remedies may become available.
However, the relevant contractual and statutory requirements must be established.
The answer depends on the indemnity wording.
Some indemnities may apply when a liability is incurred.
Others may require actual payment or another specified event.
The buyer should examine the contractual trigger and claim procedure.
The share purchase agreement may allocate rights concerning control of third-party claims.
However, the target company’s statutory rights and obligations must be respected.
The buyer should examine any notice, cooperation, settlement, or defense provisions.
The answer depends on the agreement.
An indemnity may require seller consent before settlement.
However, the target company’s statutory customs obligations remain governed by applicable law.
The buyer should ensure that contractual procedures do not cause missed customs deadlines.
The buyer should preserve the share purchase agreement, disclosure schedules, warranties, indemnities, and relevant correspondence.
Due diligence reports and data room records may establish what information was available before closing.
The company should obtain historical customs penalty decisions, assessment records, payment orders, and administrative correspondence.
Customs declarations, invoices, origin documents, tariff classification records, and valuation materials should be retained.
Financial statements and valuation reports may establish the effect of hidden penalties on the purchase price.
Any indemnity notice, escrow claim, or seller response should also be preserved.
A clear chronology should establish when the penalties were imposed, what the seller knew, what was disclosed, when the acquisition closed, and when the buyer discovered the liabilities.
A foreign buyer discovering concealed historical customs penalties should first obtain the relevant customs decisions and collection records.
The buyer should identify whether the penalties were imposed before closing or arose from pre-closing conduct.
The share purchase agreement and disclosure schedules should be reviewed.
The buyer should determine whether the seller breached a warranty, indemnity, or disclosure obligation.
The relevant contractual notice and claim deadlines should be identified.
The target company should separately examine whether the customs penalties are legally valid.
Where Customs Law Article 242 applies, the relevant objection deadline should be calculated from legally effective notification.
The buyer should preserve evidence concerning the seller’s knowledge and disclosures.
Where deliberate concealment is suspected, the applicable statutory remedies should be examined.
The buyer should also evaluate whether escrow funds, deferred purchase price provisions, or contractual security arrangements may be available.
Potential claims for indemnification, damages, price adjustment, or avoidance should be assessed under the governing law.
All relevant customs, contractual, and judicial deadlines should be calculated promptly.
1. Can a foreign buyer claim indemnity for historical customs penalties concealed by the seller?
Potentially, where the penalties fall within a valid contractual indemnity or another applicable legal basis.
2. Does a share acquisition eliminate the target company’s historical customs penalties?
No. The target company generally continues to possess its existing obligations.
3. Can the seller be liable for breaching customs compliance warranties?
Potentially, where the relevant contractual requirements are satisfied.
4. Can the buyer rescind the acquisition because of deliberate concealment?
Potentially, where the applicable statutory conditions concerning fraudulent misrepresentation or another remedy are satisfied.
5. What does Turkish Code of Obligations Article 36 provide?
Article 36 regulates fraud affecting contractual consent under specified conditions.
6. Can the buyer recover the full amount of hidden customs penalties?
Potentially, subject to the applicable indemnity, damages rules, and contractual limitations.
7. Can the buyer use escrow funds to cover customs penalties?
Potentially, where the claim falls within the escrow agreement and relevant procedures are satisfied.
8. Can the target company challenge historical customs penalties?
Potentially. Article 242 of Customs Law No. 4458 establishes an objection framework for qualifying customs decisions.
9. Can the buyer pursue international arbitration against the seller?
Potentially, where a valid arbitration agreement covers the dispute.
10. What should a foreign buyer do first after discovering concealed customs penalties?
Obtain the customs records, review the acquisition agreement and disclosures, identify contractual claim deadlines, examine the penalties, and evaluate indemnification, damages, and other legal remedies.
Foreign investors acquiring Turkish companies with concealed historical customs penalties may require legal assistance involving Customs Law No. 4458, Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Law No. 6183, Administrative Judicial Procedure Law No. 2577, share purchase agreements, customs due diligence, undisclosed liabilities, seller warranties, customs indemnities, fraudulent misrepresentation, acquisition disputes, tax court litigation, and international arbitration.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya provides legal assistance to foreign investors, multinational corporations, private equity funds, international trading groups, manufacturers, and commercial buyers facing disputes involving hidden customs penalties, historical import liabilities, administrative investigations, undisclosed regulatory risks, and post-acquisition claims.
At Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office, we assist foreign clients with reviewing share purchase agreements, examining customs due diligence records, identifying concealed customs liabilities, evaluating seller warranties and indemnities, challenging unlawful customs assessments, pursuing contractual remedies, and assessing litigation or arbitration options arising from acquisition disputes.
Phone: 0312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: 0532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr