

Can foreign buyers recover lost profits from Turkish suppliers for defective goods? Learn about CISG Article 74, foreseeability, causation, evidence, replacement purchases, damages calculations and commercial litigation in Turkey.
A foreign company that receives defective goods from a Turkish supplier may suffer financial losses extending far beyond the purchase price of the products.
Defective machinery, industrial components, textiles, electronics, construction materials, automotive parts, and other manufactured goods may disrupt production, prevent resale, cause customer cancellations, and reduce expected business profits.
In international commercial transactions, the financial consequences of defective products can be substantial.
For example, a foreign distributor may purchase 10,000 electronic devices from a Turkish manufacturer for resale under existing customer contracts. After delivery, the distributor may discover that a significant percentage of the devices fail quality testing.
The distributor may be unable to fulfill customer orders and may lose the expected profit from those sales.
In another case, an international manufacturing company may purchase specialized machinery from Turkey. The equipment may contain serious defects that prevent the buyer’s production line from operating at the agreed capacity.
The buyer may lose revenue because it cannot manufacture products for its customers.
More serious situations may involve defective components that cause production shutdowns, rejected retail collections, cancelled distribution agreements, delayed construction projects, or product recalls.
The foreign buyer may claim that the Turkish supplier is responsible not only for the defective goods but also for the profits that would have been earned if the products had complied with the contract.
The supplier may dispute the claim, arguing that the alleged profits are speculative, that the buyer failed to mitigate its losses, or that the financial consequences were not reasonably foreseeable when the contract was concluded.
These circumstances raise important legal questions.
Can a foreign buyer recover lost profits caused by defective goods supplied from Turkey? What does Article 74 of the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods provide? Must the buyer prove actual customer orders? Can projected sales be used to calculate damages? Can the buyer recover lost production revenue? What happens when the supplier argues that the claimed losses were unforeseeable?
Under Turkish law and applicable international sales rules, lost profits may be recoverable where the claimant establishes the relevant contractual breach, financial loss, causal connection, and applicable legal requirements.
However, lost profits are not automatically awarded merely because the buyer received defective goods.
The buyer must establish that the claimed profits were legally recoverable and sufficiently supported by evidence.
For qualifying international sales, the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) may apply.
Article 35 establishes important conformity requirements.
Article 45 establishes buyer remedies for seller nonperformance.
Article 74 expressly recognizes damages that may include loss of profit, subject to the foreseeability limitation.
Article 77 establishes a duty to mitigate loss.
Articles 75 and 76 provide additional damages mechanisms in specified circumstances.
Where Turkish domestic law applies, the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 establishes important rules concerning contractual liability, defective goods, damages, and compensation.
The Turkish Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 establishes important rules concerning evidence, expert examination, and judicial assessment of damages.
This guide explains how foreign buyers can establish lost profit claims, calculate recoverable damages, preserve financial evidence, and pursue compensation against Turkish suppliers under the 2026 legal framework.
Potentially.
Lost profits may be recoverable where defective goods cause a legally compensable financial loss.
For example, a foreign distributor may lose confirmed customer sales because products supplied from Turkey fail quality testing.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant contractual breach and causal connection.
The amount must be supported by evidence.
The applicable governing law must be examined.
Lost profits generally concern net financial gains that a business would have earned but for the relevant breach.
For example, a retailer may have expected to earn profit from resale of conforming products.
Defective goods may prevent those sales.
However, lost profits should be distinguished from gross revenue.
The buyer must account for relevant costs that would have been incurred in earning the income.
No.
Revenue represents income generated from sales.
Profit generally reflects revenue after relevant costs.
For example, a buyer may lose a customer order worth a substantial amount.
However, the recoverable lost profit may be lower because the buyer avoided purchasing, shipping, marketing, or other expenses.
The appropriate calculation depends on the circumstances.
Not automatically.
The value of cancelled orders may provide evidence concerning lost revenue.
However, the buyer must establish the legally recoverable financial loss.
For example, costs that were avoided because the orders were cancelled may need to be deducted.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the calculation.
Article 74 establishes the general damages framework for breach of contract under the CISG.
Damages may include loss suffered and loss of profit.
However, damages cannot exceed the loss that the party in breach foresaw or ought to have foreseen at the time of contract conclusion as a possible consequence of the breach, considering the facts and matters known or that ought to have been known.
The buyer must establish the relevant loss and causal connection.
Yes.
Article 74 expressly includes loss of profit within the general damages framework.
However, the claimant must satisfy the applicable requirements.
For example, the buyer may need to establish that defective goods prevented profitable customer sales.
The amount must be supported by reliable evidence.
No.
The existence of defective goods does not automatically establish a lost profit claim.
The buyer must prove the relevant loss.
The supplier may dispute causation, foreseeability, or the amount.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the evidence.
The foreseeability requirement limits recoverable damages.
The relevant question concerns what the party in breach foresaw or ought to have foreseen at the time of contract conclusion as a possible consequence of breach.
For example, a supplier may know that goods are intended for resale.
However, unusually extensive downstream losses may require closer examination.
The relevant circumstances must be established.
Not necessarily.
Article 74 concerns foreseeability of the possible consequences of breach.
However, the supplier’s knowledge of the commercial transaction may be important.
For example, the manufacturer may know that the buyer intends to resell the products.
The buyer must still establish the claimed financial loss.
The legal assessment depends on the circumstances.
Potentially.
International suppliers frequently know that distributors purchase goods for resale.
For example, a Turkish manufacturer may supply products to a foreign wholesaler.
The manufacturer may reasonably anticipate that defective goods could prevent resale.
However, the scope and amount of recoverable damages depend on the facts.
The statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
For example, a Turkish supplier may provide machinery or components needed for the buyer’s production operations.
The supplier may know that defective goods could disrupt manufacturing.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant knowledge and resulting loss.
The court must examine the circumstances.
Potentially.
A supplier may know that specialized materials are required for a scheduled project.
Defective products may cause delays.
However, the recoverability of resulting lost profits depends on foreseeability, causation, and proof.
The buyer must establish the relevant financial consequences.
Potentially.
For example, a foreign distributor may have confirmed orders for products supplied by a Turkish manufacturer.
The products may be defective and unsuitable for resale.
The customers may cancel their orders.
The buyer may claim qualifying lost profits.
However, the relevant contracts, cancellations, and financial calculations must be established.
Potentially.
A retailer may be unable to sell defective products.
However, the buyer must establish the expected sales and profit.
For example, historical sales records may provide evidence.
The court may also consider market conditions.
Speculative expectations do not automatically establish recoverable damages.
Potentially.
For example, a foreign distributor may lose a valuable customer agreement because the Turkish supplier delivered defective goods.
However, the buyer must establish that the loss was caused by the breach.
The supplier may dispute foreseeability.
The relevant contractual and financial evidence must be examined.
Potentially.
For example, defective goods may prevent the buyer from performing a contract awarded through a tender.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant financial loss.
The court may examine whether the tender contract was binding and profitable.
A mere possibility of winning future tenders may be insufficient.
Potentially.
A foreign company may plan a product launch using goods manufactured in Turkey.
Defective products may prevent the launch.
However, the buyer must establish the expected commercial results.
The supplier may dispute whether the claimed profits were foreseeable.
The relevant evidence must be examined.
Potentially.
Seasonal goods may lose commercial value after the relevant selling period.
For example, defective clothing may prevent a retailer from completing seasonal sales.
The buyer may possess a lost profit claim.
However, the amount must be established through reliable evidence.
Potentially.
Defective machinery may reduce production capacity or cause shutdowns.
For example, a manufacturing company may be unable to fulfill customer orders.
The buyer may claim lost profits.
However, the claimant must establish the technical defect, operational impact, and financial loss.
Potentially.
For example, defective components may stop an entire production line.
The buyer may lose output and sales.
However, the claimant must establish the causal connection.
The court may examine whether alternative production arrangements were available.
Potentially.
A machine may operate below the guaranteed production capacity.
The buyer may produce fewer units than expected.
However, the buyer must establish the actual reduction and resulting profit loss.
Technical and financial expert examination may be necessary.
Potentially.
Defective components may interrupt manufacturing or customer deliveries.
For example, an automotive supplier may be unable to complete assemblies.
The buyer may possess damages claims.
However, the relevant financial loss and causal connection must be established.
Potentially.
Electronic products may fail quality testing or malfunction after resale.
The buyer may lose customer orders.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant losses.
The supplier may dispute whether the defects caused the alleged sales decline.
Potentially.
For example, garments may fail agreed quality standards.
The retailer may be unable to sell the products.
The buyer may claim lost profits.
However, the calculation must account for relevant costs and commercial circumstances.
Potentially.
Defective materials may delay construction or require replacement.
The buyer may incur financial losses.
However, the recoverability of lost profits depends on the applicable legal requirements.
The buyer must establish the relevant causal connection.
Potentially.
Incorrect chemical composition may disrupt manufacturing processes.
The buyer may lose production output.
However, the claimant must establish the technical nonconformity and resulting financial loss.
Expert evidence may be important.
Potentially.
Defective packaging may prevent products from being sold or shipped.
For example, packaging may fail safety or durability requirements.
The buyer may lose customer orders.
However, the relevant loss and causation must be established.
Potentially.
A product recall may interrupt sales and damage commercial relationships.
However, the buyer must distinguish direct recall expenses from lost profits.
The claimant must establish the relevant financial consequences.
The applicable foreseeability and mitigation requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
Customer refunds may represent direct financial losses.
Lost profits may arise separately where the buyer loses expected margins.
However, the buyer must avoid duplicative recovery.
The court must examine the relevant calculations.
Potentially.
However, future orders may be more difficult to establish.
For example, a customer may have regularly purchased products from the buyer.
The buyer may argue that defective goods caused the customer to stop ordering.
The claimant must establish the relevant probability, causation, and financial loss.
Speculative expectations are not automatically recoverable.
Potentially.
However, the claimant must establish a legally recoverable financial loss.
For example, defective products may cause customers to switch to competitors.
The buyer may require economic analysis.
General allegations of reduced market share do not automatically establish compensation.
Potentially.
However, reputational harm and lost profits must be established.
For example, defective products may cause customers to terminate relationships.
The buyer must identify the resulting financial consequences.
The court may require detailed evidence.
Potentially.
For example, a foreign distributor may lose exclusive distribution rights because defective products caused repeated customer complaints.
However, the claimant must establish the contractual relationship and causal connection.
The supplier may dispute foreseeability.
The relevant evidence must be examined.
Potentially.
Defective products may affect franchise operations.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant financial loss.
For example, franchise customers may cancel confirmed orders.
The court must examine the contractual and commercial circumstances.
Potentially.
For example, the buyer may purchase goods from Turkey for resale to another country.
Defective products may prevent fulfillment of the export contract.
The buyer may possess a lost profit claim.
However, the relevant contracts and financial calculations must be established.
Potentially.
The buyer may lose a public procurement contract because of defective goods.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant contractual obligations and financial loss.
The supplier may dispute foreseeability.
The applicable damages framework must be examined.
Potentially.
Defective goods may require replacement or repair, delaying downstream deliveries.
The buyer may lose sales or incur contractual penalties.
However, the claimant must distinguish lost profits from other damages.
The relevant financial consequences must be established.
Potentially.
Defective machinery may delay installation or commissioning.
The buyer may be unable to begin production.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant loss and causal connection.
Technical and financial evidence may be necessary.
Potentially.
Defective materials may delay project completion.
The buyer may lose revenue associated with the project.
However, the supplier’s responsibility depends on foreseeability and causation.
The relevant contracts and project records must be examined.
Potentially.
Defective spare parts may prevent machinery or vehicles from operating.
The buyer may lose commercial revenue.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant technical defect and financial loss.
The supplier may dispute the causal connection.
Potentially.
Defective raw materials may cause production failures.
For example, incorrect material composition may render finished products unusable.
The buyer may possess damages claims.
However, the relevant loss must be established.
Potentially.
Defective goods may fail regulatory or technical requirements.
The buyer may be unable to import or resell them.
However, the supplier’s responsibility depends on the contract and applicable law.
The buyer must establish the relevant loss and foreseeability.
Potentially.
For example, goods may fail customer specifications.
The buyer may be unable to complete resale transactions.
However, the claimant must establish the expected profit and causal connection.
The relevant contracts and market evidence may be important.
Potentially.
Defective goods may be sold at reduced prices.
The buyer may suffer reduced margins.
However, the legal analysis may involve price reduction, damages, or other remedies.
The buyer must avoid duplicative recovery.
The relevant financial calculations must be examined.
Potentially.
The buyer may lose the opportunity to sell products that must be destroyed.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant financial loss.
The court must examine whether destruction was legally required or commercially reasonable.
The applicable damages framework must be considered.
Potentially.
Customer returns may reduce the buyer’s revenue and profit.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant transactions and financial consequences.
The supplier may dispute whether the returns resulted from manufacturing defects.
The buyer should preserve return records.
Potentially.
For example, defective products may cause an online retailer to suspend listings.
The buyer may lose expected sales.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant financial loss.
Historical sales data may be important.
Potentially.
A marketplace may suspend a seller because of defective products or customer complaints.
The buyer may lose sales.
However, the claimant must establish that the suspension was caused by the supplier’s breach.
The relevant marketplace records and financial evidence must be examined.
Potentially.
Chargebacks may create direct financial losses.
Lost profits may arise separately.
However, the buyer must distinguish these categories.
The relevant payment and customer records should be preserved.
Potentially.
Defective goods may prevent the buyer from completing a planned campaign.
However, the claimant must establish the expected commercial benefit.
Advertising expenses may constitute a separate damages category.
The buyer must avoid duplicative recovery.
Potentially.
For example, defective products may cause a commercial partner to terminate a distribution arrangement.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant contractual relationship and financial loss.
The supplier may dispute foreseeability.
The court must examine the evidence.
Potentially, but the legal requirements may be difficult to establish.
For example, the buyer may claim that defective goods caused the loss of future customer opportunities.
However, speculative possibilities do not automatically establish recoverable damage.
The claimant must provide reliable evidence.
The court must examine causation and foreseeability.
Not necessarily in every case.
Confirmed customer orders may provide strong evidence.
However, lost profits may also be established through other reliable commercial data.
For example, historical sales records may support a reasonable calculation.
The applicable evidentiary requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Historical sales data may help establish expected revenue and margins.
For example, the buyer may show consistent sales of similar products before the defective shipment.
However, the court must consider market conditions and other factors.
Historical performance does not automatically establish future profits.
Potentially.
Past profit margins may provide relevant financial evidence.
However, the calculation must reflect the specific transaction.
For example, costs may differ between product lines.
The court may require expert financial analysis.
Potentially.
Sales forecasts may support a lost profit claim.
However, the evidentiary value depends on reliability.
For example, forecasts prepared before the dispute may be more persuasive than unsupported estimates created afterward.
The court must examine the circumstances.
Potentially.
Business plans may contain projected sales and profit margins.
However, projections are not automatically recoverable damages.
The claimant must establish a reliable basis.
The court may consider actual market performance.
Yes, potentially.
Confirmed customer contracts may provide important evidence.
For example, the buyer may have agreed to resell goods at a specified price.
Defective products may prevent performance.
However, the buyer must establish the expected net profit and causal connection.
Potentially.
Customer purchase orders may establish expected sales.
However, the legal effect depends on whether the orders were binding and likely to be performed.
The buyer should preserve acceptance records.
The court must examine the relevant circumstances.
Potentially.
Cancellation notices may show that customers withdrew orders because of defective goods.
However, the buyer must establish the causal connection.
For example, the customer may have cancelled for unrelated commercial reasons.
The court must examine the evidence.
Potentially.
Emails may document customer complaints, cancellations, or lost sales.
However, authenticity and context must be examined.
The buyer should preserve the complete correspondence.
The financial consequences must also be established.
Potentially.
Messages may contain customer cancellations or supplier admissions.
However, authenticity and context must be examined.
A screenshot alone may not conclusively establish the amount of lost profit.
The buyer should preserve communications lawfully.
Yes, potentially.
Accounting records may establish revenue, expenses, and profit margins.
However, the records must be reliable and relevant.
The court may require expert examination.
The buyer should preserve supporting invoices and financial statements.
Potentially.
Tax returns may provide information concerning historical business performance.
However, they may not establish the precise profit lost from a particular transaction.
The court must examine the relevant financial data.
Additional evidence may be necessary.
Potentially.
Bank statements may establish payments and financial transactions.
However, they do not automatically prove expected profits.
The buyer may need customer contracts, invoices, and accounting records.
The relevant financial analysis must be completed.
Potentially.
Inventory records may show that defective products could not be sold.
However, the buyer must establish the expected sales and profit.
The supplier may dispute the market demand.
The court must examine the evidence.
Potentially.
Production records may establish lost output caused by defective machinery or components.
However, the buyer must connect the production loss to financial consequences.
The court may require technical and financial expert examination.
Potentially.
An expert may calculate expected profits using relevant financial data.
However, the report must rely on reasonable assumptions.
The supplier may challenge the methodology.
The court or arbitral tribunal must evaluate the evidence.
Yes.
The supplier may dispute projected sales, profit margins, causation, or foreseeability.
For example, the manufacturer may argue that the buyer’s sales declined because of market conditions rather than defective goods.
The court must examine the evidence.
The claimant bears the relevant burden of establishing the loss.
Yes.
The supplier may argue that the claimed profits were uncertain.
However, uncertainty does not automatically eliminate every lost profit claim.
The buyer may establish the loss through reliable evidence.
The court must examine the applicable evidentiary standard.
Potentially.
For example, the supplier may argue that the buyer’s resale operation was unprofitable.
The buyer may rely on historical margins and customer contracts.
The court must examine the relevant financial data.
The appropriate calculation depends on the circumstances.
Potentially.
Market conditions may affect sales and profitability.
For example, demand may decline independently of the defective shipment.
The buyer must establish the causal connection between the breach and claimed loss.
The court may consider alternative causes.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that the buyer lacked sufficient demand to sell the goods.
The buyer may rely on customer orders and historical sales.
The court must examine the evidence.
The existence of defective goods does not automatically establish lost sales.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that poor marketing caused the sales decline.
However, the buyer may establish that defective goods prevented sales regardless of marketing efforts.
The relevant causal relationship must be examined.
The court may consider commercial circumstances.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that the buyer’s resale prices were unrealistic.
However, the buyer may rely on confirmed customer contracts or historical prices.
The court must examine whether the expected profits were commercially supportable.
Yes.
Article 77 of the CISG establishes a duty to take reasonable measures to mitigate loss.
For example, the supplier may argue that the buyer could have purchased replacement goods.
However, the required measures depend on the circumstances.
Failure to mitigate may reduce recoverable damages.
Article 77 requires a party relying on a breach to take reasonable measures to mitigate the loss, including loss of profit.
If the party fails to take such measures, the party in breach may claim a reduction in damages by the amount that should have been mitigated.
However, the reasonableness of mitigation depends on the circumstances.
The buyer is not automatically required to take commercially unreasonable action.
Not automatically.
However, purchasing replacements may be a reasonable mitigation measure in some circumstances.
For example, substitute products may be readily available.
In other cases, replacement may be impossible or excessively expensive.
The court must examine the circumstances.
Not automatically.
Repair may be a reasonable mitigation measure where practical.
However, the supplier may possess cure rights under the applicable law.
The buyer should examine the contract and circumstances.
Unreasonable repair expenses may affect recoverable damages.
Not automatically.
Discounted resale may be commercially reasonable in some cases.
However, safety, regulatory, or contractual restrictions may prevent resale.
The buyer is not required to engage in unlawful conduct.
The relevant circumstances must be examined.
Reasonable customer notification may help mitigate losses.
For example, the buyer may inform customers of delivery problems.
However, the legal consequences depend on the circumstances.
The buyer should preserve relevant communications.
The court may examine whether reasonable mitigation measures were taken.
Potentially.
Continued operation may increase damage or create safety risks.
However, the appropriate response depends on the defect and circumstances.
The buyer should consider technical advice.
The supplier may dispute losses caused by continued unreasonable use.
Potentially.
Acceptance of goods does not automatically eliminate every damages claim.
However, the buyer must comply with applicable inspection and notification requirements.
For example, the buyer may accept products and later discover hidden defects.
The relevant legal framework must be examined.
Yes, potentially.
A damages claim may be available without contract avoidance.
For example, the buyer may retain defective machinery and seek compensation for reduced production.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant loss.
The applicable legal requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Valid avoidance does not automatically eliminate damages rights.
For example, the buyer may avoid the contract and claim qualifying losses.
Articles 74–77 may remain relevant.
However, the buyer must establish the statutory requirements.
Potentially.
However, the remedies must be legally compatible.
For example, valid avoidance may create restitution rights.
Lost profits may be claimed separately where recoverable.
The buyer cannot automatically recover the same loss twice.
Potentially.
However, the calculation must avoid duplication.
For example, the buyer may purchase replacement goods at a higher price.
The buyer may also claim other qualifying losses.
The court must examine the relationship between the claimed amounts.
Potentially.
However, the remedies must be legally compatible and must not produce duplicative compensation.
For example, price reduction may address diminished value.
Lost profits may concern separate consequential loss.
The applicable legal framework must be examined.
Potentially.
However, the agreement and governing law must be examined.
The buyer cannot automatically recover overlapping amounts.
For example, a penalty clause may address specified losses.
The court must interpret the relevant provisions.
Potentially.
Article 78 of the CISG establishes an entitlement to interest on sums in arrears, without prejudice to damages under Article 74.
However, the applicable interest rate and accrual issues may require determination under the relevant legal framework.
The contract may also contain interest provisions.
Potentially.
The allocation of legal costs depends on the applicable procedural framework and dispute resolution mechanism.
For example, litigation costs may be allocated under relevant court rules.
Arbitration may involve different cost provisions.
The buyer should not automatically assume that every legal expense is recoverable as contractual damages.
Potentially.
Expert expenses may be recoverable under the applicable procedural or damages framework.
For example, the buyer may commission technical and financial reports.
However, the relevant costs must be reasonable and legally recoverable.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the circumstances.
Potentially.
Currency fluctuations may affect the value of payments or losses.
However, the applicable damages framework and contractual currency provisions must be examined.
The buyer must establish the relevant financial consequences.
Not every exchange rate movement automatically creates recoverable damage.
Potentially.
For example, the buyer may incur additional borrowing expenses because defective goods prevent expected sales.
However, the recoverability of financing costs depends on foreseeability and causation.
The buyer must establish the relevant expenses.
The court must examine the circumstances.
Potentially.
Defective machinery or components may interrupt business operations.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant financial loss.
The court may require detailed accounting and technical evidence.
The applicable foreseeability and mitigation requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
The buyer may receive several shipments containing defective products.
However, each shipment may involve separate contractual and evidentiary issues.
The buyer should identify the relevant defects and financial losses.
The applicable contract and governing law must be examined.
Potentially.
For example, a long-term supply agreement may involve multiple deliveries.
Defects in one shipment may affect future orders.
However, the legal consequences depend on the contract and applicable CISG provisions.
Article 73 may become relevant to installment contracts.
The buyer must establish the relevant loss.
Potentially.
The buyer may lose future profits because the supplier’s breach causes termination.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant contractual rights and financial loss.
The supplier may dispute foreseeability and causation.
The court must examine the evidence.
Potentially.
For example, defective goods may cause a foreign distributor to lose an exclusive distribution agreement.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant contractual relationship and financial consequences.
The supplier may dispute whether the loss was foreseeable.
The statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially, but the evidentiary challenges may be substantial.
For example, a newly established company may lack historical sales records.
The buyer may rely on confirmed contracts, market data, and other reliable evidence.
However, speculative projections are not automatically recoverable.
The court must examine the circumstances.
Potentially.
However, the startup must establish the relevant financial loss.
For example, a startup may have binding customer orders for products manufactured in Turkey.
Defective goods may prevent performance.
The court may consider the available commercial evidence.
Potentially.
For example, a foreign investor may purchase machinery for a new manufacturing facility.
The machinery may fail to meet agreed performance standards.
The investor may claim qualifying losses.
However, the relevant contractual relationship, causation, and foreseeability must be established.
Potentially.
Article 38 of the CISG establishes inspection obligations.
However, the required inspection depends on the circumstances.
For example, hidden manufacturing defects may become apparent only after operation.
The court must examine what inspection was practicable.
Article 38 requires the buyer to examine the goods, or cause them to be examined, within as short a period as practicable in the circumstances.
However, the timing depends on the delivery arrangement and nature of the goods.
For example, complex machinery may require specialized testing.
The buyer should not assume that inspection can be delayed indefinitely.
Article 39 requires the buyer to notify the seller of the lack of conformity within a reasonable time after discovering it or when it ought to have discovered it.
The notice must specify the nature of the nonconformity.
Article 39(2) generally establishes an outer period of two years from actual handover, unless inconsistent with a contractual guarantee period.
However, Articles 40 and 44 may affect the consequences of certain notice failures.
Yes.
Failure to comply with applicable notification requirements may affect the buyer’s remedies.
For example, the supplier may argue that the buyer lost the right to rely on the nonconformity.
However, the legal consequences depend on the governing law and circumstances.
The buyer should preserve evidence concerning discovery and notification.
Article 40 limits the seller’s ability to rely on Articles 38 and 39 where the lack of conformity relates to facts the seller knew or could not have been unaware of and failed to disclose to the buyer.
For example, deliberate concealment of known defects may raise questions under Article 40.
However, the statutory conditions must be established.
The buyer must prove the relevant facts.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that the buyer installed, stored, or used the goods incorrectly.
However, the buyer may establish that the products were defective when delivered.
The relevant technical evidence must be examined.
The court may require expert analysis.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that the goods were damaged during carriage.
However, the buyer may establish that the defects originated during manufacturing.
The relevant transport and technical evidence must be examined.
Article 36 of the CISG may become relevant.
Article 36 generally makes the seller responsible for nonconformity existing when risk passes, even if discovered later.
The provision also addresses certain nonconformities arising after risk passes where they result from a breach of the seller’s obligations.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
The buyer must establish the relevant facts.
Potentially.
However, risk transfer does not automatically eliminate liability for defects existing when risk passed.
For example, a product may contain a manufacturing defect before shipment.
The buyer may discover the defect later.
The contract and Article 36 must be examined.
Yes.
Incoterms may allocate delivery obligations, costs, and risk of loss.
However, they do not automatically replace contractual quality obligations.
For example, risk may pass at a specified point.
Nevertheless, the supplier may remain responsible for qualifying manufacturing defects.
The relevant legal framework must be examined.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that reasonable repair could have reduced losses.
However, the buyer may establish that repair was impractical or ineffective.
Article 77 of the CISG may become relevant.
The court must examine the circumstances.
Potentially.
The supplier may offer conforming replacements.
The buyer may refuse.
However, the legal consequences depend on the contract and applicable law.
The court may examine whether accepting replacement would have been a reasonable mitigation measure.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that substitute goods were available.
However, the buyer may establish that replacements were unavailable or commercially unreasonable.
The relevant market conditions must be examined.
Article 77 may become important.
Potentially.
Continued sale of defective products may affect damages and mitigation.
However, the legal consequences depend on the nature of the defects and applicable law.
The buyer should not engage in unlawful or unsafe distribution.
The court must examine the circumstances.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that prompt customer notification could have reduced losses.
However, the reasonableness of notification depends on the circumstances.
The buyer must establish the relevant commercial response.
The court may consider mitigation obligations.
Potentially.
The supplier may challenge the buyer’s ability to prove defects or losses.
For example, defective products may have been destroyed without documentation.
The buyer should preserve representative samples and technical records.
Judicial evidence preservation may be appropriate.
Yes.
Independent testing may help establish product defects.
For example, a laboratory may examine material composition, electrical performance, or mechanical durability.
However, the evidentiary value depends on the methodology and circumstances.
The buyer should preserve representative samples.
Yes.
Financial expert analysis may help calculate lost profits.
For example, an expert may examine customer contracts, historical sales, and profit margins.
However, the report must rely on reliable assumptions.
The court or arbitral tribunal must evaluate the evidence.
Potentially.
A court may appoint a financial expert where specialized knowledge is necessary.
For example, the expert may analyze expected revenue and avoided costs.
However, the court determines the legal consequences.
The expert’s calculation must be supported by relevant evidence.
Potentially.
Articles 400–405 of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 establish mechanisms concerning preservation of evidence.
For example, the buyer may seek examination of defective goods or relevant records where there is a legally sufficient risk of evidence loss.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Evidence preservation is not an unrestricted discovery procedure.
Potentially.
Articles 219 and following of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure establish important rules concerning documentary evidence.
A court may order production of relevant documents under the applicable conditions.
For example, manufacturing test records may help establish whether the supplier knew of defects.
The applicant must identify the documents and legal relevance.
Potentially.
Financial records may be relevant to calculating lost profits.
However, the buyer must identify the relevant documents and legal basis.
The court must examine relevance and confidentiality.
The procedure does not automatically provide unrestricted access to every company record.
Yes.
Customer contracts may establish expected resale transactions.
However, the buyer must prove the relevant profit and causal connection.
The supplier may challenge whether the contracts would have been performed.
The court must examine the evidence.
Yes, potentially.
Cancellation notices may help establish that defective goods caused lost sales.
However, the buyer must examine the reasons for cancellation.
The supplier may dispute causation.
The relevant correspondence should be preserved.
Potentially.
Sales forecasts may support a lost profit calculation.
However, the court must examine their reliability.
For example, forecasts prepared before the dispute may be relevant.
Speculative projections do not automatically establish recoverable damage.
Potentially.
Historical margins may provide relevant evidence.
However, the calculation must reflect the specific transaction.
The court may consider changes in costs and market conditions.
Expert financial analysis may be necessary.
Potentially.
Tax returns may provide evidence concerning business performance.
However, they may not establish the precise profit lost from a particular shipment.
The buyer should preserve supporting financial records.
The court must examine the relevant evidence.
Potentially.
Bank statements may establish payments and financial transactions.
However, they do not automatically prove expected profits.
The buyer may need customer contracts, invoices, and accounting records.
The relevant financial analysis must be completed.
Potentially.
Communications may establish customer cancellations, supplier admissions, or commercial expectations.
However, authenticity and context must be examined.
A screenshot alone may not conclusively establish lost profits.
The buyer should preserve complete communications lawfully.
Potentially.
Where the CISG does not apply or has been validly excluded, the Turkish Code of Obligations may govern contractual damages.
Article 112 establishes important rules concerning liability for improper performance.
Articles 219–231 establish relevant defective goods provisions.
However, the claimant must establish the applicable statutory requirements.
Article 112 establishes the general framework concerning liability for failure to perform an obligation properly.
The debtor may be liable for resulting damage unless it establishes the relevant absence of fault under the statutory framework.
However, the claimant must establish the obligation, breach, damage, and causal connection.
For example, defective goods may prevent the buyer from completing customer sales.
The buyer must establish the resulting legally recoverable loss.
Article 219 establishes important rules concerning the seller’s liability for defects.
The provision addresses defects that reduce or eliminate the value or expected usefulness of goods and the absence of promised qualities.
For example, products that fail agreed technical specifications may raise defect liability questions.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Article 227 establishes important buyer remedies concerning defective goods under Turkish domestic sales law.
Depending on the statutory conditions, the buyer may seek rescission, price reduction, repair, or replacement.
The buyer may also possess compensation rights under the applicable framework.
However, the availability of each remedy depends on the circumstances.
Potentially.
The Turkish Code of Obligations establishes relevant compensation rules concerning defective goods.
However, the precise legal basis and requirements must be examined.
For example, the buyer may seek damages arising from defective products.
The claimant must establish the relevant loss and causal connection.
Potentially.
Article 125 establishes important creditor remedies in specified debtor default situations.
However, the provision’s application depends on the nature of the breach and applicable statutory conditions.
For example, the buyer may claim damages arising from nonperformance.
The relevant legal framework must be examined.
Article 138 concerns excessive difficulty of performance under specified conditions.
It is not a general lost profit damages provision.
However, hardship issues may arise in certain contractual disputes.
The buyer should distinguish hardship relief from compensation for defective goods.
The relevant statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
The CISG may apply where the parties have their places of business in different Contracting States and the relevant conditions are satisfied.
It may also apply through applicable private international law rules in specified circumstances.
However, the parties may exclude the CISG under Article 6.
The buyer should examine the contract and governing law.
Yes.
Article 6 permits parties to exclude the CISG or derogate from specified provisions under the Convention’s framework.
However, the exclusion must be established through the contract and applicable interpretation rules.
A general choice of Turkish law does not necessarily exclude the CISG.
No.
The CISG forms part of the applicable legal framework in qualifying international sales.
A contractual choice of Turkish law does not automatically mean that domestic sales law replaces the CISG.
The parties may expressly exclude the Convention.
The relevant contractual wording must be examined.
Potentially.
The agreement may contain liability limitation or exclusion clauses.
For example, the supplier may attempt to exclude consequential damages or lost profits.
However, the validity and enforceability of such clauses depend on the governing law and circumstances.
The buyer should examine the relevant provisions.
Potentially.
The parties may agree on specified limitations.
However, the legal effect depends on the wording and governing law.
The term “consequential damages” may be interpreted differently across legal systems.
The buyer should not assume that every exclusion automatically eliminates all lost profit claims.
Potentially.
A supply agreement may limit liability to a specified amount.
However, the enforceability of the cap depends on the governing law and circumstances.
For example, limitations concerning intentional or grossly negligent conduct may face statutory restrictions.
The relevant legal framework must be examined.
Potentially.
However, a disclaimer does not automatically eliminate every contractual obligation.
The buyer should examine whether the clause validly limits the relevant claim.
The supplier’s conduct and applicable mandatory rules may be important.
The legal consequences depend on the agreement.
Potentially.
The Turkish Code of Obligations establishes relevant rules concerning contractual limitations and general transaction terms.
For example, Articles 20–25 regulate general transaction terms.
Article 115 establishes important restrictions concerning advance exclusions of liability.
However, the applicable requirements must be examined.
Potentially, but personal liability is not automatic.
The supplier company generally possesses separate legal personality.
A director is not automatically responsible for every contractual debt.
However, separate personal liability may arise where the director’s own conduct satisfies an applicable legal basis.
The buyer must establish the relevant statutory requirements.
Potentially.
However, the buyer may not possess a direct contract with the subcontractor.
Separate liability may arise under applicable law.
The buyer must establish the relevant legal basis.
The contracting supplier may remain responsible for performance under the applicable framework.
Potentially.
However, carrier liability depends on the transport relationship and applicable conventions.
For example, transport-related damage may be governed by separate liability rules and limits.
The buyer must distinguish manufacturing defects from transport damage.
The relevant legal framework must be examined.
Potentially.
However, cargo insurance policies may exclude or limit consequential losses.
The buyer should examine the policy wording.
Business interruption or other insurance coverage may require separate analysis.
Insurance does not automatically eliminate contractual claims against the supplier.
Potentially.
However, the legal consequences depend on the insurance policy and applicable subrogation rules.
For example, an insurer that pays compensation may acquire rights against responsible parties.
The buyer cannot automatically recover the same loss twice.
The relevant legal relationships must be examined.
Potentially.
The competent court depends on the contract, jurisdiction agreement, and applicable procedural framework.
For example, a foreign buyer may bring a commercial claim before a competent Turkish commercial court where jurisdiction exists.
However, a valid arbitration agreement may require a different procedure.
The buyer should examine the dispute resolution clause.
Potentially.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and applicable jurisdiction rules.
For example, the parties may have agreed on foreign court jurisdiction.
However, the enforceability of the clause must be examined.
The buyer should also consider whether a foreign judgment can be enforced against the supplier’s assets.
Potentially.
Arbitration may be available where the parties have a valid arbitration agreement.
For example, the supply contract may provide for arbitration concerning defective goods and damages.
However, the buyer cannot automatically require arbitration without a legally sufficient basis.
The arbitration clause and procedural requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
Turkey is a party to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards.
Foreign arbitral awards may be recognized and enforced under the applicable framework.
However, the statutory requirements and possible refusal grounds must be examined.
The relevant enforcement procedure must be followed.
Potentially.
Law No. 5718 establishes important rules concerning recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
For example, a foreign buyer may obtain a judgment awarding lost profit damages.
The buyer may then seek enforcement against the supplier’s assets in Turkey.
Potentially.
Precautionary attachment may be available under the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
For example, the buyer may possess a qualifying monetary claim.
However, precautionary attachment is not automatically available in every lost profit dispute.
The court must examine the relevant conditions.
Security may also be required.
Potentially.
Articles 389 and following of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure establish important rules concerning interim judicial protection.
For example, the buyer may seek preservation of defective goods or relevant evidence.
However, the court must examine the asserted right, urgency, and proportionality.
The requested measure must address a specific legal risk.
Potentially.
Where the buyer possesses an enforceable monetary claim, Turkish enforcement procedures may be available.
However, the supplier may possess procedural defenses.
The appropriate mechanism depends on the relevant judgment, arbitral award, or other enforceable instrument.
The applicable deadlines and requirements must be examined.
Yes.
A foreign buyer may appoint a Turkish lawyer to assist with commercial litigation and related proceedings.
The applicable authorization and procedural requirements must be satisfied.
Where documents are executed abroad, authentication and translation requirements may arise.
The buyer’s physical absence from Turkey does not automatically prevent legal action.
Relevant evidence may include the supply agreement, purchase order, technical specifications, quality certificates, laboratory reports, inspection records, customer contracts, customer cancellation notices, sales forecasts, historical sales records, profit margin calculations, accounting records, tax returns, bank statements, inventory reports, production records, replacement purchase invoices, emails, and WhatsApp messages.
The buyer should establish the relevant product defect.
The date of discovery and notification should be documented.
The buyer should identify the specific sales or production opportunities lost because of the defect.
Financial calculations should distinguish gross revenue from net profit.
The buyer should also preserve evidence concerning mitigation measures.
As of November 2026, several legal frameworks may govern claims for lost profits arising from defective goods supplied by Turkish companies.
The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods may apply to qualifying international sales.
Article 6 permits exclusion or modification of the Convention under the applicable conditions.
Article 25 defines fundamental breach.
Article 35 establishes conformity requirements.
Article 36 concerns liability for nonconformity existing when risk passes.
Article 38 establishes inspection obligations.
Article 39 establishes notification requirements.
Article 40 limits the seller’s ability to rely on certain notice failures where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
Article 44 provides limited relief in specified notice situations.
Articles 45–52 establish important buyer remedies.
Article 46 addresses performance, replacement, and repair.
Article 48 addresses seller cure rights.
Article 49 governs avoidance by the buyer.
Article 50 establishes price reduction.
Article 73 establishes important rules concerning installment contracts.
Article 74 establishes the general damages framework, including loss of profit and foreseeability.
Article 75 addresses substitute transactions following valid avoidance.
Article 76 establishes important rules concerning current-price damages under specified conditions.
Article 77 establishes the duty to mitigate loss.
Article 78 addresses interest.
Articles 81–84 address consequences of avoidance and restitution.
Where Turkish domestic sales law applies, the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 establishes important rules concerning contractual liability and defective goods.
Article 112 establishes the general framework for liability arising from improper performance.
Articles 219–231 establish relevant defective goods provisions.
Article 227 establishes specified buyer remedies.
Article 231 establishes important limitation rules.
Articles 20–25 regulate general transaction terms.
Article 115 establishes important restrictions concerning advance exclusions of liability.
Articles 117–126 regulate debtor default and related remedies.
The Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 may establish additional obligations concerning commercial sales and merchant conduct.
Article 23 establishes important rules concerning specified commercial sales.
The Turkish Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 establishes important rules concerning documentary evidence, expert examination, interim judicial protection, and evidence preservation.
Articles 219 and following concern documentary evidence.
Articles 389 and following regulate interim injunctions.
Articles 400–405 regulate evidence preservation.
The Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 establishes relevant enforcement and precautionary attachment mechanisms.
Law No. 5718 establishes important rules concerning international jurisdiction, applicable law, and enforcement of foreign judgments.
The central legal distinction is whether the foreign buyer suffered a genuine, legally recoverable loss of profit caused by the supplier’s breach, rather than merely experiencing reduced revenue or disappointed commercial expectations.
A defective shipment does not automatically establish a lost profit claim.
However, where defective goods prevent profitable sales or production and the applicable requirements are satisfied, compensation may be available.
A foreign buyer seeking lost profits from a Turkish supplier should first identify the governing law.
The buyer should determine whether the CISG applies or whether the parties validly excluded it.
The next question is whether the goods were contractually nonconforming.
The buyer should preserve the supply agreement, technical specifications, inspection reports, and relevant communications.
The defect should be established through appropriate technical evidence.
The buyer should then identify the commercial consequences.
For example, the buyer may have lost confirmed customer orders or experienced production shutdowns.
Customer contracts, cancellation notices, production records, and financial statements may be important.
The buyer should calculate expected net profit rather than simply claiming the full value of lost sales.
Relevant avoided costs should be considered.
The buyer should also establish foreseeability under Article 74 of the CISG.
For example, the supplier may have known that the goods were intended for resale under existing customer contracts.
The buyer should preserve evidence of that knowledge.
The claimant must also establish causation.
For example, the supplier may argue that market conditions or unrelated business problems caused the losses.
The buyer should examine alternative explanations.
Mitigation measures should be documented.
Where replacement goods were available, the buyer should explain whether purchasing them was commercially reasonable.
Where the supplier refuses compensation, the dispute resolution clause becomes important.
Commercial litigation, arbitration, precautionary attachment, or enforcement proceedings may be available.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that lost profit disputes require careful distinction between product nonconformity, actual financial loss, foreseeability, causation, mitigation, damages calculations, and cross-border enforcement.
Lost profit claims may affect several legal interests simultaneously.
The contractual issue concerns whether the supplier breached the agreement.
The technical issue concerns whether the goods were defective.
The financial issue concerns expected net profit and actual loss.
The causation issue concerns whether the defect caused the claimed loss.
The foreseeability issue concerns the supplier’s knowledge at contract conclusion.
The mitigation issue concerns whether the buyer reasonably reduced its losses.
The evidentiary issue concerns customer contracts, accounting records, and expert reports.
The procedural issue concerns inspection deadlines, notification, and litigation.
The international issue concerns governing law, jurisdiction, arbitration, and enforcement.
These matters have different legal requirements.
A foreign buyer cannot automatically recover every projected profit merely because products supplied from Turkey were defective.
However, a Turkish supplier cannot assume that liability is limited to the purchase price where the applicable law permits recovery of qualifying consequential losses.
A coordinated legal assessment may therefore be necessary to protect the buyer’s commercial and financial interests.
1. Can a foreign buyer recover lost profits from a Turkish supplier for defective goods?
Potentially. The buyer must establish the relevant breach, financial loss, causal connection, and applicable legal requirements.
2. Does Article 74 of the CISG permit lost profit claims?
Yes. Article 74 expressly recognizes loss of profit, subject to the foreseeability limitation and other applicable requirements.
3. Must the buyer prove confirmed customer orders?
Not necessarily in every case. However, confirmed orders may provide strong evidence of expected profits.
4. Can historical sales records support a lost profit claim?
Potentially. Historical sales and profit margins may help establish a reasonable calculation.
5. Can a buyer recover lost profits from defective machinery?
Potentially. The buyer must establish the technical defect, production impact, and resulting financial loss.
6. Can the supplier challenge speculative profit calculations?
Yes. The supplier may dispute projected sales, causation, foreseeability, or the amount claimed.
7. Must the buyer mitigate lost profits?
Yes. Article 77 of the CISG requires reasonable measures to mitigate loss, including loss of profit.
8. Can the buyer recover both lost profits and replacement purchase costs?
Potentially. However, the remedies must be legally compatible and must not produce duplicative recovery.
9. Can a foreign buyer sue the Turkish supplier in Turkey?
Potentially. The competent forum depends on the contract, jurisdiction rules, and any valid arbitration agreement.
10. Can a foreign buyer pursue the dispute without traveling to Turkey?
Yes. A foreign buyer may appoint a Turkish lawyer to assist with commercial proceedings, subject to applicable authorization and procedural requirements.
Protecting international supply contracts, commercial investments and compensation rights requires timely and specialized legal assistance.
Foreign companies that suffer lost profits because of defective goods supplied from Turkey may face serious risks involving cancelled customer orders, production shutdowns, failed product launches, rejected shipments, lost distribution contracts, replacement purchases, and substantial financial damage.
Working with a lawyer experienced in Turkish commercial law, international sales contracts, the CISG, defective goods litigation, lost profit compensation, financial evidence, arbitration, and foreign buyer protection can help clarify the applicable legal framework and identify appropriate remedies.
Serving clients throughout Turkey and internationally, Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office provides professional legal support in lost profit compensation claims, defective product disputes, international supply contract enforcement, contract termination, advance payment recovery, damages litigation, evidence preservation, precautionary attachment, arbitration, and enforcement proceedings against Turkish suppliers.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya assists foreign buyers, international distributors, importers, manufacturers, wholesalers, retailers, and overseas businesses seeking compensation for commercial losses caused by defective goods supplied from Turkey.
Call Now: +90 312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: +90 532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Website: https://www.firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only. To avoid any loss of legal rights, we recommend consulting your lawyer regarding the specific circumstances of your case.