

Turkish supplier refuses to replace defective products under a commercial warranty? Learn about warranty enforcement, CISG remedies, replacement rights, repair, refunds, damages, inspection deadlines and legal proceedings in Turkey.
A foreign company that purchases products from a Turkish supplier under a commercial warranty may face substantial financial losses when the delivered goods develop defects and the manufacturer refuses to provide the promised replacements.
Commercial warranties are particularly important in international transactions involving machinery, automotive components, electronics, industrial equipment, furniture, construction materials, medical devices, and other manufactured products.
Foreign buyers frequently negotiate contractual warranties covering product quality, performance, durability, materials, manufacturing defects, and compliance with technical specifications.
These warranties may require the Turkish supplier to repair defective products, provide replacement goods, supply spare parts, or compensate the buyer for specified losses.
However, disputes may arise when the supplier refuses to honor the agreed warranty.
For example, a foreign distributor may purchase 2,000 electronic devices from a Turkish manufacturer under a two-year commercial warranty. Several months after delivery, a substantial number of devices may fail during ordinary use.
The distributor may request replacement products, but the manufacturer may refuse, arguing that the defects resulted from improper storage or customer misuse.
In another case, an international machinery buyer may purchase industrial equipment with a contractual warranty covering manufacturing defects. The machinery may repeatedly malfunction, but the Turkish supplier may insist that the buyer pay additional repair charges.
More serious situations may involve suppliers that stop responding to warranty claims, refuse to provide spare parts, deny responsibility for defective components, or demand that the foreign buyer return expensive machinery at its own cost.
The foreign company may face customer complaints, product recalls, replacement purchases, storage expenses, and substantial lost profits.
The supplier may argue that the warranty period has expired, that the buyer failed to notify defects promptly, or that the warranty excludes the particular problem.
These circumstances raise important legal questions.
Can a Turkish supplier refuse to replace defective products covered by a commercial warranty? Does the foreign buyer have a right to replacement rather than repair? Can the supplier impose additional charges? Can the buyer recover the purchase price? Can the buyer claim compensation for customer refunds, recall expenses, and lost profits? Does the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods apply?
Under Turkish law and applicable international sales rules, a supplier that refuses to comply with a valid and enforceable commercial warranty may face contractual remedies, including performance, repair, replacement, damages, or other relief where the relevant requirements are satisfied.
However, a commercial warranty does not automatically give the buyer an unrestricted right to demand replacement in every situation.
The available remedies depend on the warranty wording, governing law, nature of the defect, timing of notification, seriousness of nonconformity, and applicable statutory rules.
For qualifying international sales, the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) may apply.
Article 35 establishes conformity requirements.
Articles 38 and 39 establish inspection and notification obligations.
Article 46 regulates performance, replacement, and repair.
Article 48 addresses the seller’s right to cure.
Articles 74–77 regulate damages and mitigation.
Where Turkish domestic sales law applies, Articles 219–231 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 establish important rules concerning defective goods.
Article 227 establishes specified buyer remedies.
Article 23 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 may establish additional notification requirements for certain commercial sales between merchants.
This guide explains how foreign buyers can enforce commercial warranties, establish product defects, demand replacement goods, recover payments, and pursue legal remedies against Turkish suppliers under the 2026 legal framework.
A commercial warranty is a contractual undertaking concerning specified product characteristics, performance, durability, repair, replacement, or other obligations.
For example, a Turkish manufacturer may guarantee that machinery will operate without manufacturing defects for a defined period.
The warranty may establish rights beyond the applicable statutory remedies.
However, the scope depends on the agreement.
A commercial warranty should not automatically be confused with consumer warranty protections.
No.
The warranty may provide different remedies.
For example, it may require repair before replacement.
Alternatively, it may expressly entitle the buyer to replacement when specified defects occur.
The legal consequences depend on the warranty wording and governing law.
The buyer must identify the relevant contractual obligation.
Potentially, where a valid contractual or statutory defense exists.
For example, the supplier may establish that the defect falls outside the warranty.
However, an unjustified refusal to perform an enforceable replacement obligation may constitute breach of contract.
The buyer must establish the warranty and relevant defect.
The supplier’s defenses must be examined.
Generally, where it forms part of a valid and enforceable agreement.
For example, a supply contract may require replacement of products that fail specified quality standards during the warranty period.
The supplier may be obligated to comply.
However, the legal consequences depend on the contract and applicable law.
The buyer must establish the warranty terms.
Yes.
A supply agreement may contain express warranty provisions.
For example, the manufacturer may guarantee that products will remain free from specified manufacturing defects for 24 months.
The warranty may establish repair or replacement obligations.
However, the precise scope must be examined.
Potentially.
A purchase order may contain warranty requirements.
For example, the buyer may require a 12-month replacement warranty.
However, the legal effect depends on whether the terms became part of the agreement.
The buyer should preserve the accepted purchase order.
Potentially.
A proforma invoice may identify warranty terms.
However, the document does not automatically establish the complete agreement.
The buyer should examine purchase orders, contracts, and correspondence.
The relevant contractual relationship must be established.
Yes, potentially.
Emails may contain express warranty assurances.
For example, the supplier may promise free replacement of defective products for two years.
However, the legal effect depends on the applicable law and contractual circumstances.
The buyer should preserve the complete communication history.
Potentially.
Messages may contain discussions concerning warranty duration, replacement, or repair.
However, authenticity and context must be examined.
A screenshot alone may not conclusively establish every contractual term.
The buyer should preserve communications lawfully.
Potentially.
A warranty certificate may identify the supplier’s obligations.
However, the document’s legal effect depends on its wording and applicable law.
For example, it may cover manufacturing defects but exclude certain forms of damage.
The buyer should examine the certificate and underlying agreement.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that warranty statements were general marketing representations.
However, the buyer may possess evidence showing that the warranty formed part of the contractual agreement.
The court or arbitral tribunal must interpret the relevant communications.
The legal consequences depend on the circumstances.
Potentially.
The supplier may rely on an entire agreement clause or other contractual provisions.
However, the buyer may argue that the warranty was incorporated through purchase orders or subsequent communications.
The applicable interpretation rules must be examined.
The complete contractual documentation is important.
Not automatically.
Where warranty terms are contractually binding, unilateral changes may constitute breach.
For example, the supplier may attempt to reduce a two-year warranty to six months after receiving payment.
The legal consequences depend on the agreement and applicable law.
The buyer must establish the original warranty.
Not automatically.
The supplier may possess contractual termination rights under specified circumstances.
However, a manufacturer cannot automatically eliminate an existing warranty merely because the buyer has received the goods.
The relevant contractual and statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
However, the supplier must establish a legally sufficient basis.
For example, the manufacturer may attempt to suspend warranty service because of an unrelated payment dispute.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and applicable law.
The supplier cannot automatically withhold every warranty remedy without justification.
Potentially, where the warranty permits specified charges.
However, a warranty promising free replacement may prohibit additional charges for covered defects.
The buyer should examine the contractual terms.
The supplier must establish any claimed right to additional payment.
Potentially.
The agreement may allocate transportation expenses.
For example, the buyer may be responsible for returning defective goods.
Alternatively, the supplier may agree to cover all replacement shipping costs.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and governing law.
Potentially.
Warranty replacement shipments may involve customs procedures and charges.
However, the allocation of costs depends on the agreement and applicable customs law.
The buyer should examine whether the replacement goods qualify for any relevant customs treatment.
A contractual warranty does not automatically eliminate customs obligations.
Potentially.
The warranty may require return of defective products.
For example, the manufacturer may need to inspect the goods before providing replacements.
However, the supplier must comply with the agreement.
The buyer may dispute unreasonable or impractical return requirements.
Potentially.
The supplier may require verification of the alleged defect.
However, the inspection requirement must be consistent with the contract and applicable law.
For example, the buyer may provide laboratory reports or photographs.
The supplier cannot automatically impose arbitrary conditions that defeat an enforceable warranty.
Potentially.
The warranty may require specified evidence.
However, the legal consequences depend on the agreement.
For example, photographs may be insufficient to establish an internal technical defect.
The buyer may need laboratory testing.
The supplier’s evidentiary requirements must be reasonable and legally justified.
Potentially.
Serial numbers may help identify covered products.
However, the legal consequences depend on the warranty and circumstances.
For example, the supplier may require proof that the goods were purchased under the relevant agreement.
The buyer should preserve invoices and product identifiers.
Potentially.
The supplier may possess a valid defense where the claim falls outside the agreed period.
However, the buyer may dispute when the warranty began or whether notice was timely.
The applicable statutory remedies may also require separate examination.
The contract and governing law must be considered.
The answer depends on the agreement.
For example, the warranty may begin on shipment, delivery, installation, commissioning, or customer acceptance.
The supplier may argue that the period began earlier than the buyer claims.
The relevant contractual wording must be examined.
Yes.
The parties may agree that the warranty begins after installation or commissioning.
For example, industrial machinery may require successful site acceptance testing.
However, the agreement must establish the relevant trigger.
The buyer should preserve installation and acceptance records.
Potentially.
The parties may agree that warranty coverage begins when the buyer resells the products.
However, such arrangements must be clearly established.
The supplier may impose reporting or maximum duration requirements.
The relevant contractual terms must be examined.
Potentially.
Improper storage may cause damage outside the supplier’s responsibility.
However, the supplier must establish the relevant contractual defense and causal connection.
For example, electronic products may be damaged by excessive moisture.
The buyer may dispute the allegation.
Technical evidence may be necessary.
Potentially.
The warranty may exclude damage caused by misuse.
However, the supplier must establish the relevant circumstances.
For example, machinery may fail because it was operated outside agreed conditions.
The buyer may argue that the failure resulted from a manufacturing defect.
Expert examination may be necessary.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that installation errors caused the defect.
However, the buyer may establish that the product was already nonconforming.
The contract and technical evidence must be examined.
The allocation of installation responsibility may be important.
Potentially.
The warranty may restrict repairs by unauthorized persons.
However, the legal consequences depend on the clause and applicable law.
The supplier must establish the relevant defense.
The buyer may argue that emergency repairs were necessary.
The circumstances must be examined.
Potentially.
Commercial warranties may exclude ordinary wear.
However, premature failure may indicate a manufacturing defect.
The buyer should examine the expected service life and technical specifications.
Expert testing may be necessary.
Potentially.
The warranty may distinguish cosmetic defects from functional defects.
However, the contract may expressly cover appearance or finish.
For example, a furniture warranty may cover specified surface defects.
The relevant warranty terms must be examined.
Potentially.
The available remedy depends on the warranty and applicable law.
For example, the warranty may permit repair for minor defects.
However, a minor defect does not automatically eliminate every buyer remedy.
The contract and statutory framework must be examined.
Potentially.
However, functionality alone does not necessarily establish contractual conformity.
For example, machinery may operate below the guaranteed performance level.
The buyer may possess warranty rights.
The relevant technical requirements must be examined.
Not automatically.
A manufacturing warranty may cover defects existing at delivery.
However, the legal consequences depend on the warranty and governing law.
The supplier may argue that the buyer failed to inspect or notify promptly.
The applicable requirements must be examined.
Not automatically.
A commercial warranty may cover defects arising during the warranty period.
For example, a component may fail after several months of ordinary use.
However, the buyer must establish that the failure falls within the warranty.
The relevant technical evidence is important.
Potentially.
The warranty may be limited to the original buyer or may extend to downstream customers.
However, resale does not automatically eliminate every contractual right.
The buyer should examine the warranty’s transferability.
The relevant contractual terms must be established.
Not automatically.
A company name change does not necessarily alter legal personality.
However, the supplier may require proof of the relevant entity.
The buyer should preserve corporate records.
The legal consequences depend on the circumstances.
Potentially.
The warranty may contain assignment restrictions.
However, the legal consequences depend on the transaction and applicable law.
For example, a business transfer may involve assignment of contractual rights.
The relevant statutory and contractual requirements must be examined.
Not automatically.
A change in the supplier company’s shareholders does not necessarily eliminate its contractual obligations.
However, a merger, asset transfer, or other restructuring may create additional legal questions.
The buyer should identify the contracting legal entity.
The applicable corporate and contractual framework must be examined.
Financial difficulties do not automatically eliminate warranty obligations.
However, insolvency may affect practical recovery.
For example, the supplier may be unable to manufacture replacements.
The buyer may possess monetary claims.
The relevant insolvency and enforcement framework must be examined.
Potentially.
However, the supplier may remain responsible under the warranty.
For example, the agreement may require replacement where repair is impossible.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and applicable law.
The supplier cannot automatically avoid liability merely because spare parts are difficult to obtain.
Potentially.
However, discontinuation does not automatically eliminate existing warranty obligations.
The agreement may require equivalent replacement products.
Alternatively, monetary remedies may become relevant.
The buyer should examine the contractual framework.
Potentially.
The answer depends on the warranty and applicable law.
For example, the warranty may expressly provide replacement rights.
Under the CISG, Article 46(2) permits replacement where the lack of conformity constitutes a fundamental breach and the relevant requirements are satisfied.
However, the parties may have agreed on additional contractual replacement obligations.
Article 46 establishes important buyer remedies concerning performance.
Article 46(1) addresses performance of the seller’s obligations.
Article 46(2) permits replacement where the lack of conformity constitutes a fundamental breach and the relevant requirements are satisfied.
Article 46(3) addresses repair unless unreasonable in the circumstances.
The buyer must examine the applicable conditions.
Potentially.
Article 6 of the CISG permits parties to modify specified Convention provisions under the applicable framework.
For example, the supplier may expressly promise replacement for any covered manufacturing defect.
The contractual warranty may therefore establish obligations beyond the default Article 46(2) threshold.
However, the agreement must be interpreted carefully.
Potentially.
The warranty may expressly permit replacement for specified minor defects.
However, the default CISG replacement remedy under Article 46(2) generally requires fundamental breach.
The buyer should distinguish contractual warranty rights from statutory remedies.
The relevant terms must be examined.
Potentially.
Repeated failures may support a claim that repair is ineffective.
For example, machinery may malfunction despite several repair attempts.
The buyer may possess contractual or statutory remedies.
However, the relevant requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
The warranty may require replacement where repair attempts fail.
For example, the supplier may be unable to correct a recurring manufacturing defect.
The buyer may possess additional remedies.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and governing law.
Potentially.
However, the buyer must establish the scope of the defect and relevant warranty rights.
For example, a manufacturing defect may affect an entire production batch.
Alternatively, only a small number of products may be defective.
The applicable remedies depend on the circumstances.
Potentially.
The warranty may permit replacement of individual products.
For example, a distributor may identify 150 defective units in a shipment of 2,000.
The buyer may request replacement of those units.
However, the contractual and statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
The warranty may cover specific components.
For example, a machinery warranty may require replacement of defective motors or control units.
However, the buyer must establish the covered defect.
The relevant contractual terms must be examined.
Potentially.
The warranty may require new replacement products.
However, the supplier may argue that refurbished or equivalent products are permitted.
The contract must be interpreted.
The buyer should identify the agreed replacement standard.
Potentially.
The warranty may require identical products.
However, the original model may no longer be available.
The agreement may permit equivalent alternatives.
The legal consequences depend on the contractual terms.
Potentially.
Replacement goods must satisfy the applicable contractual requirements.
For example, the supplier may offer lower-grade products instead of the agreed model.
The buyer may possess remedies concerning nonconformity.
The relevant specifications must be examined.
Potentially.
The warranty may establish a replacement period.
For example, the supplier may be required to dispatch replacement goods within 30 days after receiving a valid claim.
Failure to comply may constitute additional nonperformance.
The relevant contractual requirements must be established.
Potentially.
The agreement may require urgent replacement under specified circumstances.
However, the supplier is not automatically obligated to use the fastest possible shipping method.
The buyer should examine the warranty and applicable law.
Additional damages may arise where delay causes recoverable loss.
Potentially.
The contract may establish an advance replacement procedure.
For example, the supplier may be required to ship replacement components before receiving defective units.
However, the legal consequences depend on the agreement.
The buyer should examine the relevant warranty process.
Potentially.
The warranty may require technicians to replace defective components at the buyer’s facility.
For example, industrial machinery may be too expensive to return.
However, the supplier’s obligations depend on the contract.
The relevant service and travel expenses must be examined.
Potentially.
However, customs obligations are governed by applicable customs law.
The supplier may contractually agree to bear specified charges.
The buyer should examine the warranty and destination-country procedures.
A replacement warranty does not automatically exempt goods from customs requirements.
Potentially.
Article 46(3) of the CISG permits repair unless unreasonable in the circumstances.
However, the warranty may establish a particular remedy.
For example, the supplier may be required to repair defective machinery.
The buyer must examine the contractual and statutory requirements.
Potentially.
The supplier may possess contractual or statutory cure rights.
For example, Article 48 of the CISG establishes important seller cure rights under specified circumstances.
However, the supplier cannot automatically impose an ineffective or unreasonable repair.
The buyer’s rights must be examined.
Article 48 establishes important rules concerning the seller’s ability to remedy nonperformance after the delivery date.
However, cure must satisfy the relevant statutory conditions.
For example, repair may be appropriate where it can be completed without unreasonable delay or inconvenience.
The buyer may retain qualifying damages claims.
Potentially.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and circumstances.
For example, repeated unsuccessful repairs may create unreasonable inconvenience.
The buyer may possess rights to seek replacement or other remedies.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Article 50 of the CISG establishes an important price reduction remedy concerning nonconforming goods.
However, the statutory conditions and seller’s cure rights must be examined.
For example, the buyer may retain defective products at a reduced price.
The appropriate reduction depends on the value of the goods.
Potentially.
Article 49 of the CISG permits avoidance where the seller’s breach is fundamental and the relevant requirements are satisfied.
For example, the supplier may refuse to replace essential machinery that cannot perform its agreed function.
However, cancellation is not automatically available for every warranty dispute.
The buyer must establish the relevant legal basis.
Potentially.
Article 25 of the CISG defines fundamental breach.
For example, refusal to remedy serious defects may substantially deprive the buyer of the expected contractual benefit.
However, the legal assessment depends on the agreement and circumstances.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the evidence.
Potentially.
Where the contract is validly avoided, Articles 81–84 of the CISG establish important restitution rules.
For example, the buyer may have paid for machinery that remains unusable despite warranty requests.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
The buyer should preserve payment and warranty records.
Potentially.
The buyer may possess restitution rights where the relevant legal conditions are satisfied.
For example, the supplier may have received an advance payment for goods that fail essential quality requirements.
However, the appropriate remedy depends on the contract and governing law.
The buyer must establish the relevant basis.
Potentially.
The buyer may possess contractual defenses or suspension rights under the applicable framework.
However, withholding payment without a legally sufficient basis may create additional liability.
For example, the buyer may dispute payment for defective goods.
The relevant obligations must be examined.
Potentially.
Set-off may be available under the applicable legal framework.
For example, Articles 139 and following of the Turkish Code of Obligations establish important rules concerning set-off.
However, the statutory conditions must be satisfied.
The supplier may dispute the amount or existence of the claim.
Yes, where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
Article 45 of the CISG establishes important buyer remedies for seller nonperformance.
Articles 74–77 regulate damages.
For example, warranty refusal may cause replacement purchases, repair expenses, or lost customer orders.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant loss and causal connection.
Article 74 establishes the general damages framework for breach of contract.
Damages may include loss suffered and loss of profit, subject to the foreseeability limitation.
For example, defective machinery may prevent the buyer from completing production.
However, the claimant must establish the relevant financial loss.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the evidence.
Potentially.
The buyer may hire another company to repair defective products.
However, the supplier’s cure rights and contractual procedures must be examined.
The buyer must establish that the expenses were reasonable and caused by the breach.
The relevant invoices should be preserved.
Potentially.
Article 75 of the CISG establishes important rules concerning substitute transactions following valid avoidance.
For example, the buyer may purchase replacement goods from another supplier at a higher price.
However, the statutory conditions must be satisfied.
The replacement purchase should be commercially reasonable.
Potentially.
A foreign distributor may refund customers who received defective products.
However, recovery from the Turkish supplier depends on the governing law and circumstances.
The buyer must establish the relevant payments and causal connection.
Not every voluntary refund is automatically recoverable.
Potentially.
Defective products may require withdrawal from the market.
However, the applicable legal requirements depend on the product and destination country.
The buyer must establish the recall costs and causal connection.
The supplier’s contractual obligations must also be examined.
Potentially.
Defective goods may remain in storage while the warranty dispute is unresolved.
However, the buyer must establish that the expenses were reasonable and caused by the breach.
The relevant invoices and records should be preserved.
Potentially.
The warranty may allocate return shipping expenses.
For example, the supplier may agree to pay transportation costs for defective products.
Where the agreement is silent, the applicable legal framework must be examined.
The buyer must establish the relevant expense.
Potentially.
Warranty returns and replacement shipments may involve customs procedures.
However, the allocation of responsibility depends on the contract and applicable customs law.
The buyer should preserve customs documents and invoices.
Not every customs charge is automatically recoverable.
Potentially.
Article 74 permits recovery of qualifying lost profits.
For example, defective machinery may prevent the buyer from fulfilling confirmed customer orders.
However, speculative future revenue does not automatically establish recoverable loss.
The buyer must establish the relevant causal connection and foreseeability.
Potentially.
The buyer may face penalties from downstream customers because of defective products.
However, recovery from the Turkish supplier depends on the governing law and circumstances.
The buyer must establish the relevant contractual obligations and financial loss.
Not every penalty paid to a third party is automatically recoverable.
Potentially, but the legal requirements may be difficult to establish.
For example, repeated product failures may damage the buyer’s commercial reputation.
However, the claimant must identify legally recoverable damage.
General allegations of reputational harm do not automatically establish compensation.
Yes.
Article 77 of the CISG establishes a duty to take reasonable measures to mitigate loss.
For example, the buyer may need to arrange appropriate repairs or replacement purchases.
However, the buyer is not automatically required to accept unreasonable costs or risks.
Failure to mitigate may reduce recoverable damages.
Potentially.
Article 38 of the CISG establishes inspection obligations.
However, the required inspection depends on the circumstances.
For example, certain manufacturing defects may become apparent only after extended use.
The court must examine what inspection was practicable.
Article 38 requires the buyer to examine the goods, or cause them to be examined, within as short a period as practicable in the circumstances.
However, the timing depends on the delivery arrangement and nature of the goods.
For example, complex machinery may require specialized testing.
The buyer should not assume that inspection can be delayed indefinitely.
Article 39 requires the buyer to notify the seller of the lack of conformity within a reasonable time after discovering it or when it ought to have discovered it.
The notice must specify the nature of the nonconformity.
Article 39(2) generally establishes an outer period of two years from actual handover, unless inconsistent with a contractual guarantee period.
However, Articles 40 and 44 may affect the consequences of certain notice failures.
Potentially.
Article 39(2) expressly recognizes the relevance of a contractual guarantee period where inconsistent with the two-year outer period.
However, the warranty’s effect depends on its wording and applicable law.
The buyer should distinguish warranty duration from the obligation to notify defects within a reasonable time.
The relevant statutory requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
Failure to comply with applicable notification requirements may affect the buyer’s remedies.
However, the legal consequences depend on the governing law and warranty terms.
For example, Article 40 of the CISG may become relevant where the supplier knew or could not have been unaware of the relevant facts and failed to disclose them.
The buyer should preserve evidence concerning discovery and notification.
Article 40 limits the seller’s ability to rely on Articles 38 and 39 where the lack of conformity relates to facts the seller knew or could not have been unaware of and failed to disclose to the buyer.
For example, deliberate concealment of known manufacturing defects may raise questions under Article 40.
However, the statutory conditions must be established.
The buyer must prove the relevant facts.
Potentially.
However, resale does not automatically eliminate every warranty or statutory remedy.
The legal consequences depend on the agreement and governing law.
For example, a distributor may possess contractual rights concerning defects discovered by downstream customers.
The relevant warranty terms must be examined.
Not automatically.
Acceptance of delivery does not necessarily eliminate every claim concerning hidden defects.
However, the buyer must comply with applicable inspection and notification requirements.
For example, defects may become apparent only during operation.
The relevant circumstances must be examined.
Not automatically.
Payment does not necessarily establish that the goods satisfy every warranty requirement.
For example, the buyer may pay before discovering manufacturing defects.
The applicable legal framework must be examined.
The supplier may possess other defenses.
Potentially.
An acceptance certificate may provide evidence concerning product approval.
However, its legal effect depends on the wording and circumstances.
For example, the certificate may confirm only preliminary testing.
The buyer may still possess claims concerning hidden defects.
Potentially.
The supplier may argue that the goods were damaged during transport.
However, the buyer may establish that the defect originated during manufacturing.
The relevant technical and transport evidence must be examined.
Article 36 of the CISG may become relevant.
Article 36 generally makes the seller responsible for nonconformity existing when risk passes, even if discovered later.
The provision also addresses certain nonconformities arising after risk passes where they result from a breach of the seller’s obligations, including specified guarantees.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
The buyer must establish the relevant facts.
Potentially.
However, risk transfer does not automatically eliminate liability for manufacturing defects existing when risk passed.
For example, a product may contain a defective component before shipment.
The buyer may discover the defect later.
The relevant contract and Article 36 must be examined.
Yes.
Incoterms may allocate delivery obligations, costs, and risk of loss.
However, they do not automatically replace contractual warranty obligations.
For example, risk may pass at a specified point.
Nevertheless, the supplier may remain responsible for covered manufacturing defects.
The contract and governing law must be examined.
Yes.
Independent testing may help establish whether products contain manufacturing defects.
For example, a laboratory may examine electrical failures, material composition, or mechanical performance.
However, the evidentiary value depends on the methodology and circumstances.
The buyer should preserve representative samples.
Yes.
The supplier may dispute the testing method, sample selection, or findings.
For example, the supplier may argue that the products were tested outside their intended operating conditions.
The court or arbitral tribunal may require expert examination.
The buyer should preserve the complete testing documentation.
Yes, where expert examination is appropriate.
For example, a court may appoint an engineer to determine the cause of product failure.
However, the expert’s role is to provide specialized technical analysis.
The court determines the legal consequences.
The relevant procedural requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Articles 400–405 of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 establish mechanisms concerning preservation of evidence.
For example, the buyer may seek examination of defective goods where there is a legally sufficient risk of evidence loss.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Evidence preservation is not an unrestricted discovery procedure.
Potentially.
Articles 219 and following of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure establish important rules concerning documentary evidence.
A court may order production of relevant documents under the applicable conditions.
For example, manufacturing test records may help establish whether the supplier knew of defects.
The applicant must identify the documents and legal relevance.
Potentially.
Warranty records may help establish the supplier’s prior handling of similar defects.
However, the buyer does not automatically possess unrestricted access to every internal record.
The court must examine relevance and confidentiality.
The applicable procedural requirements must be satisfied.
Potentially.
Photographs may show visible damage or defects.
However, they may not establish the underlying cause.
The buyer should preserve original images where possible.
Technical testing may be necessary.
Potentially.
Videos may document equipment failure or abnormal operation.
However, authenticity and context must be examined.
The supplier may dispute the operating conditions.
The buyer should preserve original recordings and technical data.
Yes, potentially.
Emails may establish warranty terms or replacement promises.
For example, the supplier may confirm that defective units will be replaced without charge.
The buyer should preserve the complete correspondence.
The court or arbitral tribunal must examine the context.
Potentially.
Messages may contain discussions concerning defects, replacement requests, or supplier refusals.
However, authenticity and context must be examined.
A screenshot alone may not conclusively establish every relevant fact.
The buyer should preserve communications lawfully.
Potentially.
For example, the supplier may acknowledge that a particular production batch contains defective components.
Such a statement may provide important evidence.
However, the legal consequences depend on the context and applicable law.
The buyer should preserve the complete communication.
Potentially.
A pattern of similar failures may support an allegation of a common manufacturing problem.
However, the buyer must establish the relevant technical connection.
For example, products from the same batch may fail in similar ways.
Expert examination may be necessary.
Potentially.
The contracting supplier may remain responsible for product conformity.
Article 116 of the Turkish Code of Obligations establishes important rules concerning responsibility for auxiliary persons.
However, the applicable conditions must be satisfied.
The supplier cannot automatically avoid liability merely by outsourcing production.
Potentially.
The supplier may remain responsible for delivering conforming goods.
For example, defective components may originate from a raw material supplier.
The manufacturer may possess separate claims against that supplier.
However, the foreign buyer’s contractual rights depend on its agreement and governing law.
Potentially, where the conduct satisfies the elements of a recognized criminal offense.
For example, deliberate deception concerning product quality may raise fraud questions.
Articles 157 and 158 of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 establish relevant provisions.
However, ordinary warranty nonperformance does not automatically constitute criminal fraud.
The prosecution must establish the statutory elements.
Potentially.
A supplier may allegedly provide fabricated warranty or technical documents.
The legal consequences depend on the nature of the document and conduct.
Articles 204 and 207 of the Turkish Penal Code regulate official and private document forgery.
However, an inaccurate document does not automatically establish criminal forgery.
Not automatically.
A criminal complaint concerns suspected criminal conduct.
Recovery of the purchase price may require separate commercial proceedings.
A criminal investigation does not automatically reverse payments.
The buyer should examine the appropriate contractual remedies.
Potentially.
The CISG may apply where the parties have their places of business in different Contracting States and the relevant conditions are satisfied.
It may also apply through applicable private international law rules in specified circumstances.
However, the parties may exclude the CISG under Article 6.
The buyer should examine the contract and governing law.
Yes.
Article 6 permits parties to exclude the CISG or derogate from specified provisions under the Convention’s framework.
However, the exclusion must be established through the contract and applicable interpretation rules.
A general choice of Turkish law does not necessarily exclude the CISG.
No.
The CISG forms part of the applicable legal framework in qualifying international sales.
A contractual choice of Turkish law does not automatically mean that domestic sales law replaces the CISG.
The parties may expressly exclude the Convention.
The relevant contractual wording must be examined.
Yes, where the CISG does not apply or has been validly excluded.
Articles 219–231 of the Turkish Code of Obligations establish important rules concerning defective goods.
Article 227 establishes specified buyer remedies.
Article 23 of the Turkish Commercial Code may establish additional requirements for commercial sales between merchants.
The buyer should identify the applicable framework.
Article 219 establishes important rules concerning the seller’s liability for defects.
The provision addresses defects that reduce or eliminate the value or expected usefulness of goods and the absence of promised qualities.
For example, products that fail guaranteed performance requirements may raise defect liability questions.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Article 227 establishes important buyer remedies concerning defective goods under Turkish domestic sales law.
Depending on the statutory conditions, the buyer may seek rescission, price reduction, repair, or replacement.
The buyer may also possess compensation rights under the applicable framework.
However, the availability of each remedy depends on the circumstances.
Potentially.
Article 227 recognizes replacement as a remedy where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
However, the nature of the goods and availability of conforming replacements may be important.
For example, replacement may be appropriate where the supplier can provide defect-free products.
The court must examine the circumstances.
Potentially.
Article 227 recognizes repair under the applicable conditions.
However, repair must be possible and appropriate.
For example, a defective machinery component may be replaced.
The relevant circumstances must be examined.
Potentially.
Article 227 recognizes price reduction as a remedy.
However, the amount must be determined under the applicable framework.
The buyer should preserve evidence concerning the value of conforming and defective goods.
Expert examination may be necessary.
Potentially.
Article 227 permits rescission under the applicable conditions.
However, the court may consider whether rescission is appropriate.
For example, a minor defect may not justify termination of the entire transaction.
The buyer must establish the relevant legal requirements.
The applicable limitation period depends on the legal basis and warranty terms.
Article 231 of the Turkish Code of Obligations establishes important limitation rules concerning defective goods under domestic sales law.
However, contractual guarantees, statutory exceptions, and deliberate concealment may affect the analysis.
The buyer should identify the applicable deadline promptly.
Potentially.
The competent court depends on the contract, jurisdiction agreement, and applicable procedural framework.
For example, a foreign buyer may bring a commercial claim before a competent Turkish commercial court where jurisdiction exists.
However, a valid arbitration agreement may require a different procedure.
The buyer should examine the dispute resolution clause.
Potentially.
The legal consequences depend on the contract and applicable jurisdiction rules.
For example, the parties may have agreed on foreign court jurisdiction.
However, the enforceability of the clause must be examined.
The buyer should also consider whether a foreign judgment can be enforced against the supplier’s assets.
Potentially.
Arbitration may be available where the parties have a valid arbitration agreement.
For example, the supply contract may provide for arbitration concerning warranty disputes.
However, the buyer cannot automatically require arbitration without a legally sufficient basis.
The arbitration clause and procedural requirements must be examined.
Potentially.
Turkey is a party to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards.
Foreign arbitral awards may be recognized and enforced under the applicable framework.
However, the statutory requirements and possible refusal grounds must be examined.
The relevant enforcement procedure must be followed.
Potentially.
Law No. 5718 establishes important rules concerning recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments.
However, the statutory requirements must be satisfied.
For example, a foreign buyer may obtain a judgment requiring replacement-related compensation or repayment.
The buyer may then seek enforcement against the supplier’s assets in Turkey.
Potentially.
Precautionary attachment may be available under the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
For example, the buyer may possess a qualifying monetary claim concerning defective products.
However, precautionary attachment is not automatically available in every warranty dispute.
The court must examine the relevant conditions.
Security may also be required.
Potentially.
Articles 389 and following of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure establish important rules concerning interim judicial protection.
For example, the buyer may seek preservation of defective goods or technical evidence.
However, the court must examine the asserted right, urgency, and proportionality.
The requested measure must address a specific legal risk.
Potentially.
Where the buyer possesses an enforceable monetary claim, Turkish enforcement procedures may be available.
However, the supplier may possess procedural defenses.
The appropriate mechanism depends on the relevant judgment, arbitral award, or other enforceable instrument.
The applicable deadlines and requirements must be examined.
Yes.
A foreign buyer may appoint a Turkish lawyer to assist with commercial litigation and related proceedings.
The applicable authorization and procedural requirements must be satisfied.
Where documents are executed abroad, authentication and translation requirements may arise.
The buyer’s physical absence from Turkey does not automatically prevent legal action.
Relevant evidence may include the supply agreement, commercial warranty, warranty certificate, purchase order, proforma invoice, technical specifications, quality certificates, laboratory reports, serial numbers, production batch records, inspection reports, customer complaints, repair records, replacement requests, shipping documents, payment records, emails, and WhatsApp messages.
The buyer should identify the exact warranty obligation.
The date of delivery, discovery of defects, notification, and supplier refusal should be documented.
Where repeated failures are alleged, technical evidence concerning the relevant production batch may be important.
The buyer should also preserve records concerning financial losses.
As of November 2026, several legal frameworks may govern disputes involving Turkish suppliers that refuse to replace defective products under commercial warranties.
The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods may apply to qualifying international sales.
Article 6 permits exclusion or modification of the Convention under the applicable conditions.
Article 25 defines fundamental breach.
Article 35 establishes conformity requirements.
Article 36 concerns liability for nonconformity existing when risk passes and specified guarantee obligations.
Article 38 establishes inspection obligations.
Article 39 establishes notification requirements.
Article 40 limits the seller’s ability to rely on certain notice failures where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
Article 44 provides limited relief in specified notice situations.
Articles 45–52 establish important buyer remedies.
Article 46 addresses performance, replacement, and repair.
Article 48 addresses seller cure rights.
Article 49 governs avoidance by the buyer.
Article 50 establishes price reduction.
Articles 74–77 regulate damages and mitigation.
Articles 81–84 address consequences of avoidance and restitution.
Where Turkish domestic sales law applies, Articles 219–231 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 establish important rules concerning defective goods.
Article 227 establishes specified buyer remedies.
Article 231 establishes important limitation rules.
Article 112 establishes the general framework for liability arising from improper performance.
Articles 139 and following regulate set-off.
Article 116 establishes important rules concerning responsibility for auxiliary persons.
Article 23 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 may establish additional inspection and notification obligations for commercial sales between merchants.
The Turkish Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 establishes important rules concerning documentary evidence, expert examination, interim judicial protection, and evidence preservation.
Articles 219 and following concern documentary evidence.
Articles 389 and following regulate interim injunctions.
Articles 400–405 regulate evidence preservation.
The Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 establishes relevant enforcement and precautionary attachment mechanisms.
Law No. 5718 establishes important rules concerning international jurisdiction, applicable law, and enforcement of foreign judgments.
The Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 may become relevant where the supplier’s conduct satisfies the elements of fraud, forgery, or another recognized offense.
The central legal distinction is whether the defect falls within a valid commercial warranty and whether the supplier is contractually or statutorily required to provide replacement rather than another remedy.
A commercial warranty does not automatically entitle the buyer to replacement in every case.
However, a Turkish supplier cannot disregard an enforceable warranty obligation merely because replacement is commercially inconvenient or expensive.
The available remedies depend on the contract, governing law, and actual circumstances.
A foreign buyer whose Turkish supplier refuses warranty replacement should first identify the governing law.
The buyer should determine whether the CISG applies or whether the parties validly excluded it.
The next question is whether the commercial warranty establishes an enforceable replacement obligation.
The buyer should preserve the supply agreement, warranty certificate, purchase order, and relevant correspondence.
The exact warranty duration and covered defects should be identified.
The buyer should then establish whether the products are defective.
For example, independent laboratory testing or technical expert examination may be necessary.
The date of delivery, defect discovery, notification, and replacement request should be documented.
Under the CISG, Articles 38 and 39 may be particularly important.
Where the warranty provides a longer guarantee period, the interaction with Article 39(2) should be examined.
The buyer should identify the supplier’s stated reason for refusal.
For example, the manufacturer may allege misuse, improper storage, or expired coverage.
The relevant technical evidence should be preserved.
The buyer should then identify the appropriate remedy.
Where the warranty expressly requires replacement, contractual enforcement may be available.
Where the defect constitutes a fundamental breach, replacement or avoidance under the CISG may require consideration.
Where repair is possible, the supplier’s cure rights may become relevant.
The buyer should calculate any financial losses, including repair costs, replacement purchases, customer refunds, storage expenses, recall costs, and lost profits.
The applicable damages framework must be examined.
Where the supplier refuses to cooperate, the buyer should assess the dispute resolution clause.
Commercial litigation, arbitration, interim judicial protection, or enforcement proceedings may be available.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya emphasizes that commercial warranty disputes require careful distinction between contractual replacement promises, statutory conformity remedies, defect notification deadlines, technical causation, damages, and cross-border enforcement.
Warranty replacement disputes may affect several legal interests simultaneously.
The contractual issue concerns the scope of the commercial warranty.
The technical issue concerns the nature and cause of the defect.
The procedural issue concerns inspection, notification, and warranty claim deadlines.
The commercial issue concerns repair, replacement, price reduction, and contract avoidance.
The financial issue concerns refunds, lost profits, customer compensation, and replacement expenses.
The transport issue concerns return shipping and replacement delivery.
The customs issue concerns importation and re-export of defective or replacement products.
The international issue concerns governing law, jurisdiction, arbitration, and enforcement.
These matters have different legal requirements.
A foreign buyer cannot automatically demand replacement of every defective product without examining the warranty and applicable law.
However, a Turkish supplier cannot assume that a commercial warranty is unenforceable merely because the goods were sold internationally.
A coordinated legal assessment may therefore be necessary to protect the buyer’s commercial and financial interests.
1. Can a Turkish supplier refuse to replace defective products under a commercial warranty?
Potentially, where a valid contractual or statutory defense exists. Unjustified refusal may constitute breach of contract.
2. Does a commercial warranty automatically give the buyer a replacement right?
No. The available remedy depends on the warranty terms and applicable law.
3. Can the buyer demand replacement under Article 46 of the CISG?
Potentially. Article 46(2) permits replacement where the lack of conformity constitutes a fundamental breach and the relevant requirements are satisfied.
4. Can a contractual warranty provide broader replacement rights than the CISG?
Potentially. The parties may agree on additional replacement obligations under the applicable legal framework.
5. Can the buyer demand replacement after failed repairs?
Potentially. The answer depends on the warranty, seriousness of the defect, and applicable law.
6. Can the buyer recover the purchase price?
Potentially. Valid avoidance may create restitution rights under Articles 81–84 of the CISG.
7. Can the buyer recover repair and replacement costs?
Potentially. The buyer must establish the relevant loss, causal connection, and applicable legal requirements.
8. Can the buyer recover lost profits?
Potentially. Article 74 of the CISG permits recovery of qualifying lost profits, subject to the statutory requirements.
9. Can a foreign buyer sue the Turkish supplier in Turkey?
Potentially. The competent forum depends on the contract, jurisdiction rules, and any valid arbitration agreement.
10. Can a foreign buyer pursue the dispute without traveling to Turkey?
Yes. A foreign buyer may appoint a Turkish lawyer to assist with commercial proceedings, subject to applicable authorization and procedural requirements.
Protecting international supply contracts, commercial warranties and buyer rights requires timely and specialized legal assistance.
Foreign companies whose Turkish suppliers refuse to replace defective products under commercial warranties may face serious risks involving failed machinery, defective components, rejected products, customer complaints, product recalls, replacement purchases, and substantial financial losses.
Working with a lawyer experienced in Turkish commercial law, international sales contracts, the CISG, commercial warranty enforcement, defective goods litigation, arbitration, and foreign buyer protection can help clarify the applicable legal framework and identify appropriate remedies.
Serving clients throughout Turkey and internationally, Fırat Fesih Kaya Law Office provides professional legal support in commercial warranty disputes, replacement product claims, defective goods litigation, international supply contract enforcement, advance payment recovery, compensation claims, evidence preservation, precautionary attachment, arbitration, and enforcement proceedings against Turkish suppliers.
Lawyer Fırat Fesih Kaya assists foreign buyers, international distributors, importers, manufacturers, wholesalers, retailers, and overseas businesses facing warranty replacement refusal or contractual nonperformance by Turkish suppliers.
Call Now: +90 312 434 22 22
WhatsApp: +90 532 769 22 22
Email: info@firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Website: https://www.firatfesihkaya.av.tr
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only. To avoid any loss of legal rights, we recommend consulting your lawyer regarding the specific circumstances of your case.